Menu Expand
Secret Agents and the Memory of Everyday Collaboration in Communist Eastern Europe

Secret Agents and the Memory of Everyday Collaboration in Communist Eastern Europe

Péter Apor | Sándor Horváth | James Mark

(2017)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

The collection of essays in Secret Agents and the Memory of Everyday Collaboration in Communist Eastern Europe addresses institutions that develop the concept of collaboration, and examines the function, social representation and history of secret police archives and institutes of national memory that create these histories of collaboration. The essays provide a comparative account of collaboration/participation across differing categories of collaborators and different social milieux throughout East-Central Europe. They also demonstrate how secret police files can be used to produce more subtle social and cultural histories of the socialist dictatorships. By interrogating the ways in which post-socialist cultures produce the idea of, and knowledge about, “collaborators,” the contributing authors provide a nuanced historical conception of “collaboration,” expanding the concept toward broader frameworks of cooperation and political participation to facilitate a better understanding of Eastern European communist regimes.


Péter Apor (PhD), a permanent research fellow at the Institute of History, Research Centre for the Humanities, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary, is a specialist in the social and cultural history of East-Central European countries after World War II.

Sándor Horváth (PhD), a permanent research fellow and the head of department for Contemporary History at the Institute of History, Research Centre for the Humanities, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary, is the founding editor of the Hungarian Historical Review.

James Mark (PhD) is professor of history at the University of Exeter, United Kingdom.


Whilst debates over secret agents and the public revelation of lists of former collaborators have fascinated both post-Communist societies and the wider world, it is surprising how little has been written either on the nature of Communist-era collaboration or the processes through which post-Communist societies have sought to make sense of what collaboration was, and how it should be dealt with in the present. This is surprising given the amount of work that has been produced on the themes of resistance and victimization.

Unlike more popular (and often lurid) accounts of collaboration, which naturalise the concept as an obvious and incontestable characterization of Communist-era behaviour, ‘Secret Agents and the Memory of Everyday Collaboration in Communist Eastern Europe’ rather interrogates the ways in which Post-Socialist cultures produce the idea of, and knowledge about, ‘collaborators’. It addresses those institutions which produce the concept and examines the function, social representation and history of secret police archives and institutes of national memory that create these histories of collaboration. This work seeks to provide a more nuanced historical conception of ‘collaboration’, expanding the concept towards broader frameworks of cooperation and political participation in order to facilitate a better understanding of the maintenance of Eastern European Communist regimes.

This work contends that secret police files are too often used to provide a one dimensional historical account of the ‘mechanisms of oppression’. It demonstrates, through case studies, how secret police files can be used to produce more subtle social and cultural histories of the socialist dictatorships. Of particular importance is the focus on the microhistorical. Contributions here explore the motivations and moralities of becoming an agent, the personal decisions and social consequences such steps involved as well as the everyday milieus in which agents lived and were active. This book analyses communities of cooperation, with particular focus on local and mid-level party organizations, organs of the church organs and artist or intellectual networks. Ranging across differing categories of collaborators and different social milieux across East-Central Europe, this work provides a comparative account of collaboration and participation with a range hitherto unavailable.


“This excellent volume marks a genuine breakthrough in our knowledge about the everyday lives of the people who made up the secret police, of their motivations and their experiences. It challenges binary visions of the past and powerfully highlights the complexity of the term ‘collaboration.’ Ultimately, it makes a case for the human factor in the history of the repressive state.”
—Ulf Brunnbauer, Director, Leibniz Institute for East and Southeast European Studies, Regensburg, Germany

