Menu Expand
Applied Paramedic Law and Ethics

Applied Paramedic Law and Ethics

Ruth Townsend | Morgan Luck

(2012)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

A fundamental local law text for undergraduate paramedics in Australia and New Zealand.

Applied Paramedic Law and Ethics Australia and New Zealand is the first of its kind to bring together legal and ethical concepts specifically for the Australian and New Zealand paramedic profession.

An indispensable guide for student paramedics, Applied Paramedic Law and Ethics Australia and New Zealand promotes the understanding of ethical principles and legal regulations through realistic scenarios and extensive case studies, which are available both in the book and on Elsevier’s Evolve platform.

The book includes Australian state-specific legislation and local case law, and there is a chapter devoted specifically to the New Zealand paramedic service.

This excellent law textbook focuses on the essential concepts and skills local paramedics need to respond to life-threatening emergencies in often-unfamiliar environments. For paramedics to determine the best course of action in any situation they need an intimate understanding of the profession’s code of conduct and current legal regulations. In its attention to key areas such as consent, negligence, child protection, mental health and record-keeping Applied Paramedic Law and Ethics Australia and New Zealand proves a fundamental resource for the undergraduate paramedic course in Australia and New Zealand.

The textbook’s 13 comprehensive chapters are written in a clear, engaging style ideal for undergraduate paramedic students as well as ambulance service volunteers and practicing paramedics.

  • Over 60 paramedic-specific scenarios
  • Relevant case law discussed
  • Suitable for the undergraduate course in Paramedic Law and Ethics
  • Provides a clear ethical decision-making model for paramedics Key supporting features available on the Evolve platform:
  • Multiple choice, short answer and essay questions
  • Case studies
  • Image collection
  • Additional instructor resources including PowerPoints and further case studies

