Menu Expand
Amphibian Conservation

Amphibian Conservation

Rebecca K. Smith | William J. Sutherland

(2014)

Abstract

Amphibian Conservation is the fourth in the series of Synopses of Conservation Evidence, linked to the online resource www.ConservationEvidence.com.

This synopsis is part of the Conservation Evidence project and provides a useful resource for conservationists. It forms part of a series designed to promote a more evidence-based approach to biodiversity conservation. Others in the series include bee, bird, farmland and bat conservation and many others are in preparation.

Approximately 32% of the 7,164+ amphibian species are currently threatened with extinction and at least 43% of species are declining. Despite this, until recently amphibians and their conservation had received little attention. Although work is now being carried out to conserve many species, often it is not adequately documented.

This book brings together and summarises the available scientific evidence and experience relevant to the practical conservation of amphibians.

The authors consulted an international group of amphibian experts and conservationists to produce a thorough summary of what is known, or not known, about the effectiveness of amphibian conservation actions across the world.

"The book is packed with literature summaries and citations; a veritable information goldmine for graduate students and researchers. It also admirably provides decision makers with a well-researched resource of proven interventions that can be employed to stem/reverse the decline of amphibian populations." -John G Palis, Bulletin of the Chicago Herpetological Society


Dr Rebecca K. Smith is a Research Associate at the University of Cambridge.  She holds degrees in the ecology & conservation of European hares (PhD, University of Bristol), Applied Ecology & Conservation (MSc, University of East Anglia) and Biology (BSc with Honours, University of Bristol). Dr Smith is part of the Conservation Evidence group at the University of Cambridge, which focuses on summarising and disseminating scientific evidence about the effects of conservation interventions for habitats and species. She is an author of the Farmland Conservation synopsis and has undertaken systematic reviews on the effectiveness of conservation management for birds. Prior to this work Dr Smith undertook projects developing monitoring and management strategies for high conservation priority mammal species. Her current scientific duties include facilitating the development of further synopses including bat, reptile and forest conservation and invasive species management. She is also the Editorial Administrator of the Conservation Evidence Journal.


To properly evaluate this book, I focused this review on four (out of many) subjects of personal interest. The first takes me back to my childhood in suburban Brookfield, Illinois. The one and only amphibian inhabiting the world of my youth was the American toad, Anaxyrus (a. k. a. Bufo) americanus. I encountered toads in the nearby forest preserve, in neighborhood yards and gardens, as well as in the street as they fed on insects under the light of street lamps in the evening. In addi- tion, I often observed --- with anguish --- toads at the bottom of storm drains that were built into the roadbed adjacent to the curb. Because each storm drain was covered with an immov- able steel grate, I was unable to extract the entrapped toads. Over time, the toads succumbed to starvation and/or desiccation. Did the authors of Amphibian Conservation consider this threat to amphibians and, if so, did they find a solution? Indeed, they had.

In the “ Threat: Transportation and service corridors” chapter, I found a subsection entitled, “ Modify gully pots and
kerbs. ” In the United Kingdom, the terms “gully pot” and “kerb” are synonymous with our “storm drain” and “curb” respectively. Research in Europe found that separating storm drains from the curb by 4 inches decreased the number of great crested newts (Triturus cristatus) that fell in by 80%. Intrigued, I searched the internet and found the original article. Separation of the storm drain from the adjacent curb is achieved by replac- ing the standard section of curb with a section that has a recessed wall. Small animals following the curb wall diverge slightly into the recessed portion, thus avoiding the storm drain. This modified curb provides a simple solution to my vexing childhood dilemma of what to do about toads falling into storm drains. Perhaps urban/suburban readers of the Bulletin can lobby their respective community leaders to implement this solution in their neighborhoods. Interested readers are encouraged to visit www. aco. co. uk to learn more about these commercially-produced modified curbs.

As field herpetologists know, many of our more interesting amphibians cannot successfully reproduce in water bodies harboring large, predatory fishes. These fishes (sunfishes, in particular) look upon frog and salamander larvae as delectable treats. Paradoxically, I have captured larvae of fish-intolerant amphibian species co-existing with predatory fishes. How is this possible? Invariably, these larvae take refuge in aquatic vegetation.

