Menu Expand
On Retaliation

On Retaliation

Bertram Turner | Günther Schlee

(2017)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Retaliation is associated with all forms of social and political organization, and retaliatory logics inform many different conflict resolution procedures from consensual settlement to compensation to violent escalations. This book derives a concept of retaliation from the overall notion of reciprocity, defining retaliation as the human disposition to strive for a reactive balancing of conflicts and injustices. On Retaliation presents a synthesized approach to both the violence-generating and violence-avoiding potentials of retaliation. Contributors to this volume touch upon the interaction between retaliation and violence, the state’s monopoly on legitimate punishment and the factors of socio-political frameworks, religious interpretations and economic processes.


On Retaliation is impressive, exciting and full of insight. It will be a valuable and widely referred to contribution to academic scholarship and to policy formation in an extremely critical area of national and global concern.” · Andrew Arno, University of Hawai’i


Bertram Turner is an anthropologist and a senior researcher in the department ‘Law and Anthropology’ at the Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology in Halle, Germany. He has conducted extended field research in the Middle East and North Africa, Germany and Canada and has held university teaching positions in Munich, Leipzig and Halle and has published widely on the anthropology of law, religion, conflict, morality, development and resource extraction.


Günther Schlee is one of the Founding Directors of the Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology in Halle, Germany. He conducted fieldwork in Kenya, Ethiopia and Sudan, and was a guest lecturer in Padang (Sumatra) and at the Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Science Sociales in Paris. Currently, he is one of the spokespersons of the International Max Planck Research School on Retaliation, Mediation and Punishment

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
On Retaliation i
On Retaliation - Towards an Interdisciplinary Understanding of a Basic Human Condition - Edited by Bertram Turner and Günther Schlee iii
Contents v
Figures and Tables vii
Acknowledgements viii
Introduction - On Retaliation - Conceptual Plurality, Transdisciplinary Research, Rifts, Blurrings and Translations - Bertram Turner 1
Section I - Retaliation and the Human Nature - The Search for Universalities? 27
Chapter 1 - Revenge and Retaliation - A Social-Functionalist Approach - Mario Gollwitzer and Arne Sjöström 29
Chapter 2 - In the Heat of the Moment - The Influence of Visceral Factorson Retaliation - Robert J. Bies and Thomas M. Tripp 47
Section II - Retaliation in Psychological and Economic Analyses of Crime and Deviance 67
Chapter 3 - A Criminal is a Victim is a Criminal? An Economist’s View on the Victim–Offender Overlap - Horst Entorf 69
Chapter 4 - Laypeople’s Reactions to Deviancy as Determined by Retributive Motives - Margit E. Oswald 81
Section III - Retaliation and Punishment - Encounter of Formal and Informal Normativities 99
Chapter 5 - Violent Crimes and Retaliation in the European Criminal Justice System between the Seventeenth and Nineteenth Centuries - Karl Härter 101
Chapter 6 - Crime in Motion - Predation, Retaliation and the Spread of Urban Violence - Richard Wright, Volkan Topalli and Scott Jacques 122
Section IV - Faith-Based Retaliation - Spirituality and Normativity of the Retaliatory Grammar 143
Chapter 7 - Crime and Punishment - Intentionality and Diya in Algeria and Sudan - Yazid Ben Hounet 145
Chapter 8 - ‘Bewitched People and Bad Luck Everywhere!’ - Disputing and Magical Retaliation in SiSwati-Speaking Southern Africa - Severin Lenart 164
Section V - Retaliation in Negotiations and Organizations of Social and Political Orders 183
Chapter 9 - Forum Shopping as Retaliation in Disguise - How Nomadic Fulbe Condemn Retaliation and Forum Shopping, But Practise Them Anyway - Albert K. Drent 185
Chapter 10 - Customary Law and the Joys of Statelessness - Somali Realities beyond Libertarian Fantasies - Günther Schlee 208
Section VI - Travelling Models of Retaliation - Postconflict Scenarios in International Law and on the Ground 237
Chapter 11 - Retaliation in Postwar Times - An Analysis of the Rhetoric and Practices of Retaliation in Bamyan, Afghanistan, 2009 - Friederike Stahlmann 239
Chapter 12 - The International Criminal Court Reparation System - Punishment, Retaliation, Restoration - Pietro Sullo 257
Conclusion - Retaliation in Specific Spheres of Effectiveness - Bertram Turner 283
Index 307