Menu Expand
Justice for Laughing Boy

Justice for Laughing Boy

Sara Ryan

(2017)

Abstract

On July 4th 2013, Connor Sparrowhawk, also known as Laughing Boy or LB, was found dead in a specialist NHS unit. Connor, who had autism and epilepsy, had a seizure while in the bath and no member of staff was on hand to stop him from drowning. An entirely preventable death.

Sara Ryan presents a frank, sometimes funny and touching account of her son's early life and preventable death and the unfolding #JusticeforLB campaign. This serves as a wake-up call to all of us and asks: can we really claim that we respect the life and dignity of learning disabled people?


This is a story that needs to reach as wide an audience as possible. Only then will people such as Connor receive the care and protection they are entitled to.
Gail McKeitch, parent of two sons with autism, one of whom also has epilepsy
This account of a parent's experience brings to light the vital need to really listen, understand and work alongside people with learning disabilities and their families to ensure that care and support is right for them.
Lyn Romeo, Chief Social Worker for Adults
The echoes of those who no longer speak... no candy coating, it is what it is; a tragedy born from negligence. To quote: 'At the heart of this story is love'. Love 'mobilised a social movement' and love keeps hope alive. Not a good read, a must read.
Dr Wenn B. Lawson, lecturer and author
Anyone who cares about patient safety and fairness should read this book. It will make you cry, it will make you laugh, it will make you think, and I would be amazed if it did not make you passionate about changing things.
Peter Walsh, Chief Executive, Action against Medical Accidents (AvMA)
What happened to Connor shows that people with learning disabilities are still not treated as human beings like everyone else. Professionals need to listen to people with learning disabilities and their families and friends about what their care should be.
Gary Bourlet, Founder of Learning Disability England and self-advocate of learning disabled rights
The heart of this story rises above a narrative of private grief and public failure by offering a powerful eulogy to the sheer force of love, especially the personality and character of Connor Sparrowhawk that helped inspire a social movement for truth, justice and accountability. Everyone committed to accountable public services should read this book and learn from it.
Richard Humphries, Senior Fellow, The King's Fund
This is a book that should never have needed to be written - young "dudes" like Connor should not die untimely deaths and families should not have to fight for justice. However, it is a book that most definitely needs to be read and used to effect change
Ruth Northway OBE FRCN PFHE, Professor of Learning Disability Nursing, University of South Wales
This brilliantly written book is so many things. It's a story of love and loss, a story of people dying preventable deaths because our society doesn't care enough, a story of how what started as one family's battle for accountability turned into a social movement.
Dr Jenny Morris OBE, Visiting Professor of Social Work and Social Policy and policy analyst
Dr Sara Ryan is a social scientist at the University of Oxford, specialising in autism and learning disabilities. Her blog, 'My Daft Life', started before Connor's death, and continues to document the events that followed https://mydaftlife.com.
A searingly powerful book.
Sarah Holmes MBE, Patient Advocate
This is, rightly, a book which makes difficult reading for anyone professionally invested in any part of the system - for exactly the same reasons, it should make compulsory reading.
Alex Ruck Keene, barrister, writer and educator, 39 Essex Chambers
This is a beautifully written and deeply moving account of a mother's love for her son. It is a book about how a social movement, inspired by the quest for justice, continues to seek accountability and change following Connor Sparrowhawk's needless death. This book deserves to be read widely and for people to take action from it. #JusticeForLB
Rhidian Hughes, Voluntary Organisations Disability Group
A truly remarkable book that should never have had to be written, and that should be read by literally anyone who cares about their fellow human being; Sara brings beauty to her narrative, juxtaposed to the brutal ugliness of the subject matter, juxtaposed to the heart wrenching loving memory of a son taken from his family before his time. An emotional roller coaster made even more poignant by reason that the text is so tragically not fictional.
Dr Luke Beardon, Senior Lecturer in Autism, Sheffield Hallam University and author
A salutary lesson on what happens when public services lose their heart and forget that they exist to serve the public and, in particular, be part of addressing the prejudices and disadvantage that are inherent in our society.
Rob Greig CBE, Chief Executive, National Development Team for Inclusion

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Justice for Laughing Boy: Connor Sparrowhawk – A Death by Indifference by Sara Ryan 8
Foreword by Baroness Helena Kennedy QC 17
Author's note 21
Chapter 1: What a Wonderful World 29
Connor 30
The early years 33
The blog 37
Chapter 2 : Dog Days, Holidays and Life Rafts 41
The epilepsy 45
Chunky Stan, 2003–16 49
Negotiating mediocrity and the life raft 51
Chapter 3: Nudging Adulthood 57
The halcyon years 57
The lack of an imagined future 59
A taste of the future 61
The downturn 62
Opening up the blog 66
Choice and hindsight 68
Epilepsy reaches the Unit 70
Chapter 4 : The Fallout 79
The relatives room 79
Death decisions 80
A human rights intervention 83
Post-death work 84
No ‘First Fit’ clinic in life or death 86
Connor’s do 89
Death of a Service Chapter 5: User 97
Mother-blame 100
CQC report and inquiries 101
Introducing ‘natural causes’ 104
Death by Indifference 106
Criticisms of Southern Health and its responses 108
Dirty lenses and human rights 110
Chapter 6: The Seeds of Justice for LB 115
A devastating discovery 120
Gaining momentum and friends 123
107 days of action 126
Chapter 7: The Waiting Game 138
Death anniversaries 142
Chapter 8: A Very Adversarial Affair 151
Securing a jury 155
The final pre-inquest hearing 158
The 161
Summer 2015: Verita 2 and the Mazars findings 164
1 October 2015: the week before the inquest 166
Chapter 9: The Inquest 169
The Coroner’s Court 171
The jury 173
The family room 176
Early days 178
The locked door and continued seizure denial 180
Dr Murphy and more 182
Mother-blame revisited 183
Chapter 10: Taking the Stand 188
An earlier death 188
Giving evidence 192
The jury retire 198
The determination 200
Chapter 11: Stumbling into Scandal 209
The Mazars findings 209
LB’s story spreads 212
A voicemail message 215
The extraordinary board meeting 216
Chapter 12: Crime and Justice 221
Jeremy Hunt 224
Introducing the mermaids 225
Rolling heads 227
230
234
Chapter 13: Justice for Connor Sparrowhawk and all the young dudes 240
Appendix A: The Connor Manifesto 248
What does 248
Appendix B: The cast of 251
Acknowledgements 270
Blank Page