Because a large number of people enjoy fishing, water bodies are commonly stocked with game fish. As a result, many otherwise suitable water bodies are off limits to amphibians that are palatable to fish. Perhaps it’s possible, however, to encourage the presence of aquatic vegetation in fish ponds so they can also provide amphibian habitat. Did the authors of Amphibian Conservation consider this potential intervention? Yes, in Chapter 8, “ Threat: Invasive alien and other problematic species. ” Here, I found a subsection entitled, “ Encourage aquatic plant growth as refuge against fish predation. ” Unexpectedly, the authors did not find any studies demonstrating the efficacy of such an intervention. This result was surprising as I know relevant literature exists. Two studies come to mind, one conducted in the laboratory (Baber and Babbitt, 2004) and the other in the field (Shulse et al. , 2012). Although both provide valuable support for providing aquatic vegetation as a means to protect amphibian larvae from fish predation --- evidence that could inform real-world solutions --- neither appeared to meet the criteria for inclusion in the book. The exclusion of these studies illustrates the necessity of looking beyond the literature captured by the Conservation Evidence Project (as encouraged by the authors).

Worldwide, wetland losses have been enormous (Zedler and Kercher, 2005). Wetland loss is one of the greatest threats to amphibians because so many species rely on them for reproduction. How is this addressed in Amphibian Conservation? Chapter 12, “ Habitat restoration and creation” provides numerous examples of interventions that have been implemented to miti- gate the loss of amphibian habitat, including the creation of ponds and wetlands. I was heartened to see the substantial collection of literature pertaining to this subject. Humans are very adept at tinkering with their surroundings, whether it be for human benefit (e. g. , draining a marsh to increase agricultural acreage) or the benefit of wildlife (e. g. , creating a wetland). The popularity and proven benefits of habitat restoration and creation is evidenced by the length of this chapter which, at 54 pages, is the longest in the book. The authors did an excellent job of providing readers with a treasure trove of information on the subject. More than any other chapter, this one gives the reader the greatest feeling of hope. The literature shows that when provided with a new home, amphibians will move in.

Amphibian Conservation is a welcome antidote to the proliferation of depressing reports of amphibian declines. The book is packed with literature summaries and citations; a veritable information goldmine for graduate students and researchers. It also admirably provides decision makers with a well-researched resource of proven interventions that can be employed to stem/reverse the decline of amphibian populations. The free, downloadable pdf version and other relatively inexpensive formats that are available (eBook, for example) generously provide individuals who lack deep pockets access to this significant source of information. Interventions described in the book are available at the Conservation Evidence Project website (www. conservationevidence.com) where one can also peruse the open-access journal Conservation Evidence. My only caution for the reader is to take seriously the authors’ advice and perform supplementary reviews of the literature for their particular topic or species of interest. To do otherwise risks missing pertinent and important information not captured in Amphibian Conservation.


