Menu Expand
Does the Writing Workshop Still Work?

Does the Writing Workshop Still Work?

Dianne Donnelly

(2010)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

This book explores the effectiveness of the workshop in the Creative Writing classroom, and looks beyond the question of whether or not the workshop works to address the issue of what an altered pedagogical model might look like. In visualising what else is possible in the workshop space, the sixteen chapters collected in ‘Does the Writing Workshop Still Work?’ cover a range of theoretical and pedagogical topics and explore the inner workings and conflicts of the workshop model. The needs of a growing and diverse student population are central to the chapter authors’ consideration of non-normative pedagogies. The book is a must-read for all teachers of Creative Writing, as well as for researchers in Creative Writing Studies.


The essays in Does the Writing Workshop Still Work? demonstrate a range of approaches, questions, experiences, contexts, analyses, frustrations and enthusiasm, from teachers of university creative writing who are clearly passionate about their teaching and committed to their students. Many variations of the workshop are presented here: the inclusion of literary readings; hands-on writing exercises in class; informing one’s teaching with various theoretical perspectives; taking into account students’ diversity and cultural and gender differences; ethics; issues of power and autonomy.


Marcelle Freiman, Macquarie University, Australia

Does the Writing Workshop Still Work? (Multilingual Matters, 2010), edited by Dianne Donnelly, provides a foundation into creative writing studies in addition to new conceptions of what the workshop is and what it could be with revisions…Does the Writing Workshop Still Work? offers an important and timely contribution to the discipline because—in addition to reiterating the censure of instructors who do not turn a critical eye onto their pedagogies, professionalization, and workshop methodologies—the collection complicates issues by asking readers to consider the workshop as an event, an artistic act, and a human activity.


KATE KOSTELNIK

By exploring the workshop from within as well as without, and by challenging the notion that such a staid enterprise as the workshop cannot be reified for emerging writers and teachers, this collection bravely takes its place among its clear predecessors - namely Moxley’s Creative Writing in America and Bishop and Ostrom’s Colors of a Different Horse - in refusing to quietly accept the simple notions that writing instruction is an organic enterprise, and that writers are (or should be) meekly acculturated to the practices and values of the writing workshop as ‘fine, I [guess],’ to paraphrase one of the many astute contributors here.


Kelly Ritter, University of North Carolina-Greensboro

Does the Writing Workshop Still Work? is alert to the newest media in the creative arts, while offering a defense and investigation of the best practices of the creative writing workshop. A valuable resource to all teachers who view creative writing pedagogy as an academic discipline and humanistic exploration.


Shirley Geok-lin Lim, University of California, Santa Barbara; author of Among the White Moon Faces.

A remarkable new collection of essays about the theory, practice, design, and reinvention of peer-review components in writing-courses. The expertise and range of experience represented by the contributors is astonishing. This is a bountiful offering indeed.


Hans Ostrom, Editor, Colors of a Different Horse: Re-Thinking Creative Writing Theory and Pedagogy

Dianne Donnelly is the recipient of multiple teaching, scholarship, and writing awards and has published articles and short stories in a number of venues. She is also a frequent presenter at conferences on the subject of creative writing theory and pedagogy and the emergence of creative writing studies. She holds a PhD in English and teaches creative writing at the University of South Florida and Eckerd College.


This collection offers writing practitioners new and insightful approaches to their teaching and is an important and timely resource with which to reflect on course development, teaching and evaluation.


Catherine Cole, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Contents v
Acknowledgements vii
About the Authors viii
Foreword: On Experience xv
Introduction: If it Ain’t Broke, Don’t Fix it; Or Change is Inevitable, Except from a Vending Machine 1
SECTION ONE INSIDE THE WRITING WORKSHOP MODEL 29
Chapter 1 Once More to the Workshop: A Myth Caught in Time 30
Chapter 2 Workshop: An Ontological Study 36
Chapter 3 Small Worlds: What Works in Workshops If and When They Do? 52
Chapter 4 Teaching as a Creative Act: Why the Workshop Works in Creative Writing 63
Chapter 5 Workshopping and Fiction: Laboratory, Factory, or Finishing School? 78
SECTION TWO ENGAGING THE CONFLICTS 93
Chapter 6 Poetry, F(r)iction, Drama: The Complex Dynamics of Audience in the Writing Workshop 94
Chapter 7 Engaging the Individual/Social Conflict within Creative Writing Pedagogy 105
Chapter 8 Potentially Dangerous: Vulnerabilities and Risks in the Writing Workshop 117
Chapter 9 ‘Its fine, I gess’: Problems with the Workshop Model in College Composition Courses 130
SECTION THREE THE NON-NORMATIVE WORKSHOP 147
Chapter 10 The Creative Writing Workshop in the Two-Year College: Who Cares? 148
Chapter 11 Workshopping Lives 160
Chapter 12 The Things I Used To Do: Workshops Old and New 169
SECTION FOUR NEW MODELS FOR RELOCATING THE WORKSHOP 181
Chapter 13 Re-envisioning the Workshop: Hybrid Classrooms, Hybrid Texts 182
Chapter 14 Introducing Masterclasses 194
Chapter 15 Wrestling Bartleby: Another Workshop Model for the Creative Writing Classroom 206
Chapter 16 ‘A Space of Radical Openness’: Re-Visioning the Creative Writing Workshop 216
Afterword Disciplinarity and the Future of Creative Writing Studies 230