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Front cover cover
Evolve splash page fm_2
Applied Paramedic Law and Ethics i
Copyright page iv
Table of Contents v
Acknowledgements vi
Foreword vii
Contributors ix
Reviewers xi
1 Why introduce paramedics to law, ethics and professionalism? 1
Learning objectives 1
Introduction 2
Conclusion 6
Review questions 6
Endnotes 6
2 An introduction to ethics for paramedics 8
Learning objectives 8
Introduction 9
What is ethics? And what isn’t it? 9
Misunderstanding: ‘Acting ethically just means helping people’ 10
Misunderstanding: ‘Acting ethically just means following the law’ 11
Misunderstanding: ‘Acting ethically is only something to worry about in difficult cases’ 12
Misunderstanding: ‘Acting ethically is about avoiding moral dilemmas’ 13
Misunderstanding: ‘Acting ethically is relative’ 15
The three main ethical theories 17
Consequentialist ethics 18
Objection: Does consequentialist ethics demand too much from us? 19
Objection: Should we always try to maximise happiness? 20
Deontological ethics 21
Objection: Is deontological ethics too rigid? 22
Virtue ethics 23
Objection: What do we do in the meantime? 24
The four principles of bioethics 25
What is the principle of autonomy? 26
What is the principle of non-maleficence? 27
What is the principle of beneficence? 27
What is the principle of justice? 28
Applying the four principles 29
Conclusion 31
Review questions 32
Endnotes 32
3 PRECARE – an ethical decision-making model for paramedics 33
Learning objectives 33
Introduction 34
The PRECARE decision-making model 34
Problem 35
Reconnaissance 36
Ethics 37
Code 39
Alternative 40
Regulations 41
Evaluate 43
Conclusion 45
Review questions 46
Endnotes 47
4 The ethical governance of paramedic practice 48
Learning objectives 48
Introduction 49
Codes of conduct 49
Governance 50
How ethical governance is distinguished from morality and legal governance 51
Principles and the role of moral principles in ethical governance 55
Paramedics and public sector ethics codes 56
The principles stated in codes covering paramedics 56
SA Ambulance Service Code of Ethics and Conduct 2010 56
Ambulance Service of NSW Code of Conduct 2006 56
Queensland Public Service Code of Conduct 2010 57
Code of Conduct for Victorian Public Sector Employees (No. 1) 2007 57
St John Ambulance WA Motto, Mission and Values 57
Ambulance Tasmania 57
ACT Public Service Code of Ethics 58
Paramedics Australasia Code of Conduct 59
Code of Conduct for ambulance officers in New Zealand 60
Observations on values and principles in codes 60
Applying the code principles to practice 61
Confidential information 62
Conclusion 65
Review questions 66
Endnotes 66
5 An introduction to the legal system and paramedic professionalism 67
Learning objectives 67
Introduction 68
What is the law? 69
Legal philosophy 69
How is the law made? 71
An Act of Parliament 72
Difference between an Act and a Regulation 72
Precedent 73
Different types of law 74
Criminal law 74
Civil law 75
Torts 76
Administrative law 76
Customary laws 76
Human rights laws 77
International law 78
The structure of the court system 78
Tribunals 79
How to read law 80
Where do paramedics fit in the legal system? 81
What are ambulance services? 81
Who can provide those services? 81
Who can legally use the title ‘paramedic’? 81
What about paramedic registration? 82
Paramedics as professionals 82
Can paramedics still be called to court to justify their actions? 84
What about professional disciplinary action against paramedics? 84
Conclusion 86
Review questions 86
Endnotes 90
6 Consent and refusal of treatment 92
Learning objectives 92
Introduction 93
Consent 94
Forms of consent 94
Implied consent 94
Verbal consent 95
Written consent 95
Elements of a valid consent 95
Voluntary decision 95
Informed consent 97
Consent covers the treatment 98
Capacity 98
Circumstances where consent is not required 98
Emergencies 98
Non-emergencies 99
Refusal of treatment 102
Informed choice 102
Voluntary decision 103
Specific to the situation 103
Capacity 103
Presumption of capacity 104
Factors that can reduce capacity 104
Assessment of capacity 104
Sufficient understanding 106
Outcome of the assessment 106
Substitute decision making 107
How is a substitute decision maker appointed? 108
Terms to describe a substitute decision maker 109
When can a substitute decision maker make decisions for a patient? 109
What decisions can a substitute decision maker make? 109
Consent and children 109
Who is a child? 112
Who is authorised to provide consent on behalf of a child? 114
Can someone other than the parents provide consent? 114
Can a parent refuse to provide consent to treatment for their child? 115
Can a child provide consent for their own treatment? 116
What is the test to determine if a child has capacity to consent to treatment? 117
Can a child refuse treatment? 119
Conclusion 121
Review questions 121
Endnotes 121
7 The tort of negligence, standards of care and vicarious liability 130
Learning objectives 130
Introduction 131
What is a tort? 131
What is negligence? 132
What is a duty of care? 133
What are the standard of care and the assessments that identify a breach of duty of care? 134
The giving of information and the standard of care 135
What is damage? 137
What is causation and what is remoteness? 137
What is vicarious liability? 138
Is there a duty to rescue and where do the obligations of the off-duty paramedic lie? 139
Good Samaritans 140
Intoxicated patients 140
Defences to a negligence claim – contributory negligence and the voluntary assumption of risk 141
Negligence case study 1 142
The initial finding by the lower court 144
The finding by the NSW Court of Appeal 144
Was the paramedic negligent? 144
Conclusion as to the paramedic’s negligence 146