John G. Palis

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Amphibian Conservation 2
Amphibian Conservation 3
Contents 5
Advisory board 10
About the authors 11
Acknowledgements 12
About this book 13
The purpose of Conservation Evidence synopses 13
Who is this synopsis for? 13
The Conservation Evidence project 13
Scope of the Amphibian Conservation synopsis 14
Husbandry vs conservation of species 14
How we decided which conservation interventions to include 15
How we reviewed the literature 15
How the evidence is summarized 15
Terminology used to describe evidence 16
Taxonomy 17
Habitats 17
Significant results 17
Multiple interventions 17
How you can help to change conservation practice. 18
Threat: Residential and commercial development 19
Key messages 19
Protect brownfield or ex-industrial sites 19
Restrict herbicide, fungicide and pesticide use on and around ponds on golf courses 19
Legal protection of species 19
1.1 Protect brownfield or ex-industrial sites 19
1.2 Restrict herbicide, fungicide and pesticide use on and around ponds on golf courses 20
1.3 Legal protection of species 20
Threat: Agriculture 22
Key messages – engage farmers and other volunteers 22
Pay farmers to cover the costs of conservation measures 22
Engage landowners and other volunteers to manage land for amphibians 22
Key messages – terrestrial habitat management 22
Manage cutting regime 22
Manage grazing regime 22
Reduced tillage 22
Maintain or restore hedges 22
Plant new hedges 23
Manage silviculture practices in plantations 23
Key messages – aquatic habitat management 23
Exclude domestic animals or wild hogs by fencing 23
Manage ditches 23
Engage farmers and other volunteers 23
2.1 Pay farmers to cover the costs of conservation measures 23
2.2 Engage landowners and other volunteers to manage land for amphibians 25
Terrestrial habitat management 28
2.3 Manage cutting regime 28
2.4 Manage grazing regime 28
2.5 Reduce tillage 30
2.6 Maintain or restore hedges 30
2.7 Plant new hedges 31
2.8 Manage silviculture practices in plantations 31
Aquatic habitat management 31
2.9 Exclude domestic animals or wild hogs by fencing 31
2.10 Manage ditches 33
Threat: Energy production and mining 35
Key messages 35
Artificially mist habitat to keep it damp 35
3.1 Artificially mist habitat to keep it damp 35
Threat: Transportation and service corridors 36
Key messages 36
Install culverts or tunnels as road crossings 36
Install barrier fencing along roads 36
Modify gully pots and kerbs 36
Use signage to warn motorists 36
Close roads during seasonal amphibian migration 36
Use humans to assist migrating amphibians across roads 36
4.1 Install culverts or tunnels as road crossings 37
4.2 Install barrier fencing along roads 46
4.3 Modify gully pots and kerbs 48
4.4 Use signage to warn motorists 49
4.5 Close roads during seasonal amphibian migration 49
4.6 Use humans to assist migrating amphibians across roads 50
Threat: Human intrusions and disturbance 75
Key messages 75
Use signs and access restrictions to reduce disturbance 75
6.1 Use signs and access restrictions to reduce disturbance 75
Threat: Natural system modifications 76
Key messages 76
Use prescribed fire or modifications to burning regime 76
Use herbicides to control mid-storey or ground vegetation 76
Mechanically remove mid-storey or ground vegetation 76
Regulate water levels 76
7.1 Use prescribed fire or modifications to burning regime 76
7.1.1 Forests 77
7.1.2 Grassland 82
7.2 Use herbicides to control mid-storey or ground vegetation 83
7.3 Mechanically remove mid-storey or ground vegetation 84
7.4 Regulate water levels 85
Threat: Pollution 123
Key messages – agricultural pollution 123
Plant riparian buffer strips 123
Prevent pollution from agricultural lands or sewage treatment facilities entering watercourses 123
Create walls or barriers to exclude pollutants 123
Reduce pesticide, herbicide or fertilizer use 123
Key messages – industrial pollution 123
Add limestone to water bodies to reduce acidification 123
Augment ponds with ground water to reduce acidification 124
Agricultural pollution 124
9.1 Plant riparian buffer strips 124
9.2 Prevent pollution from agricultural lands or sewage treatment facilities entering watercourses 124
9.3 Create walls or barriers to exclude pollutants 125
9.4 Reduce pesticide, herbicide or fertilizer use 125
Industrial pollution 126
9.5 Add limestone to water bodies to reduce acidification 126
9.6 Augment ponds with ground water to reduce acidification 128
Threat: Climate change and severe weather 129
Key messages 129
Use irrigation systems for amphibian sites 129
Maintain ephemeral ponds 129
Deepen ponds to prevent desiccation 129
Provide shelter habitat 129
Artificially shade ponds to prevent desiccation 129
Create microclimate and microhabitat refuges 129
Protect habitat along elevational gradients 129
10.1 Use irrigation systems for amphibian sites 129
10.2 Maintain ephemeral ponds 130
10.3 Deepen ponds to prevent desiccation 130
10.4 Provide shelter habitat 130
10.5 Artificially shade ponds to prevent desiccation 131
10.6 Create microclimate and microhabitat refuges 131
10.7 Protect habitat along elevational gradients 131
Habitat protection 132
Key messages 132
Protect habitats for amphibians 132
Retain connectivity between habitat patches 132
Retain buffer zones around core habitat 132
11.1 Protect habitats for amphibians 132
11.2 Retain connectivity between habitat patches 134
11.3 Retain buffer zones around core habitat 134
Education and awareness raising 249
Key messages 249
Raise awareness amongst the general public through campaigns and public information 249
Provide education programmes about amphibians 249
Engage volunteers to collect amphibian data (citizen science) 249
14.1 Raise awareness amongst the general public through campaigns and public information 250
14.2 Provide education programmes about amphibians 252
14.3 Engage volunteers to collect amphibian data (citizen science) 254
Index 257