Menu Expand
Risk Revisited

Risk Revisited

Pat Caplan

(2000)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

This book looks at the concept of risk from a cross-cultural perspective, the contributors challenge the Eurocentric frameworks within which notions of risk are more commonly considered.

They argue that perceptions of danger, and sources of anxiety, are far more socially and culturally constructed - and far more contingent - than risk theorists generally admit. Topics covered include prostitutes in London; AIDS in Tanzania; the cease-fire in Northern Ireland; the volcanic eruptions in Montserrat; modernisation in Amazonia; and the BSE scare in Britain.
'An authoritative and compelling text exploring risk from a variety of cultural perspectives, highly recommended reading to anyone studying social sciences'
Stuart Agnew, Lecturer in Criminology

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Contents iii
Introduction: Risk Revisited 1
RISK:THE DEBATES 1
THE COLLECTION 14
THEMES ARISING 20
THE REFLEXIVITY OF MODERNITY:ANTHROPOLOGY AND SOCIOLOGY 24
BIBLIOGRAPHY 26
1. The Politics of Risk among London Prostitutes 29
INTRODUCTION 29
BACKGROUND: THE PRAED STREET PROJECT 31
GOVERNING RISK: HIV, THE PROSTITUTE AND THE STATESMAN 34
MEDICALISATION AND RISK 36
COMPARISON: RISK AS A MEASURE OF ALL THINGS 39
A SOCIAL MOVEMENT 41
INSIDE, NOT OUTSIDE THE STATE 42
RISK AND REFLEXIVITY 48
CONCLUSION 49
NOTES 53
2. Risk and Trust: Unsafe Sex, Gender and AIDS in Tanzania 59
BECK AND GIDDENS: RELEVANT PARADIGMS? 60
AN INAPPROPRIATE FRAMEWORK? 62
RISK AND TRUST IN THE AIDS LITERATURE 64
DEFINING RISK AND TRUST IN THE TANZANIAN CONTEXT 65
AIDS IN LUSHOTO 66
EXPLAINING AIDS IN LUSHOTO 68
VARIETY OF MALE RESPONSES 70
WOMEN ’S RESPONSES 72
CONDOMS AND SAFER/UNSAFE SEX 73
CONCLUSION 77
NOTES 78
REFERENCES 82
3. 'Conflicting Models of Risk': Clinical Genetics and British Pakistanis 85
INTRODUCTION 85
‘THIS IS MY QISMAT (FATE)’ 85
CLINICAL VIEWS OF GENETIC RISK 89
GENETIC RISK AND BRITISH PAKISTANIS 90
THE CLINICAL VIEW IN SOCIAL AND CULTURAL CONTEXT 91
CLINICAL SOLUTIONS 93
PAKISTANI ATTITUDES TO RISK IN SOCIAL AND\r CULTURAL CONTEXT 94
ISLAM, FATALISM AND THE ROLE OF SAINTS 97
FAMILY HISTORIES AND HOUSEHOLD DYNAMICS 99
CONCLUSION 103
NOTES 104
REFERENCES 104
4. Risk-talk: the Politics of Risk and its Representation 108
THE POLITICS OF RISK REPRESENTATION 108
NUCLEAR RISK – A DISCUSSION 110
RISK AND BLAME 112
GENDER AND RISK IN INDIA 114
WOMEN AND RISK IN THE LOW-INCOME\r SETTLEMENTS OF CHENNAI 119
NEGOTIATING RISK 122
JUGGLING RISKS 126
CONCLUSION 128
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 129
NOTES 129
REFERENCES 130
5. A Risky Cease-fire: British Infantry Soldiers and Northern Ireland 133
PRELUDE 133
INTRODUCTION 133
TRAINING AND THREATS 135
CONCEPTUALISING RISK 140
INTERNALISING THE ENEMY 144
EXTERNALISING THE CONFLICT 149
CONCLUSION 151
NOTES 153
REFERENCES 154
6. The Eruption of Chances Peak, Montserrat, and the Narrative Containment of Risk 156
INTRODUCTION 156
RISK AND NARRATIVE AS RESEARCH TOPICS 159
LIVING ON THE VOLCANO OF MONTSERRAT 164
NARRATIVE, RADIO AND THE CONTAINMENT OF RISK ON MONTSERRAT 171
CONCLUSION 177
NOTES 178
REFERENCES 179
7. 'Eating British Beef with Confidence': A Consideration of Consumers' Responses to BSE in Britain 184
BRITISH BEEF AND ITS MEANINGS 186
FOOD AND FOOD SCARES 186
THE CONCEPTS OF HEALTHY EATING RESEARCH PROJECTS 187
THE SECOND BSE SCARE 193
RESTORING PUBLIC CONFIDENCE 197
CONCLUSION: RISK KNOWLEDGE,TRUST AND LOCATION 199
NOTES 199
REFERENCES 200
8. Risk, Ambiguity and the Loss of Control: How People with a Chronic Illness Experience Complex Biomedical Causal Models 204
INTRODUCTION 204
RISK AND CAUSALITY 208
TYPE II DIABETES AND PATIENTS ’ PERCEPTIONS OF RISK 211
RISK AND CONTROL 218
NOTES 221
REFERENCES 221
9. Good Risk, Bad Risk: Reflexive Modernisation and Amazonia 226
BECK ’S RISK ANALYSIS 228
ECOLOGICAL PANACEA OR PANEGYRIC? 232
WORKING TOWARDS RISK IN AMAZONIA 233
AMAZONIA AND THE DOCTRINE OF TROPICAL NASTINESS 237
INADVERTENT RISK 239
OPERATIONALISING RISK IN AMAZONIA 240
RISK MANAGERS 242
CONCLUSION 245
REFERENCES 247
Contributors 249
Index 251
Africa 15
and modernity, 15 15
gender inequality, 63 63
gender inequality, 69-70 69
sexuality in, 61 61
sexuality in, 67 67
spread of AIDS in, 59 59
spread of AIDS in, 61 61
spread of AIDS in, 62-3 62
age, factor in risk perception 189
189 189
193 193
agency 17