Was the Ambulance Service negligent in relation to the protocols? 146
Conclusion as to the negligence of the Ambulance Service 146
Comments on the case 147
Negligence case study 2 147
The negligence of the paramedics 148
Conclusion as to the paramedic’s negligence 149
Comments on the District Court judgement 149
The appeal to the NSW Supreme Court of Appeal 149
A hypothetical negligence case 151
8 End-of-life care 157
Learning objectives 157
Introduction 159
Background 159
Advance care directives 161
Competence 162
Directive made voluntarily 162
Liability of staff 163
Clinical practice guidelines 164
Lack of capacity and surrogate decision makers 165
What happens if there is no ‘default decision maker’ appointed? 165
What is the difference between passive euthanasia and withdrawing treatment and voluntary euthanasia aiding and abetting a suicide and involuntary euthanasia, and why should paramedics know it? 167
Pain relief and hastening death 167
Mercy killing 168
Aid, abet, assist suicide 169
Futile treatment 170
What is the definition of death and what happens to a dead body? 171
End-of-life decision making and the freedom to choose – food for thought 172
Conclusion 172
Review questions 173
Endnotes 182
9 An introduction to child protection and mandatory reporting 186
Learning objectives 186
Introduction 188
Child protection: an overview 188
Who is responsible for child protection? 189
Why just focus on child protection and not other vulnerable members of society? 191
History of child protection 191
Identifying child abuse 192
The role of the paramedic 193
Types of abuse 194
Physical abuse 195
Sexual abuse 195
Emotional/psychological abuse 197
Neglect 199
Fabricated or induced illness by carers (FII) 200
Cultural issues related to child protection 201
Legal and other issues concerning child protection intervention 203
The threshold for child protection intervention 204
Rule of optimism and child abuse 204
Mandatory reporting 205
Reporting suspected cases of child abuse 206
Right to privacy versus state intervention 207
Conclusion 207
Review questions 208
Endnotes 221
10 The mental health patient in the pre-hospital emergency care setting 225
Learning objectives 225
Introduction 226
What is mental illness? 226
Contemporary principles and frameworks for mental health care 228
The nature and challenges of mental illness in paramedic work 229
Ethical and practical challenges of emergency mental health care 230
Paramedics and people with mental illness: assessment and treatment 231
The role of paramedics and models for practice 231
Protecting and transporting patients – orders for involuntary assessment 234
Practice tips 237
Conclusion 238
Review questions 239
Endnotes 245
11 Employment and industrial law in paramedic practice 250
Learning objectives 250
Introduction 251
What laws relating to the workplace apply to paramedics in Australia and New Zealand? 252
What is an employment contract? 252
Express and implied terms 253
Who is an employee? 253
Vicarious liability 254
What are an enterprise agreement and enterprise bargaining? 254
Doctrine of privity of contract 254
Greenfield agreements 255
Hours of work 257
What is workers compensation? 258
Termination of contract and dismissal 258
What is occupational health and safety? 260
What should I do if I assess that a workplace is unsafe? 265
The shootings at Highmoor Cross 267
What is discrimination? 267
Unlawful discrimination 269
What are bullying and harassment? 269
What happens if I am threatened at work? 270
What is meant by workplace culture? 271
Conclusion 272
Review questions 273
Endnotes 277
12 Record keeping and the patient health care record 280
Learning objectives 280
Introduction 281
What is a patient health care record? 282
Electronic records 283
Record ownership 284
Confidentiality and privacy 285
Access to medical records 285
Patient access to their own records 286
Who else can gain access to records? 288
Content of a record 289
Patient identification 292
Critical information 292
Important and relevant information 292
Presenting problem, conditions, provisional diagnosis 292
History and assessment findings 293
Current medications and other conditions 293
Treatment given and medications administered 293
Other considerations 293
Correction of errors 294
Conclusion 295
Review questions 296
Endnotes 298
13 The use of drugs in pre-hospital care 299
Learning objectives 299
Introduction 300
The governance of drugs 300
What are the ‘schedules’ of drugs? 300
Who may possess and supply certain drugs? 300
Storage and recording of drugs 304
What are the issues to consider with ‘drug substitution’? 304
What happens if I don’t use all of the schedule 8 drug? 305
What happens if I notice a discrepancy? 305
What if my patient is drug dependent? 305
Prescribing 305
Medication errors 306
Safety and medication administration 307
The five rights of drug administration 307
Assessment and documentation of drug administration 308
What happens if I give a drug in error? 309
Conclusion 309
Review questions 310
Endnotes 310
14 Paramedic practice in New Zealand – legal issues and current debates 312
Learning objectives 312
Introduction 313
The history of New Zealand paramedics and ambulance services 314
New Zealand ambulance funding 314
A volunteer workforce 314
New Zealand’s medico–legal landscape 315
No-fault compensation 315
‘Treatment injury’ under the Accident Compensation Act 2001 and paramedics 316
Health and Disability Commissioner Act 1994 317
Code of Health and Disability Services’ Consumers Rights 318
The registration debate 323
Conclusion 325
Review questions 326
Endnotes 328
Glossary 331
Index 335
A 335
B 336
C 336
D 339
E 340
F 340
G 341
H 341
I 342
J 342
K 342
L 342
M 343
N 344
O 344
P 344
Q 346
R 346
S 347
T 347
U 348
V 348
W 348
Y 348