Menu Expand
Elliott & Quinn's Criminal Law

Elliott & Quinn's Criminal Law

Louise Taylor

(2018)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

 

Elliott & Quinn’s Criminal Law has been specifically designed to introduce you to the legal principles, cases and statutes at play in this core subject area. Areas of debate, critique of the current law and consideration of reform options are also included throughout making this an ideal text for LLB or GDL who want an accessible and engaging introduction to criminal law.

 

This new edition has been fully updated with all the latest legal developments in the area, including:

 

·    A substantially revised chapter 11 on accomplice liability which has been reworked to reflect the change to the law brought about by R v Jogee and Ruddock (2016);

·    Extensively updated coverage of voluntary manslaughter to reflect decision made in R v Gurpinar (2015), R v Golds (2016), R v Wilcocks (2016) and R v Meanza (2017); and

·    Discussion of the case of R (on the application of Collins) v Secretary of State for Justice (2016) in the context of the householder’s defence in self-defence.

 


Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Front Cover Front Cover
Title Page iii
Copyright Page iv
Brief Contents vii
Contents ix
Preface xix
Table of cases xx
Table of statutes xxvii
Table of treaties xxix
Introduction 1
Introduction 2
How much crime is there? 2
Awareness of crime 2
Reporting crime 3
Recording crime 4
White‐collar and corporate crime 5
Statistics and conclusions 6
Sources of criminal law 8
European criminal law 8
European Convention on Human Rights 9
Fair labelling 9
Codification of the criminal law 9
Summary 11
Reading list 12
Chapter 1 Elements of a crime 13
Introduction 14
Actus reus 14
Conduct must be voluntary 14
Types of actus reus 15
Causation 15
Omissions 16
Mens rea 22
Intention 23
Recklessness 23
Negligence 28
Transferred malice 29
Coincidence of actus reus and mens rea 30
Mens rea and motive 31
Proof of mens rea 31
Problems with the law on mens rea 31
Subjective principles in criminal law 33
Answering questions 34
Summary 35
Reading list 37
Chapter 2 Strict liability 38
Introduction 39
Which crimes are crimes of strict liability? 39
Regulatory offence 40
Issue of social concern 41
The wording of the Act 43
The smallness of the penalty 44
Relevance of the four factors 45
Crimes of negligence 46
The effect of mistake 46
The European Convention on Human Rights 46
Arguments in favour of strict liability 46
Promotion of care 46
Deterrent value 47
Easier enforcement 47
Difficulty of proving mens rea 47
No threat to liberty 47
Profit from risk 47
Arguments against strict liability 47
Injustice 47
Ineffective 48
Little administrative advantage 49
Inconsistent application 49
Better alternatives are available 50
Reform 50
Restrict the use of strict liability 50
Defence of all due diligence 50
Extending strict liability 51
Answering questions 51
Summary 52
Reading list 53
Chapter 3 Murder 54
Introduction 55
The common elements of homicide offences 55
A human being 55
Causation 56
Murder 61
Definition 62
Mens rea 62
Sentence 69
Criticism 70
Proposals for reform 71
Answering questions 75
Summary 76
Reading list 77
Chapter 4 Voluntary manslaughter 79
Introduction 80
Loss of control 80
1. Loss of self‐control 82
2. Resulting from a qualifying trigger 82
3. The objective test 88
Burden of proof 90
Criticism 90
Diminished responsibility 93
An abnormality of mental functioning 94
Burden of proof 98
Criticism 99
Suicide pacts 103
Answering questions 103
Summary 105
Reading list 106
Chapter 5 Involuntary manslaughter 108
Introduction 109
Manslaughter by an unlawful and dangerous act 109
Actus reus 109
Mens rea 116
Criticism 117
Gross negligence manslaughter 117
Criticism 123
Subjective reckless manslaughter? 125
Causing death by dangerous driving 127
Sentence 128
Causing death by careless driving under the influence of drink or drugs 128
Road Safety Act 2006 129
Criticism 130
Causing or allowing the death of a child or vulnerable adult 132
Criticism of the law 134
Difficulties with causation 134
Reform of involuntary manslaughter 138
Home Office proposals 138
Answering questions 141
Summary 146
Reading list 147
Chapter 6 Non‐fatal offences against the person 150
Introduction 151
Assault 151
Actus reus 151
Mens rea 154
Battery 154
Actus reus 154
Mens rea 155
Offences Against the Person Act 1861, s. 47 155
Actus reus 155
Mens rea 157
Offences Against the Person Act 1861, s. 20 158
Actus reus 158
Mens rea 160
Offences Against the Person Act 1861, s. 18 161
Actus reus 162
Mens rea 162
Causing serious injury by dangerous driving 162
Problems with offences against the person 163
Domestic violence and abuse 163
Definitions of the offences 167
Structure of the offences 168
Reform 168
Modernising the legislation 168
Stalking 170
Harassment 171
Stalking 171
Aggravated harassment 172
Aggravated stalking 172
Crimes using the internet 173
