Menu Expand
Bird Conservation

Bird Conservation

David R. Williams | Robert G. Pople | David A. Showler | Lynn V. Dicks | Matthew F. Child | Erasmus K.H.J. zu Ermgassen | William J. Sutherland

(2013)

Additional Information

Abstract

This book brings together scientific evidence and experience relevant to the practical conservation of wild birds. The authors worked with an international group of bird experts and conservationists to develop a global list of interventions that could benefit wild birds. 

For each intervention, the book summarises studies captured by the Conservation Evidence project, where that intervention has been tested and its effects on birds quantified. The result is a thorough guide to what is known, or not known, about the effectiveness of bird conservation actions throughout the world.

The preparation of this synopsis was funded by the Natural Environment Research Council and Arcadia.


Too much past conservation has been a nice fluffy exercise which has regularly failed to deliver. Given the current crisis in wildlife declines we need to sharpen our game and for this we need to use the best available evidence. This volume and it associated publications will help us to do this. 


Mick Green

Overall, this is an outstanding book (and an excellent concept) that will make a significant contribution to evidence-based bird conservation, and I hope there will be many future editions allowing conservation practitioners to be right up to date with current scientific research.


Robert Sheldon

David Williams is a Research Assistant in the Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge.

Robert G. Pople is a former Research Assistant in the Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge.

David Showler is a Research Associate in the School of Biological Sciences, University of East Anglia and the Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge.

Matthew F. Child is a Research Assistant in the Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge.

Lynn Dicks is a Research Associate in the Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge.

Erasmus K.H.J. zu Ermgassen is a student in the Department of Veterinary Medicine, University of Cambridge.

William J. Sutherland is the Miriam Rothschild Professor of Conservation Biology at the University of Cambridge.


Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover cover
Contents v
Advisory board xiv
About the authors xv
Acknowledgements xvi
1. About this book 1
2. Habitat protection 7
Key messages 7
2.1. Legally protect habitats 8
2.2. Ensure connectivity between habitat patches 9
2.3. Provide or retain un-harvested buffer strips 10
3. Education and awareness raising 13
Key messages 13
3.1. Raise awareness amongst the general public through campaigns and public information 13
3.2. Provide bird feeding materials to families with young children 14
3.3. Enhance bird taxonomy skills through higher education and \rtraining 14
3.4. Provide training to conservationists and land managers on bird ecology and conservation 14
4. Threat: Residential and commercial development 15
Key messages 15
4.1. Angle windows to reduce collisions 15
4.2. Mark or tint windows to reduce collision mortality 15
5. Threat: Agriculture 17
Key messages – All farming systems 17
Key messages – Arable farming 20
Key messages – Livestock farming 21
Key messages – Perennial, non-timber crops 23
Key messages – Aquaculture 24
All farming systems 25
5.1. Support or maintain low-intensity agricultural systems 25
5.2. Practise integrated farm management 25
5.3. Food labelling schemes relating to biodiversity-friendly farming 25
5.4. Increase the proportion of natural/semi-natural vegetation in the farmed landscape 25
5.5. Pay farmers to cover the costs of conservation measures 27
5.6. Cross compliance standards for all subsidy payments 36
5.7. Reduce field size (or maintain small fields) 37
5.8. Provide or retain set-aside areas in farmland 37
5.9. Manage hedges to benefit wildlife 42
5.10. Plant new hedges 44
5.11. Manage stone-faced hedge banks to benefit birds 44
5.12. Manage ditches to benefit wildlife 45
5.13. Protect in-field trees 46
5.14. Plant in-field trees 46
5.15. Tree pollarding and tree surgery 46
5.16. Plant wild bird seed or cover mixture 46
5.17. Plant nectar flower mixture/wildflower strips 55
5.18. Create uncultivated margins around intensive arable or pasture fields 57
5.19. Plant grass buffer strips/margins around arable or pasture fields 59
5.20. Use mowing techniques to reduce chick mortality 63
5.21. Provide refuges in fields during harvest or mowing 64
5.22. Mark bird nests during harvest or mowing 64
5.23. Relocate nests at harvest time to reduce nestling mortality 65
5.24. Make direct payments per clutch for farmland birds 65
5.25. Control scrub on farmland 66
5.26. Take field corners out of management 67
5.27. Reduce conflict by deterring birds from taking crops 67
Arable farming 68
5.28. Increase crop diversity 68
5.29. Implement 'mosaic management' 69
5.30. Leave overwinter stubbles 69
5.31. Plant nettle strips 73
5.32. Leave unharvested cereal headlands within arable fields 73
5.33. Plant crops in spring rather than autumn 73
5.34. Undersow spring cereals,with clover for example 75
5.35. Plant more than one crop per field (intercropping) 76
5.36. Revert arable land to permanent grassland 76
5.37. Reduce tillage 78
5.38. Add 1%barley into wheat crop for corn buntings 81
5.39. Leave uncropped, cultivated margins or plots (includes lapwing and stone curlew plots) 81
5.40. Create skylark plots 83
5.41. Create corn bunting plots 84
5.42. Plant cereals in wide-spaced rows 85
5.43. Create beetle banks 85
Livestock farming 87
5.44. Maintain species-rich, semi-natural grassland 87
5.45. Reduce management intensity on permanent grasslands 88
5.46. Reduce grazing intensity 90
5.47. Provide short grass for waders 93
5.48. Raise mowing height on grasslands 93
5.49. Delay mowing date or first grazing date on grasslands 94
5.50. Leave uncut rye grass in silage fields 95
5.51. Plant cereals for wholecrop silage 96
5.52. Maintain lowland heathland 97
5.53. Maintain rush pastures 97
5.54. Maintain traditional water meadows 98
5.55. Maintain upland heath/moor 99
5.56. Plant Brassica fodder crops 100
5.57. Use mixed stocking 100
5.58. Use traditional breeds of livestock 100
5.59. Maintain wood pasture and parkland 100
5.60. Exclude grazers from semi-natural habitats (including woodland) 100
5.61. Protect nests from livestock to reduce trampling 103
5.62. Mark fences to reduce bird collision mortality 103
5.63. Create open patches or strips in permanent grassland 104
Perennial, non-timber crops 104
5.64. Maintain traditional orchards 105
5.65. Manage perennial bioenergy crops to benefit wildlife 105
Aquaculture 106
5.66. Reduce conflict with humans to reduce persecution 106
5.67. Scare birds from fish farms 106
5.68. Disturb birds at roosts 109
5.69. Use electric fencing to exclude fish-eating birds 110
5.70. Use netting to exclude fish-eating birds 111
5.71. Disturb birds using foot patrols 112
5.72. Use ‘mussel socks ’ to prevent birds from attacking shellfish 112
5.73. Translocate birds away from fish farms 113
5.74. Increase water turbidity to reduce fish predation by birds 113
5.75. Provide refuges for fish within ponds 114
5.76. Use in-water devices to reduce fish loss from ponds 114
5.77. Spray water to deter birds from ponds 115
5.78. Deter birds from landing on shellfish culture gear 115
6. Threat:Energy production and mining 117
Key messages 117
6.1. Paint wind turbines to increase their visibility 117
