Menu Expand
Critical Psychiatry

Critical Psychiatry

Ian Cummins

(2017)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Critical Psychiatry outlines the history of a group of thinkers that has come to be known as the anti-psychiatry movement. Though it has been called a movement, the individual thinkers’ and authors’ ideas were often in conflict but what they share is a critical perspective on psychiatry as a discipline and institutionalised modes of care. 

The current crisis in mental health services means that it is time to examine once again the key themes of critical psychiatry. The excesses of the 1960s radicalism have meant that these themes - with an emphasis on the individual dignity of all those involved in mental health services - have been lost.  These need to be rediscovered as part of a solution to current difficulties but also as the starting point for a new model of service provision. 

Critical Psychiatry is a history of ideas. It provides a critical evaluation of key thinkers and the application of their work to contemporary mental health service settings. 


Ian Cummins is senior lecturer in social work at the University of Salford. His main research revolves around the experiences of people with mental health problems in the Criminal Justice system with a focus on policing and mental illness. This is linked to an exploration of the development of the penal state and its interaction with community based mental health services. He is interested in the ways the CJS has become, in many incidences, the default provider of mental health care


Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover 1
Half-title i
Series page ii
Title page iii
Copyright information iv
Dedication page v
Table of Contents vii
Meet the author ix
Acknowledgements xi
Introduction 1
Critical psychiatry Or anti-psychiatry 1
Psychiatry and the counterculture 2
1 R D Laing: the psychiatrist of the counterculture 5
Glasgow 6
Major works 6
The rumpus room and the establishment of Kingsley Hall 7
Kingsley Hall 9
Laing, the family and madness 9
Mental illness as a journey 10
Mad to be normal? 11
2 Michel Foucault 15
Madness and Civilization 16
Responses to Foucault 19
The continuing importance of Foucault 21
Conclusion 22
3 Erving Goffman: madness, and the asylum as a total institution 25
Stigma 26
The Insanity of Place 26
Asylums 26
Total institutions 27
Institutionalisation 28
Identity and the loss of self 30
Goffman’s legacy 31
4 Frantz Fanon: Black Minds Matter – race, psychiatry and revolutionary politics 33
Key works 34
Othering 34
Race, racism and mental health services 36
Conclusion 40
5 Thomas Szasz: a libertarian challenge to the ‘therapeutic state’ 43
The Myth of Mental Illness 44
The therapeutic state, consent and coercion 45
Discussion 49
6 Franco Basaglia: psychiatry as radical politics 53
Gramsci 54
The radical politics of 1968 54
Basaglia in Gorizia 55
Basgalia’s Law or Law 180 56
Critical perspectives on Basaglia’s work 56
Basaglia and contemporary mental health services 58
Conclusion 59
7 David Rosenhan: an experiment revisited 61
The Rosenhan experiment 61
Rosenhan’s main conclusions 63
Critical responses to Rosenhan 64
Discussion 65
Conclusion 67
8 Plath, Frame and Kesey: psychiatry and the literary imagination 69
The Bell Jar 70
The novels of Janet Frame 71
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest 72
Psychiatry, ECT and representation 73
Conclusion 73
Conclusion 77
Community care 79
Recovery 80
Conclusion 82
Bibliography 83
Index 93