Menu Expand
Ricoeur and Castoriadis in Discussion

Ricoeur and Castoriadis in Discussion

Suzi Adams

(2017)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

This book features a highly significant discussion between Paul Ricoeur and Cornelius Castoriadis. Recorded for Radio France (Culture) in 1985, it is the only known encounter between these two great philosophers of the imagination. Their wide ranging conversation covers such themes as the productive imagination, human creation, social imaginaries, and the possibility of historical novelty; it reveals points of surprising commonality as well as divergence in their approaches. The dialogue is supplemented by critical essays by specialist scholars in Castoriadis and Ricoeur studies, and includes contributions from Johann P. Arnason, George H. Taylor, François Dosse, Johann Michel, Jean-Luc Amalric, and Suzi Adams. The book is a must read for all scholars interested in Ricoeur and Castoriadis studies, as well as those interested in debates on the possibilities and limits of human creation, and the importance of the imagination for social change.
Suzi Adams has made an important contribution to our understanding of French intellectual life in recent years by assembling a series of thoughtful essays by noted authors around an encounter between two major figures: Paul Ricoeur and Cornelius Castoriadis. In their conversation, translated here in English for the first time, the two philosophers join forces to tackle the question of human creativity in history.
Vincent Descombes, Professor at the École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales, Paris
Suzi Adams is Senior Lecturer in Sociology at Flinders University, Australia. She is the author of Castoriadis’s Ontology: Being and Creation (2011), and editor of Cornelius Castoriadis: Key Concepts (2014) and Cornelius Castoriadis: Critical Encounters (a special issue of the European Journal of Social Theory, 2012, co-edited with Ingerid Straume).

Contributors: Johann P. Arnason, Jean-Luc Amalric, François Dosse, Johann Michel, George Taylor
This engaging live dialogue between Ricoeur and Castoriadis offers important insights into inexhaustible hermeneutic interpretation and productive collective imagination, which turn around the question of the possibility of radical novelty in thinking and social being. The publication of the debate is accompanied by a set of perceptive interpretations and commentaries that are philosophically significant in their own right.
Dmitri Nikulin, Professor of Philosophy, New School for Social Research
Suzi Adams has assembled an important collection of essays that offer crucial insights into the significance human production and creativity have for history, politics, and action. Ricoeur and Castoriadis in Discussion represents a major contribution to our understanding of the social imaginary’s critical role in a world beset with social and political challenges.
Roger W. H. Savage, Professor of Systematic Musicology, University of California, Los Angeles
This fascinating comparison between two major contemporary thinkers, who had only limited contact with each other, nevertheless takes us to the heart of major issues in social theory: the interworking of institutions and symbols, their significance for relations of power and the scope for radical change in history. The authors, in charting the relations between these two views, end up casting an enormous amount of light on these crucial questions.
Charles Taylor, Professor Emeritus of Philosophy, McGill University

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover 1
Half Title i
Series Information ii
Title Page iii
Copyright Page iv
Table of contents v
Acknowledgements vii
Editor’s Foreword ix
Note to the French Edition xiii
Preface: Situating Castoriadis and Ricoeur xv
Preface to the French Edition xxxiii
Notes xlvii
References xlviii
Part I Ricoeur and Castoriadis Radio Dialogue 1
Chapter One Dialogue on History and the Social Imaginary 3
Notes 18
References 19
Part II Essays 21
Chapter Two On the Cusp: Ricoeur and Castoriadis at the Boundary 23
The Primordiality of the Social Imaginary 24
The Differentiation Between Productive and Creative Imagination 26
Castoriadis 27
Ricoeur 30
The Creative Imagination and The Imaginary Ex Nihilo 35
Ricoeur 35
Castoriadis 39
Notes 44
References 46
Chapter Three Castoriadis and Ricoeur on Meaning and History: Contrasts and Convergences 49
Setting The Scene 49
From Production to Institution 51
Confronting Structuralism 58
Creativity in Context 59
Continuity and Discontinuity 61
Imaginary Significations and Historical Processes 69
Notes 73
References 73
Chapter Four Ricoeur and Castoriadis: The Productive Imagination between Mediation and Origin 77
The Philosophical Context of The Dialogue: A Common Defence of The Practical Power of Productive Imagination 78
Creation, Production, and Institution: A Converging Critique of Structuralism Beyond The Terminological Dispute 84
Productive Imagination: Between Origin and Mediation, Creation and Retroaction 92
Notes 103
References 107
Chapter Five Castoriadis and Ricoeur on the Hermeneutic Spiral and the Meaning of History: Creation, Interpretation, Critique 111
Much Ado About ‘Nothing’: Creation or Production? 112
History, Tradition, and The Hermeneutic Spiral 118
Castoriadis 120
Ricoeur 124
Conclusions and Beginnings: Traversing The Hermeneutic Spiral Anew 130
Acknowledgement 134
Notes 134
References 135
Chapter Six The Social Imaginary as Engine of History in Ricoeur and Castoriadis 139
Dual Discontent Regarding Inherited Thought About The Imaginary 140
The Living Imagination in Paul Ricoeur 144
The Imaginary Between Chaos and Institution in Castoriadis’s Works 153
A Real Proximity Between Ricoeur and Castoriadis 164
Notes 166
References 167
Biographical Notes on Paul Ricoeur and Cornelius Castoriadis 171
Paul Ricoeur (1913–2005) 171
References 172
Cornelius Castoriadis (1922–1997) 173
References 174
Index 175
About the Contributors 185