7. Threat:Transportation and service corridors 118
Key messages – Verges and airports 118
Key messages – Power lines and electricity pylons 118
Verges and airports 119
7.1. Mow roadside verges 119
7.2. Sow roadside verges 119
7.3. Scare or otherwise deter birds from airports 119
Power lines and electricity pylons 120
7.4. Bury or isolate power lines to reduce incidental mortality 120
7.5. Remove earth wires to reduce incidental mortality 121
7.6. Thicken earth wire to reduce incidental mortality 121
7.7. Mark power lines to reduce incidental mortality 121
7.8. Use raptor models to deter birds and so reduce incidental \rmortality 124
7.9. Add perches to electricity pylons to reduce electrocution 124
7.10. Insulate power pylons to prevent electrocution 125
7.11. Use perch-deterrents to stop raptors perching on pylons 125
7.12. Reduce electrocutions by using plastic, not aluminium, leg rings to mark birds 126
8. Threat: Biological resource use 127
Key messages – reducing exploitation and conflict 127
Key messages – reducing fisheries bycatch 128
Reducing exploitation and conflict 130
8.1. Use legislative regulation to protect wild populations 130
8.2. Increase 'on-the-ground' protection to reduce unsustainable levels of exploitation 132
8.3. Promote sustainable alternative livelihoods 133
8.4. Use education programmes and local engagement to help reduce persecution or exploitation of species 133
8.5. Employ local people as ‘biomonitors 135
8.6. Mark eggs to reduce their appeal to egg collectors 136
8.7. Relocate nestlings to reduce poaching 136
8.8. Use wildlife refuges to reduce hunting disturbance 137
8.9. Introduce voluntary 'maximum shoot distances' 138
8.10. Provide ‘sacrificial' grasslands to reduce the impact of wild geese on crops 138
8.11. Move fish-eating birds to reduce conflict with fishermen 139
8.12. Scare fish-eating birds from areas to reduce conflict 139
Reduce fisheries bycatch 139
8.13. Set longlines at night to reduce seabird bycatch 140
8.14. Turn deck lights off during night-time setting of longlines to reduce bycatch 142
8.15. Use streamer lines to reduce seabird bycatch on longlines 143
8.16. Use larger hooks to reduce seabird bycatch 146
8.17. Use a water cannon when setting longlines to reduce seabird bycatch 147
8.18. Set lines underwater to reduce seabird bycatch 147
8.19. Set longlines at the side of the boat to reduce seabird bycatch 148
8.20. Use a line shooter to reduce seabird bycatch 148
8.21. Use bait throwers to reduce seabird bycatch 149
8.22. Tow buoys behind longlining boats to reduce seabird bycatch 149
8.23. Dye baits to reduce seabird bycatch 149
8.24. Use high-visibility longlines to reduce seabird bycatch 150
8.25. Use a sonic scarer when setting longlines to reduce seabird bycatch 150
8.26. Weight baits or lines to reduce longline bycatch of seabirds 150
8.27. Use shark liver oil to deter birds when setting lines 152
8.28. Thaw bait before setting lines to reduce seabird bycatch 152
8.29. Reduce seabird bycatch by releasing offal overboard when setting longlines 153
8.30. Use bird exclusion devices such as 'Brickle curtains' \rto reduce seabird mortality when hauling longlines 153
8.31. Use acoustic alerts on gillnets to reduce seabird bycatch 154
8.32. Use high-visibility mesh on gillnets to reduce seabird bycatch 154
8.33. Reduce gillnet deployment time to reduce seabird bycatch 155
8.34. Mark trawler warp cables to reduce seabird collisions 155
8.35. Reduce 'ghost fishing' by lost//discarded gear 155
8.36. Reduce bycatch through seasonal or area closures 156
9. Threat: Human intrusions and disturbance 157
Key messages 157
9.1. Use wildlife refuges to reduce hunting disturbance 157
9.2. Use signs and access restrictions to reduce disturbance at nest sites 157
9.3. Set minimum distances for approaching birds (buffer zones) 160
9.4. Provide paths to limit the extent of disturbance 160
9.5. Reduce visitor group size 161
9.6. Use voluntary agreements with local people to reduce disturbance 161
9.7. Start educational programmes for personal watercraft owners 161
9.8. Habituate birds to human visitors 162
9.9. Use nest covers to reduce the impact of research on predation of ground-nesting seabirds 162
10. Threat:Natural system modifications 164
Key messages 164
10.1. Use prescribed burning 167
10.2. Use fire suppression/control 183
10.3. Protect nest trees before burning 184
10.4. Clear or open patches in forests 184
10.5. Clearcut and re-seed forests 186
10.6. Thin trees within forests 187
10.7. Coppice trees 189
10.8. Use patch retention harvesting instead of clearcutting 190
10.9. Use selective harvesting/logging instead of clearcutting 191
10.10. Use variable retention management during forestry 192
10.11. Use shelterwood cutting instead of clearcutting 193
10.12. Manage woodland edges for birds 193
10.13. Manually control or remove mid-storey and ground-level 194
10.14. Replace non-native species of tree/shrub 202
10.15. Provide deadwood/snags in forests 202
10.16. Remove coarse woody debris from forests 204
10.17. Apply herbicide to mid- and under-storey vegetation 205
10.18. Treat wetlands with herbicide 206
10.19. Employ grazing in natural and semi-natural habitats 208
10.20. Plant trees to act as windbreaks 214