Answering questions 174
Summary 177
Reading list 179
Chapter 7 Sexual offences (by Samantha Pegg) 181
Introduction 182
Rape 182
Actus reus 182
The defendant 182
The victim 183
Sexual intercourse 183
Absence of victim’s consent 184
Mens rea 188
Burden of proof 189
Only reasonable mistakes negative mens rea 193
Sentence 194
Assault by penetration 194
Actus reus 194
Mens rea 195
Sentence 196
Sexual assault 196
Actus reus 196
Mens rea 197
Sentence 197
Causing sexual activity without consent 197
Actus reus 197
Mens rea 198
Sentence 198
Criticisms of consent 198
Sexual offences against children under 13 199
Sentences 201
Sexual offences against children aged 13 to 16 201
Sentences 203
Child sex offences committed by children and young persons 204
Conviction rates 204
The victim’s sexual history 206
Anonymity of suspects 209
Rape myths and social attitudes 209
The trial 210
Sentencing 211
The Sex Offenders Register 211
Answering questions 212
Summary 213
Reading list 215
Chapter 8 Non‐fraudulent property offences 218
Introduction 219
Theft 219
Actus reus 219
Mens rea 231
Sentence 235
Robbery 235
Actus reus 235
Mens rea 237
Completion of the offence 237
Sentence 237
Burglary 239
Burglary under s. 9(1)(a) 239
Burglary under s. 9(1)(b) 242
Sentence 242
Aggravated burglary 243
Actus reus 244
Mens rea 244
Sentence 245
Squatting in a residential building 245
Blackmail 246
Actus reus 246
Mens rea 246
Chapter 9 Fraudulent property offences 258
Introduction 259
Problems with the pre‐2007 fraud offences 259
Complex and confused 259
Fraudsters could avoid liability 259
Poor prosecuting decisions 260
Jury discretion 260
Civil law concepts 260
Breadth of the criminal law 260
Conspiracy to defraud 260
Codification 261
Reform process 261
Fraud offences today 261
General offence of fraud 262
Obtaining services dishonestly 267
Additional related offences 268
Making off without payment 269
Criticism of the Fraud Act 2006 271
Answering questions 273
Summary 277
Reading list 278
Chapter 10 Inchoate offences 280
Introduction 281
Attempt 281
Actus reus 282
Mens rea 284
Offences which may not be attempted 285
Sentence 286
Criticism and reform 286
Conspiracy 288
Statutory conspiracy 289
Common law conspiracy 293
Criticism and reform 297
Assisting or encouraging a crime 298
Actus reus 299
Mens rea 300
Defence 301
Sentence 302
Criticism 302
Reform 302
Answering questions 303
Summary 305
Reading list 306
Chapter 11 Accomplices 308
Introduction 309
The principal offender 309
Innocent agents 309
Secondary parties 310
Actus reus 311
Mens rea 317
Liability of a secondary party for a different offence 324
Strict liability offences 324
Withdrawal 326
Criticism 328
The breadth and complexity of joint enterprise liability 328
Joint enterprise and secondary party liability 329
Sentencing 330
Reform 330
Depraved heart murder 330
Answering questions 331
Summary 333
Reading list 334
Chapter 12 Corporate liability 336
Introduction 337
Vicarious liability 337
The doctrine of identification 338
Corporate manslaughter 340
Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007 342
Criticism 344
Individual liability 344
The senior management test 345
Punishment 346
Lack of deterrence 347
Reform 347
The Law Commission 347
Civil liability 348
Alternative punishments 348
Answering questions 348
Summary 349
Reading list 350
Chapter 13 General defences 351
Introduction 352
Complete and partial defences 352
General and specific defences 352
The burden of proof 352
Infancy 352
Criticism 354
Insanity 355
The M’Naghten rules 356
Criticism 360
Proposals for reform 362
Automatism 364
Involuntary act 364
External cause 365
Self‐induced automatism 366
Criticism 366
Reform 368
Mistake 368
Mistake and mens rea 368
An honest mistake 369
Mistake and other defences 369
Intoxication 369
Absence of mens rea 370
Specific and basic intent crimes 371
Involuntary intoxication 373
Dutch courage’ 374
Intoxication and automatism 374
Mistake and intoxication 374
Criticism 375
Reform 377
Self‐defence, defence of property and public defence 378
Public defence 380
Self‐defence 380
Protection of property 381
Necessity for action 381
Reasonable force: the ordinary rule 385
Mistake as to the degree of force 385
Criticism 388
Duress 390
Duress by threats 391
Two‐part test 391
Duress of circumstances 396
Criticism 397
Reform 400
Necessity 401
Necessity and murder 404
Should there be a general defence of necessity? 405
Reform 407
Consent 408
An informed consent 408
Consent obtained by fraud 409
A genuine consent 410
Capacity to consent 410
The nature and degree of harm 411
Euthanasia 411
Exceptions 412
Criticism 417
Sexual relations 417
Serious injury and consent 418
Consent and euthanasia 418
Lawful chastisement 419
Criticism 420
Answering questions 420
Summary 424
Reading list 427
Appendix: Answering examination questions 430
Essay questions 431
Problem questions 433
Select bibliography 436
Glossary 449
Index 456
Back Cover Back Cover