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover 1
Front Matter ii
Half-title i
Series information ii
Title page iii
Copyright information iv
Table of contents v
List of abbreviations vii
Introduction: collaboration, Cooperation and Political Participation in the Communist Regimes 1
The Memory of Collaboration 1
Producing concepts of collaboration 3
Rethinking the history of collaboration 9
Notes 13
Chapter (1-15) 1
Part I Institutes of Memory 19
Chapter 1 A Dissident Legacy and its Aspects: The Agency of the Federal Commissioner for The Stasi Records ... 21
Introduction 21
A Special Postcommunist German Feature: Stasi Files and BStU 22
Securing the Stasi files 23
Opening the Stasi files 25
Lustrations and Collaboration 28
Conclusion 31
Notes 33
Chapter 2 Goodbye Communism, Hello Remembrance: Historical Paradigms and The Institute of National Remembrance in Poland 37
Introduction 37
The Institute 39
Establishment of the IPN 40
Super-archives and dangerous folders 41
Prosecution and punishment 43
Memory, Historical Politics and the Totalitarian Paradigm 44
Totalitarian paradigm 46
2010, a Landmark Year: Toward Pluralism 47
The breakup of the narrative 50
The Radical (Re)turn to Commemoration 51
Notes 53
Chapter 3 The Exempt Nation: Memory of Collaboration in Contemporary Latvia 59
Introduction 59
Elements of Collective Memory of Collaborationism 61
The Conception of the “Exempt Latvian Nation” 66
Conclusion 75
Notes 76
Chapter 4 Institutes of Memory in Slovakia and The Czech Republic: What Kind of Memory? 81
Introduction 81
Collective Memory and Anticommunism 82
Transitional Justice in the Czech Republic and Slovakia 83
The Nation’s Memory Institute (NMI) 85
The Need to Address the Past 87
The Delegitimization of the Regimes of the Past 89
Truth and Memory 89
Presidential Veto 91
The Institute for the Study of Totalitarian Regimes (ISTR) 92
The Delegitimization of the Regimes of the Past 94
Truth and Memory 95
Conclusion 97
Notes 99
Chapter 5 Closing The Past—Opening The Future: Victims and Perpetrators of The Communist Regime in Hungary 105
Prolonged File-Fever after 1989 106
Museums and Collaboration with the Communist Regimes 115
Conclusion 122
Notes 123
Chapter 6 To Collaborate and to Punish: Democracy and Transitional Justice in Romania 129
“Transitional Justice” in Romania: Stakes, Obstacles, Solutions 130
CNSAS and the Unveiling of Political Police 132
Public Opinion Concerning the “Pact with the Devil” 138
Strategies of Distancing 139
Types of Collaboration and Unveiling 141
Conclusion 143
Notes 144
Part II Secret Lives 149
Chapter 7 “Resistance Through Culture” or “Connivance Through Culture”: Difficulties of Interpretation; Nuances ... 151
“Resistance through Culture” 151
The True Constantin Noica in the Securitate Archive 154
Constantin Noica as agent of influence: “Supporting culture” by converting the exile 155
“Cultural reconversion” through political deactivation 157
The myth of the “resistance through culture”—the Paltinis type 160
The other facet of the story: The Stockholm Syndrome 162
The Manipulation of the Secret Police Archives 164
Notes 165
Chapter 8 Intellectuals Between Collaboration and Independence in Late Socialism: Politics and Everyday Life ... 171
Introduction 171
The Stories of Two Historians 173
Solidarity, Party Loyalty and Stiff Competition among Colleagues 180
The State Security Forces: An Unequal Struggle between the Individual and the State Machinery 181
Conclusion: Individual Strategies, Competing Loyalties and the Legitimacy of the System 185
Notes 187
Chapter 9 Deal With The Devil: Intellectuals and Their Support of Tito’s Rule in Yugoslavia (1945–80) 191
Introduction 191
Tito’s Attitudes toward “Unreliable Waverers” 192
Intellectuals on “the Greatest Son of Our Peoples and Nationalities” 193
Conclusion: Betrayal of the Intellectuals? 200
Notes 201
Chapter 10 A Spy in Underground: Polish Samizdat Stories 207
Recruiting to Social Media 208
Surviving the First Years 210
“External Intervention”: Janusz’s Second Life 212
“Tactical Diversity”: Polish Resistance Culture 216
Investigation Closing In 218
Between Individual and Collective Agency 221
Notes 221
Chapter 11 Entangled Stories: on The Meaning of Collaboration with The Securitate 225
Before 1989: The Stories of Dissent in the Files of Radio Free Europe 227
After 1989: The stories of dissent in the files of the Securitate 232
Conclusion 239
Notes 241
Part III Collaborating Communities 247
Chapter 12 Finding the way Around: Regional-Level Party Activists and Collaboration 249
The Troubles of Local Party Cadres 251
Struggle against Religion 258
Party Life in Local Organizations 261
Conclusions 263
Notes 264
Chapter 13 Wer Aber ist Die Partei? History and Historiography 269
“The Highest Extent of Organization,” or Data on the Question of Party Membership 270
The Jungle of Paperwork 272
Levels of Political Communication 275
Participants in the Communication: The Village-Goers 276
Participants in the Communication: Local Peasantry 277
Participants in the Communication: Party Leadership 277
Party Life and Attitudes toward “Partisanship” Following the “Great Turn” 278
Notes 284
Chapter 14 Just A Simple Priest: Remembering Cooperation with the Communist State in the Catholic Church ... 287
The Personal and the Collective in Catholic Memory 290
Catholic Public Memory after 1989 292
Oral History: Stories of Resistance 296
Stories of “Faithful Priests” 301
Conclusion 305
Notes 306
Chapter 15 Unofficial Collaborators in the Tourism Sector (GDR and Hungary) 309
Tourism Control by Hungarian State Security 310
Cooperation with State Security as a Possible Livelihood Strategy 312
Stasi Control of East German Tourists in Hungary 316
A Full-Time Informer of the Stasi at Lake Balaton 317
Conclusion 322
Notes 323
Conclusion 329
Notes 336
End Matter 339
Bibliography 339
Contributors 351
Index 353