Menu Expand
Land Dispossession and Everyday Politics in Rural Eastern India

Land Dispossession and Everyday Politics in Rural Eastern India

Kenneth Bo Nielsen

(2018)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Over the past decade India has witnessed a number of land wars that have centred crucially on the often forcible transfer of land from small farmers or indigenous groups to private companies. Among these, the land war that erupted in Singur, West Bengal, in 2006, went on to make national headlines and become paradigmatic of many of the challenges and social conflicts that arise when a state-led policy of swiftly transferring land to private sector companies encounters resistance on the ground. Land Dispossession and Everyday Politics in Rural Eastern India analyses the movement by Singur’s so-called unwilling farmers to retain and reclaim their farmland. By foregrounding the everyday politics of popular mobilization, the book sheds new light on the movement’s internal politics as well as on contentious issues rooted in everyday caste, class and gender relations.


‘Kenneth Bo Nielsen provides a close, careful analysis of the Singur story […]. For those who want to understand how land wars can make or break governments and the dominant models of economic growth that they promote, this book is highly recommended.’
—Amita Baviskar, Professor of Sociology, Institute of Economic Growth, Delhi, India


Kenneth Bo Nielsen is associate professor of South Asia Studies at the Department of Culture Studies and Oriental Languages, University of Oslo, Norway.


‘Land Dispossession and Everyday Politics in Rural Eastern India deals with […] the question of land in the agenda of collective politics. […] The book is enriched with the creative tension between the pulls of analysis flowing from political economy and those of an ethnographic understanding of politics.’
—Ranabir Samaddar, Director, Mahanirban Calcutta Research Group, Kolkata, India


Over the past decade India has witnessed a number of new land wars that have centred crucially on the often forcible transfer of land from small farmers or indigenous groups to private companies. Among these many localized and dispersed land conflicts, the land war that erupted in Singur, West Bengal, in 2006, went on to make national headlines and become paradigmatic of many of the challenges and social conflicts that arise when a state-led policy of swiftly transferring land to private sector companies encounters resistance on the ground.

‘Land Dispossession and Everyday Politics in Rural Eastern India’ is about the movement of Singur’s unwilling farmers to retain and reclaim their farmland. The book analyses the practical, representational and political work that the unwilling farmers engaged in as they have sought to mobilize public opinion; represent and justify their claims to land to a larger public; forge useful political alliances; engage and manoeuvre the legal system; navigate internal differences and discrepant interests; and simply keep the movement together on the ground. How did Singur’s unwilling farmers frame their movement to save the farmland? Which notions of development and justice did they draw on? How did they navigate everyday social cleavages and conflicts along the lines of caste, class and gender? Who led, who followed, and who was silenced? By engaging these questions through the prism of everyday politics, ‘Land Dispossession and Everyday Politics in Rural Eastern India’ makes an important empirical and ethnographic contribution to the still-limited anthropological understanding of the localized dynamics of India’s new land wars.


‘Nielsen’s work is both ambitious in scale and innovative in approach. …The book will offer new theoretical and methodological directions for scholars working not only on displacement-dispossession and land wars, but also for a wider audience interested in the development paradoxes of the global South.’
—Ritanjan Das (2019): Land Dispossession and Everyday Politics in Rural Eastern India, Forum for Development Studies, DOI: 10.1080/08039410.2019.1575006


‘Nielsen is also very good at depicting the complex ecology of political parties, non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and activists from whom the Singur farmers and workers took support, and the behind-the-scenes deliberations and negotiations this involved. … This is a must read for anyone interested in social movements and the politics of land and development in contemporary India.’
—Michael Levien (2019): Land Dispossession and Everyday Politics in Rural Eastern India, South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies, DOI:10.1080/00856401.2019.1557827


"Nielsen’s book gives a rich account of the internal dynamics and politics of a social movement revealing its ambivalences and ambiguities"
—Sirpa Tenhunen (2018): 'Land Dispossession and Everyday Politics in Rural Eastern India,' "Journal of Contemporary Asia," DOI: 10.1080/00472336.2018.1526961


