Menu Expand
Comparative Perspectives on Language Acquisition

Comparative Perspectives on Language Acquisition

Dr. Marzena Watorek | Sandra Benazzo | Maya Hickmann

(2012)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

This volume aims to provide a broad view of second language acquisition within a comparative perspective that addresses results concerning adult and child learners across a variety of source and target languages. It brings together contributions at the forefront of language acquisition research that consider a wide range of open questions: What are the precise mechanisms underlying acquisition? How can we characterize learners’ initial state and predict their degree of final achievement? What role do specific (typological) properties of source and target languages play? How does fossilization occur? How does the relative complexity of cognitive systems in adult and child learners affect acquisition? Does language learning influence cognitive organization? Can language learning shed light on our general understanding of human language and language processing?


Marzena Watorek is Professor in Linguistics at the University Paris 8. Her research interests include first and second language acquisition, particularly discourse production, initial processing of the input by adult learners, and the interface between language acquisition and teaching.

Sandra Benazzo is Associate Professor in Linguistics and French as a Second Language at the University Lille 3. Her research mainly concerns L2 acquisition in the domain of temporality, information structure, discourse organization and the comparison with L1 acquisition.

Maya Hickmann is Research Director in the Laboratoire Structures Formelles du Langage (CNRS and Université Paris 8). Her research mainly focuses on the role of structural vs. functional and universal vs. language-specific determinants in first and second language acquisition.


This well-edited collection of papers responds to the theoretical issues that concerned Clive Perdue throughout his productive career. The 29 chapters examine similarities and differences between monolinguals, childhood bilinguals, and adult and child learners of a second language. We see how learner productions are influenced by perceptual abilities, L1 transfer, and explicit learning as they operate across the lifespan, rather than some uniform expiration of a critical period.


Brian MacWhinney, Carnegie Mellon University, USA

In this volume, written by collaborators and friends of Clive Perdue, we find both familiar themes such as the expression of meaning in language, and unfamiliar ones such as the critical period, evolution, and signed language. Well-studied migrant workers provide data as do new populations (tutored learners, child L2ers, near native adult L2ers, bilinguals). What binds the contributions is a concern with simpler linguistic systems. A worthy tribute to Clive's intellectual legacy.


Susanne Carroll, University of Calgary, Canada

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Contents v
Contributors ix
Introduction: New Comparative Perspectives in the Study of Language Acquisition – Clive Perdue’s Legacy 1
Part 1 Second Language Acquisition: From Initial to Final Stages 21
1 A Way to Look at Second Language Acquisition 23
2 L2 Input and the L2 Initial State: The Writings of Clive Perdue 37
3 Finiteness and the Acquisition of Negation 54
4 The Different Role of Additive and Negative Particles in the Development of Finiteness in Early Adult L2 German and L2 Dutch 73
5 Lexical Categories in theTarget Language and the Lexical Categorisation of Learners: The Word Class of Adverbs 92
6 Is it Necessary for Chinese Mandarin Speakers to Mark Time? Refl ections About the Use of Temporal Adverb swith Respect to Verbal Morphology 108
7 The Development of Reference to Time and Space in French L3: Evidence from Narratives 133
8 Verbal Morphology in Advanced Varieties of English L2: Aspect or Discourse Hypothesis? 153
9 High-Level Proficiency in Second Language Use: Morphosyntax and Discourse 170
10 Ultimate Attainment and the Critical Period Hypothesis: Some Thorny Issues 188
11 Language Origins, Learner Varieties and Creating Language Anew: How Acquisitional Studies Can Contribute to Language Evolution Research 204
12 Multiple Perspectives on the Emergence and Development of Human Language: B. Comrie, C. Perdue and D. Slobin 223
Part 2 L1 and L2 Acquisition: Learner Type Perspective 243
13 Child Language Study and Adult Language Acquisition: Twenty Years Later 245
14 The Derivation of Mixed DPs: Mixing of Functional Categories in Bilingual Children and in Second Language Learners 263
15 L1 or L2 Acquisition?Finiteness in Child Second Language Learners (cL2), Compared to Adult L2 Learners (aL2) and Young Bilingual Children (2L1) 282
16 Young L2 and L1 Learners: More Alike than Different 303
17 The Older the Better, or More is More: Language Acquisition in Childhood 324
18 Additive Scope Particles and Anaphoric Linkage in Narrative and Descriptive Texts: A Developmental Study in French L1 and L2 350
19 Discourse Cohesion in Narrative Texts: The Role of Additive Means in Italian L1 and L2 375
20 The Role of Conceptual Development in the Acquisition of the Spatial Domain by L1 and L2 Learners of French, English and Polish 401
21 The Grammaticalisation of Nominals in French L1 and L2: A Comparative Study of Child and Adult Acquisition 420
Part 3 Typological Variation and Language Acquisition 441
22 Typology Meets Second Language Acquisition 443
23 Linguistic Relativity: Another Turn of the Screw 464
24 Paths in L2 Acquisition: The Expression of Temporality in Spatially Oriented Narration 482
25 A Cross-Linguistic Study of Narratives with Special Attention to the Progressive: A Contrast between English, Spanish and Catalan 502
26 Reference to Entities in Fictional Narratives of Russian/French Quasi-Bilinguals 520
27 The Cohesive Function of Word Order in L1 and L2 Italian: How VS Structures Mark Local and Global Coherence in the Discourse of Native Speakers and of Learners 535
28 Macrostructural Principles and the Development of Narrative Competence in L1 German: The Role of Grammar (8–14-Year-Olds) 559
29 Online Sentence Processing in Children and Adults: General and Specific Constraints. A Crosslinguistic Study in Four Languages 586
30 A Personal Tribute 613