10.21. Re-seed grasslands 215
10.22. Fertilise artificial grasslands 215
10.23. Raise water levels in ditches or grassland 217
10.24. Manage water level in wetlands 218
10.25. Use environmentally sensitive flood management 220
10.26. Use greentree reservoir management 220
10.27. Plough habitats 221
10.28. Create scrapes and pools in wetlands and wet grasslands 222
11. Habitat restoration and creation 224
Key messages 224
11.1. Restore or create forests 225
11.2. Restore or create grasslands 229
11.3. Restore or create traditional water meadows 235
11.4. Restore or create shrubland 236
11.5. Restore or create savannas 237
11.6. Restore or create wetlands and marine habitats 237
12. Threat:Invasive alien and other problematic species 243
Key messages – reduce predation by other species 243
Key messages – reduce incidental mortality during predator eradication or control 244
Key messages – reduce nest predation by excluding predators from nests or nesting areas 244
Key messages – reduce mortality by reducing hunting ability or changing predator behaviour 245
Key messages – reduce competition with other species for food and nest sites 246
Key messages – reduce adverse habitat alteration by other species 246
Key messages – reduce parasitism and disease 247
Key messages – reduce detrimental impacts of other problematic species 247
Reduce predation by other species 248
12.1. Remove or control predators to enhance bird populations and communities 248
Predator control on islands 249
12.2. Control avian predators on islands 249
12.3. Control mammalian predators on islands 251
12.4. Control invasive ants on islands 261
12.5. Control predators not on islands 261
12.6. Reduce predation by translocating predators 269
Reduce incidental mortality during predator eradication or control 270
12.7. Do birds take bait designed for pest control? 270
12.8. Distribute poison bait using dispensers 271
12.9. Use repellents on baits 271
12.10 Use coloured baits to reduce accidental mortality during predator control 272
Reduce nest predation by excluding predators from nests or nesting areas 273
12.11. Physically protect nests from predators using non-electric fencing 273
12.12. Protect bird nests using electric fencing 274
12.13. Physically protect nests with individual exclosures/barriers or provide shelters for chicks 276
12.14. Can nest protection increase nest abandonment? 281
12.15. Can nest protection increase predation of adults and chicks? 282
12.16. Use artificial nests that discourage predation 283
12.17. Use multiple barriers to protect nests 284
12.18. Plant nesting cover to reduce nest predation Background 285
12.19. Use snakeskin to deter mammalian nest predators 285
12.20. Use mirrors to deter nest predators 285
12.21. Use naphthalene to deter mammalian predators 286
12.22. Use ultrasonic devices to deter cats 286
12.23. Protect nests from ants 286
12.24. Guard nests to prevent predation 287
12.25. Use 'cat curfews' to reduce predation 287
12.26. Use lion dung to deter domestic cats 287
12.27. Play spoken-word radio programmes to deter predators 287
Reduce mortality by reducing hunting ability or changing predator behaviour 288
12.28. Use collar-mounted devices to reduce predation 288
12.29. Use supplementary feeding to reduce predation 288
12.30. Use aversive conditioning to reduce nest predation 289
12.31. Reduce predation by translocating nest boxes 293
Reduce competition with other species for food and nest sites 294
12.32. Reduce inter-specific competition for nest sites by removing competitor species 294
12.33. Reduce inter-specific competition for nest sites by modifying habitats to exclude competitor species 298
12.34. Protect nest sties from competitors 298
12.35. Reduce competition between species by providing nest boxes 299
12.36. Reduce inter-specific competition for food by removing or controlling competitor species 300
Reduce adverse habitat alteration by other species 301
12.37. Reduce adverse habitat alterations by excluding problematic species 301
12.38. Control or remove habitat-altering mammals 303
12.39. Remove problematic vegetation 304
12.40. Use buffer zones to reduce the impact of invasive plant control 305
Reduce parasitism and disease 306
12.41. Remove/treat endoparasites and diseases 306
12.42. Exclude or control ‘reservoir species ’ to reduce parasite burdens 307
12.43. Remove/treat ectoparasites to increase survival or reproductive success 308
12.44. Guard nests to reduce risk of ectoparasites 312
12.45. Remove/control brood parasites 312
12.46. Use false brood parasite eggs to discourage brood parasitism 316
12.47. Provide supplementary food to increase parental presence and so reduce brood parasitism 316
12.48. Alter artificial nest sites to discourage brood parasitism 317
Reduce detrimental impacts of other problematic species 317
12.49. Use copper strips to exclude snails from nests 317
13. Threat: Pollution 318
Key messages – Industrial pollution 318
Key messages – Agricultural pollution 318
Key message – Air-borne pollutants 319
Key messages – Excess energy 319
Industrial pollution 320
13.1. Clean birds following oil spills 320
13.2. Relocate birds following oil spills 322
13.3. Deter or prevent birds from landing on toxic pools 323
