Menu Expand
A Fragmented Landscape

A Fragmented Landscape

Silvia De Zordo | Joanna Mishtal | Lorena Anton

(2016)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Since World War II, abortion policies have remained remarkably varied across European nations, with struggles over abortion rights at the forefront of national politics. This volume analyses European abortion governance and explores how social movements, political groups, and individuals use protests and resistance to influence abortion policy. Drawing on case studies from Italy, Spain, Norway, Poland, Romania, Russia, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the European Union, it analyses the strategies and discourses of groups seeking to liberalise or restrict reproductive rights. It also illuminates the ways that reproductive rights politics intersect with demographic anxieties, as well as the rising nationalisms and xenophobia related to austerity policies, mass migration and the recent terrorist attacks in Europe. 


“This edited volume does not only offer gender historians a rich source, but should also be of interest to historians of social movements and legal historians who have to face the fact that an expected process like ‘liberalization’ is created by economic and material factors as well as subterranean techniques of subjectivization and does not reveal any direction but presents a constellation that can switch position any time.” · H-Soz-Kult

“This is an extremely important contribution to the literature on the policies and politics surrounding reproductive rights. It covers a range of historical developments and national contexts while developing multiple overarching themes in an accessible manner.” · Jennifer Merchant, Université Paris II


Silvia De Zordo is a Senior Researcher at the University of Barcelona (UB), Department of Anthropology. Her research interests encompass contraception, abortion and conscientious objection in Latin America and Europe. She has recently been awarded an ERC Starting Grant to study the impact on women of barriers to legal abortion in Europe. Her recent publications include Reproduction and Biopolitics: Ethnographies of Governance, "Irrationality" and Resistance (ed. with Milena Marchesi), published by Routledge in 2014.


Joanna Mishtal is an Associate Professor of Anthropology at the University of Central Florida. Her research examines reproductive rights, health, and policies in Poland, and in the context of EU governance. Her ethnography The Politics of Morality: The Church, the State and Reproductive Rights in Postsocialist Poland (2015) received the Adele E. Clarke Book Award in 2017.


Lorena Anton is a Marie Curie Fellow in social anthropology at the University of Bucharest (2013-2017), where she develops a project on abortion governance in post-communist Romania. Recent publications include ‘On n'en parlera jamais de tout ça! Ethnographier la mémoire de l’avortement en Roumanie de Ceaușescu’, in Ethnologie Française (2014) and the ‘Cultural Memory’ entry in Protest Cultures: A Companion (eds. Fahlenbrach et al., Berghahn Books).

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
A Fragmented Landscape - Abortion Governance and Protest Logics in Europe - Edited by Silvia De Zordo, Joanna Mishtaland Lorena Anton iii
Copyright Page iv
Contents v
Introduction by Silvia De Zordo, Joanna Mishtal, Lorena Anton 1
Part I - Pro-abortion Rights Activism, Movements, Strategies, and Protest Logics 21
Chapter 1 - Legal and Political Discourses on Women’s Right to Abortion by Christina Zampas 23
Chapter 2 - Freeing Abortion in Sweden by Annulla Linders and Danielle Bessett 46
Chapter 3 - Women’s Liberation and the ‘Right to Choose’ - Struggling for Abortion in the United Kingdom and Switzerland by Kristina Schulz and Leena Schmitter 66
Part II - Anti-abortion Rights Activism, Movements, Strategies, and Protest Logics 83
Chapter 4 - Contesting Abortion Rights in Contemporary Italy - Discourses and Practices of Pro-life Activism by Claudia Mattalucci 85
Chapter 5 - Innocence and Demographic Crisis - Transposing Post-abortion Syndrome into a Russian Orthodox Key by Sonja Luehrmann 103
Chapter 6 - Still a Woman’s Right? - Feminist and Other Discourses in Belgium’s Abortion Struggles by Karen Celis and Gily Coene 123
Part III - Health Professionals’/Providers’ Involvement in the Pro- or Anti-abortion Rights Debateand Access to Services 145
Chapter 7 - ‘Good Doctors Do Not Object’ - Obstetricians-Gynaecologists’ Perspectives on Conscientious Objection to Abortion Care and their Engagement with Pro-abortion Rights Protests in Italy by Silvia De Zordo 147
Chapter 8 - Women Rights or ‘Unborn’ Rights? - Laws and Loopholes in Madrid’s Public Healthcare Services’ Abortion Provision to Migrant Women by Beatriz Aragón Martín 169
Chapter 9 - One Step Forward and Two Steps Back - Accessing Abortion in Norway by Mette Løkeland 187
Part IV - Pronatalism, Nationalism, and Resistance in Abortion Politics and Access to Abortion Services 207
Chapter 10 - For the Good of the Nation - Pronatalism and Abortion Ban during Ceauşescu’s Romania by Lorena Anton 209
Chapter 11 - Quietly ‘Beating the System’ - The Logics of Protest and Resistance under the Polish Abortion Ban by Joanna Mishtal 226
Chapter 12 - Abortion Governance in the New Northern Ireland by Robin Whitaker and Goretti Horgan 245
Afterword - Reproductive Governance meets European Abortion Politics - The Challenge of Getting the Gaze Right by Lynn M. Morgan 266
Acknowledgements 283
Index 285