‘Nielsen’s ethnographic analysis sheds light on the micro-politics of caste, class, gender and leadership that are all too often neglected in the studies of land protests.’
—Lucia Michelutti, Reader in Anthropology, University College London, UK

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover 1
Front Matter iii
Half title i
Title page iii
Copyright information iv
Table of contents v
List of tables vii
Acknowledgements ix
List of abbreviations xi
Chapter Int-Con 1
Introduction 1
The Political Economy of India’s New Land Wars 6
The SEZ Policy, Dispossession and Resistance 8
India’s Land Wars through the Prism of ‘Everyday Politics’ 10
The Chapters 14
Chapter One Situating Singur 17
The Trajectory of Singur and Its Politics 18
‘From Agriculture to Industry’ – Singur and LF Industrial Policy 22
Singur and Beraberi Shantipara, Late 2007 25
Chapter Two Land, Identity and The Politics of Representation 37
A Visit from Reuters, Shantipara, 26 February 2008 37
Unwilling Farmers and Their Land 43
Land as an Economic Asset 46
Land as a Sociopolitical and Symbolic Resource 49
Activists Representations: Peasant Utopia or Agro-incarceration? 53
Conclusion 58
Chapter Three Law, Judicialization and The Politics of Waiting 61
A Gram Baithak in Shantipara, Late November 2007 61
Law, Judicialization and Popular Politics 65
Mediation and the Law in Shantipara 68
Quasi-judicialization, Mimicry and the Everyday Politics of Judicialization 70
Accessing the High Court: The Everyday Politics of Waiting and Mediation 73
The Letter of the Law and the High Court Verdict 75
A SKJRC Meeting and a Gram Baithak, January 2008 78
Making the Law Redundant: Dejudicializing and Repoliticizing 79
Governing by Exception: The Singur Land Rehabilitation and Development Act 84
Conclusion 85
Chapter Four Class, Caste and Community 89
A Gram Baithak in Nadipara, February 2008 89
A Note on Caste and Class 91
The Everyday Politics of Caste and Class in Shantipara and Nadipara 93
Core-Periphery Organization: Chasi Leadership, Khet Majur Marginalization 100
The ‘Class Politics’ of Anti-dispossession Politics: Organizational Multiplication... 104
The Decline of the SABKMS 111
Conclusion: Caste, Class and Community in Anti-dispossession Politics 114
Chapter Five Gendered Mobilization: Women as Activists and Symbols 117
Getting Ready for the Rally, Shantipara, 2 December 2007 117
Women, Gender and Popular Politics 119
Finding the Time: Tanika’s Daily Routine and ‘Women’s Work’ 121
Spatial Movements and the Ideal of Domesticity 123
Seeing New Things, Meeting New People: Escaping Domesticity 127
Spreading the Message: Bijoya’s Trip to Delhi 129
‘Enchanted Moments’: Anti-dispossession Politics as a Feminist Pre-movement? 131
Sidelining Bauri Women 133
The Gendered Everyday Politics of Organization and Leadership 135
Women as Movement Symbols 137
Conclusion 144
Chapter Six Activist Leadership 147
Shahid Divas 147
Preparing for and Hosting the Shahid Divas 150
Everyday Leadership 154
Conclusion 162
Chapter Seven MA, MATI, Manush – Mamata 165
Shahid Divas, 18 December 2007 165
Mamata Banerjee: A Brief Background 167
Mamata and Singur 168
‘Didi Has Helped Us in Every Way’: Moral, Material and Logistical Support 172
Generating Public Attention – the Dharna in Kolkata 174
From Land War to a Battle of Good versus Evil 177
Ma, Mati, Manush: Scaling Up 179
One-Woman Dominance and Internal Discontent 180
Making and Breaking Movement Leaders 183
Conclusion 187
Conclusion 189
Political Society and Anti-dispossession Politics 190
Excess, Temporality and Everyday Politics 192
End Matter 195
Glossary 195
Biblography 199
Index 217