13.4. Use repellents to deter birds from landing on pools polluted by mining 325
Agricultural pollution 325
13.5. Reduce pesticide or herbicide use generally 325
13.6. Restrict certain pesticides or other agricultural chemicals 327
13.7. Provide food for vultures to reduce mortality from diclofenac 328
13.8. Make selective use of spring herbicides 329
13.9. Use organic rather than mineral fertilisers 329
13.10. Reduce chemical inputs in permanent grassland management 329
13.11. Leave headlands in fields unsprayed (conservation headlands) 330
13.12. Provide unfertilised cereal headlands in arable fields 332
13.13. Plant riparian buffer strips 332
13.14. Provide buffer strips around in-field ponds 333
Air-borne pollutants 333
13.15. Use lime to reduce acidification in lakes 333
Excess energy 333
13.16. Reduce incidental mortality from birds being attracted to artificial lights 333
13.17. Turn off lights to reduce mortality from artificial lights 334
13.18. Reduce the intensity of lighthouse beams 334
13.19. Shield lights to reduce mortality from artificial lights 334
13.20. Use flashing lights to reduce mortality from artificial lights 335
13.21. Use lights low in spectral red to reduce mortality from artificial lights 335
13.22. Use volunteers to collect downed birds and rehabilitate them 336
14. Threat: Climate change,extreme weather and geological events 337
Key messages 337
14.1. Water nesting mounds to increase incubation success in malleefowl 337
14.2. Replace nesting substrate following severe weather 338
15. General responses to small/declining populations 339
Key messages – inducing breeding, rehabituation and egg removal 339
Key messages – provide artificial nesting sites 339
Key messages – foster chicks in the wild 340
Key messages – provide supplementary food 341
Key messages – translocations 342
15.1. Use artificial visual and auditory stimuli to induce breeding in wild populations 343
15.2. Rehabilitate injured birds 343
15.3. Remove eggs from wild nests to increase reproductive output 344
15.4. Provide artificial nesting sites 345
15.5. Clean nest boxes to increase occupancy or reproductive success 390
15.6. Use differently-coloured artificial nests 392
15.7. Provide nesting material for wild birds 393
15.8. Repair/support nests to support breeding 393
15.9. Artificially incubate eggs or warm nests 394
15.10. Provide nesting habitat for birds that is safe from extreme weather 394
15.11. Remove vegetation to create nesting areas 395
15.12. Guard nests to increase nest success 397
Foster chicks in the wild 398
15.13. Foster eggs or chicks with wild conspecifics 398
15.14. Foster eggs or chicks with wild non-conspecifics (cross-fostering) 404
Provide supplementary food 407
15.15. Provide supplementary food to increase reproductive success 408
15.16. Provide supplementary food to allow the rescue of \ra second chick 430
15.17. Provide supplementary food to increase adult survival 431
15.18. Can supplementary feeding increase predation or parasitism? 449
15.19. Provide supplementary food through the establishment of food populations 450
15.20. Use perches to increase foraging success 451
15.21. Place feeders close to windows to reduce collisions 452
15.22. Provide supplementary water to increase survival or reproductive success 453
15.23. Provide calcium supplements to increase survival or reproductive success 453
Translocations 457
15.24. Translocate birds to re-establish populations or increase genetic variation 457
15.25. Use techniques to increase the survival of species after capture 474
15.26. Ensure translocated birds are familiar with each other before release 475
15.27. Ensure genetic variation to increase translocation success 475
15.28. Translocate nests to avoid disturbance 476
15.29. Use vocalisations to attract birds to new sites 477
15.30. Use decoys to attract birds to new sites 479
15.31. Alter habitat to encourage birds to leave an area 481
16. Captive breeding,rearing and releases (ex situ conservation) 483
Key messages – captive breeding 483
Key messages – release of captive--bred individuals 484
Captive breeding 485
16.1. Use captive breeding to increase or maintain populations 485
16.2. Can captive breeding have deleterious effects on individual fitness? 490
16.3. Use artificial insemination in captive breeding 491
16.4. Freeze semen for use in artificial insemination 492
16.5. Wash contaminated semen and use it for artificial insemination 493
16.6. Artificially incubate and hand-rear birds in captivity 494
16.7. Use puppets to increase the success of hand-rearing 504
Release of captive-bred individuals 505
16.8. Release captive-bred individuals into the wild to restore or augment wild populations 505
16.9. Use appropriate populations to source released \rpopulations 520
16.10. Use holding pens at release sites 521
16.11. Clip birds’ wings on release 523
16.12. Release birds in groups 524
16.13. Release chicks and adults in 'coveys' 524
16.14. Release birds as adults or sub-adults,not juveniles 525
16.15. Use 'anti-predator training' to improve survival after release 527
16.16. Use 'flying training' before release 528
16.17. Provide supplementary food during and after release 529
16.18. Use microlites to help birds migrate 530
Index 531