Menu Expand
Environmental Problem-Solving  A Video-Enhanced Self-Instructional e-Book from MIT

Environmental Problem-Solving A Video-Enhanced Self-Instructional e-Book from MIT

Lawrence Susskind | Bruno Verdini | Jessica Gordon | Yasmin Zaerpoor

(2017)

Abstract

The ‘Environmental Problem-Solving - A Video-Enhanced Self-Instructional e-Book from MIT’ e-book presents short-excerpts from carefully selected readings, expert commentaries on those readings, interactive assignments, short videos of the best MIT student responses to the assignments, exam questions with excellent student responses and additional video excerpts of MIT faculty discussing the four main elements of the curriculum: models of environmental policy-making; competing theories of environmental ethics; tools for environmental assessment and environmental decision-making; and techniques for public engagement and group decision-making. The e-book covers the material presented in the semester-long course required of all students enrolled in MIT’s Environmental Policy and Planning Specialization. It includes the actual assignments the MIT students are expected to complete each week as well as videos of the real-time oral presentations they are required to make to visiting practitioners. The final exam is accompanied by the best student answers. 


Dr. Lawrence Susskind is Ford Professor of Urban and Environmental Planning and Head of the Environmental Policy and Planning Group at MIT. One of the founders of the field of environmental dispute resolution, he has been teaching at MIT and Harvard for 45 years.

Dr. Bruno Verdini is Director of the MIT-Harvard Mexico Negotiation Program and Lecturer in Urban Planning and Negotiation at MIT. He teaches MIT’s popular course the ‘Art and Science of Negotiation’.

Jessica Gordon is completing a PhD in Environmental Policy and Planning at Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Gordon has worked on environmental issues including climate change, natural resource management and food security.

Yasmin Zaerpoor is a doctoral candidate in Environmental Policy and Planning within the Department of Urban Studies and Planning at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).


The book is divided into four sections: The first section focuses on how certain environmental problems can only be solved through active government effort to implement policies that effectively take science and politics into account. This section introduces readers to foundational concepts, including the steps in the US federal environmental policy-making process, and offers an action-oriented analysis of how environmental policy gets implemented and how practitioners can use comparative analysis of public policy in environmental problem-solving. It concludes with questions about the possibility of a unified theory of environmental policy making. The section empowers readers to develop, through exercises and videos, a solid framework to shape an action plan to solve specific environmental problems.

The next section focuses on formulating a sound philosophical basis for taking action in environmental problem solving situations. This includes a discussion of several ethical frameworks that practitioners can use to underpin the actions they propose. This section begins with a general overview of environmental ethics, and then moves on to a discussion of utilitarianism versus intrinsic value, deep green approaches to environmental problem-solving, the debate over sustainability versus economic growth, and how science and indigenous knowledge can be applied in a wide range of environmental problem-solving situations. The section, through exercises and videos, empowers readers to take a stand on these debates, drawing on practical cases with worked examples.

The penultimate section helps environmental practitioners understand how to use various analytical tools. It includes a quick survey of traditional and non-traditional evaluation tools, discussing the strengths and weaknesses of each tool, focusing on environmental impact assessment, cost benefit analysis, ecosystem services analysis, risk assessment, simulation and modeling, and scenario planning. The section, through interactive exercises and videos, empowers readers to practice multi-party environmental problem-solving, and to identify the power of each tool to enhance environmental problem-solving, developing the judgment to enumerate strengths and weaknesses as they see them playing out in practice.

The concluding section is a survey of the theory and practice behind mobilizing support for particular problem-solving ideas. It includes discussions of democratic decision-making and environmental problem solving, how the public can be brought in as a partner, methods of collaborative decision-making, the ideas of consensus building, and how politics and power sway collective action efforts. 


“This remarkable e-book contains everything you need to teach a rich, dynamic course on the practical and theoretical dimensions of environmental policy as well as to evaluate your students’ work. It integrates classic readings, commentaries, scenarios and assignments, along with videos of talks by faculty and presentations by students.”
—Judith E. Innes, Professor Emerita, Department of City and Regional Planning, University of California Berkeley, USA


“Developed in the classroom of MIT's Department of Urban Studies and Planning, the e-book is the long-awaited textbook for introductory environmental policy courses at both undergraduate and graduate levels. It includes a number of essential reading materials authored by leading scholars that will provide a framework for analyzing the substance and processes of environmental policy. It also comes with scenario-based exercises, suggested assignments, exam questions and even sample answers. It is a must-have volume for all instructors around the world.”
—Masahiro Matsuura, Professor, Meiji University, Graduate School of Governance Studies, Tokyo, Japan

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover 1
Front Matter i
Half title i
Title page iii
Copyright information iv
Table of contents v
Acknowledgments ix
Credits and Permissions xi
Chapters 1
Introduction 1
Scenarios and Videos 5
Section I Influencing the Environmental Policy-Making Process 7
Introduction 7
Readings and Commentaries 10
Steven Cohen—“‘Understanding Environmental Policy’ and ‘A Framework for Understanding the Environmental Policy Issue... 10
Michael Howlett, M. Ramesh and Anthony Perl— Studying Public Policy: PolicyCycles & Policy Subsystems 47
Lawrence Susskind—Local Planning: Contemporary Principles and Practice 84
Elinor Ostrom— The Future of the Commons: Beyond Market Failure andGovernment Regulations 92
Scenario: Policy Evaluation 103
Video: Student response to Policy Evaluation scenario 103
Scenario: Comparative Policy Analysis 104
Video: Student response to Comparative Policy Analysis scenario 104
Written Assignment 1: National Environmental Policy- Making 105
First student response to Assignment 1: National Environmental Policy- Making in theUnited Kingdom 106
Second student response to Assignment 1: A Model of Environmental Policy- Making inthe United States 110
Notes 45
Section II Ethical Dilemmas in Environmental Problem-Solving 115
Introduction 115
Readings and Commentaries 117
Joseph R. DesJardins—Environmental Ethics: An Introduction to Environmental Philosophy 117
Jason Corburn— Street Science: Community Knowledge and Environmental Health Justice 142
Scenario: The Precautionary Principle 159
Video Discussion: Dealing with Uncertainty 159
Scenario: Sustainability versus Economic Development 160
Video: Student response to Sustainability versus Economic Development scenario 160
Scenario: Local Knowledge versus Expert Knowledge 161
Video: Student response to Local Knowledge versus Expert Knowledge scenario 161
Written Assignment 2: Environmental Ethics 162
First student response to Assignment 2: Environmental Ethics and Sustainable Development 163
Second student response to Assignment 2: The Ethics of Sustainable Development 167
Notes 137
Section III Developments in Policy And Project Analysis 171
Introduction 171
Readings and Commentaries 175
Lawrence Susskind, Ravi K. Jain and Andrew... 175
Ciaran O’Faircheallaigh— Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 209
Arwin van Buuren and Sibout Nooteboom— Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 239
David Pearce, Giles Atkinson and Susana Mourato— Cost Benefit Analysis and theEnvironment: Recent Developments 258
Frank Ackerman and Lisa Heinzerling— University of Pennsylvania Law Review 285
Lawrence H. Goulder and Ian W. H. Parry— Economics of the Environment 312
Robert Costanza, Rudolf de Groot, Paul Sutton, Sander van der Ploeg,Sharolyn J. Anderson, Ida Kubiszewski, Stephen Farber and... 338
Donald Ludwig— Ecosystems 358
Howard Kunreuther and Paul Slovic— Annals of the American Academy of Politicaland Social Science 368
John Sterman— Managing a Nation: The Microcomputer Software Catalog 375
University of Washington Urban Ecology Research Lab, Puget Sound Future Scenarios vi
Scenario: Cost- Benefit Analysis 421
Video Discussion: Defining Gains and Losses 422
Role- Play Exercise: Negotiating Societal Risk Assessment 423
General Instructions 423
Confidential Instructions to the Head of the Dairy Cooperative 425
Video: Negotiating Societal Risk Assessment 426
Student Reflection: Negotiating Societal Risk Assessment 427
Written Assignment 3: Environmental Assessment 430
First student response to Assignment 3: Strengths, Weaknesses and Policy Implicationsof Environmental Analysis Tools 431
Second student response to Assignment 3: Environmental Management Can BeEnhanced through Analytical Tools 437
Section IV Collective Action to Solve Environmental Problems 443
Introduction 443
Readings and Commentaries 446
Lawrence Susskind and Jeffrey Cruikshank— “Convening,” “Assigning Roles and Responsibilities,.. 446
Ian Shapiro— State of Democratic Theory 460
Mark Sagoff— The Economy of the Earth: Philosophy, Law, and the Environment 481
Lynn A. Mandarano— Journal of Planning Education and Research 500
Lawrence Susskind and Connie Ozawa— Journal of Planning Education and Research 524
Eugene A. Rosa, Ortwin Renn and Aaron McCright— Risk Society Revisited: SocialTheory and Governance 547
Thomas C. Beierle— Public Participation in Environmental Decisions 566
Garrett Hardin— Science 597
Elinor Ostrom— Governing the Commons 611
Scenario: Public Participation Techniques and Strategies 638
Video: Student response to Public Participation Techniques and Strategies scenario 638
Scenario: Regional Consensus Building 639
Video: Student response to Regional Consensus Building scenario 639
Scenario: Environmental Dispute Resolution 640
Video: Student response to Environmental Dispute Resolution scenario 640
Written Assignment 4: Public Participation and Group Decision- Making 641
First student response to Assignment 4: Public Interest and the Consensus Building Approach 642
Second student response to Assignment 4: Democracy and Environmental Decision- Making 646
Final Exam 651
Questions 651
Sample Responses to Select Exam Questions 653
Conclusions 661
End Matter 665
Biographies 665
References 666
Index 669