Menu Expand
Decolonising Intervention

Decolonising Intervention

Meera Sabaratnam

(2017)

Additional Information

Abstract

Building, or re-building, states after war or crisis is a contentious process. But why? Sabaratnam argues that to best answer the question, we need to engage with the people who are supposedly benefiting from international ‘expertise’.

This book challenges and enhances standard ‘critical’ narratives of statebuilding by exploring the historical experiences and interpretive frameworks of the people targeted by intervention. Drawing on face-to-face interviews, archival research, policy reviews and in-country participant-observations carried out over several years, the author challenges assumptions underpinning
external interventions, such as the incapacity of ‘local’ agents to govern and the necessity of ‘liberal’ values in demanding better governance. The analysis focuses on Mozambique, long hailed as one of international donors’ great success stories, but whose peaceful, prosperous, democratic future now hangs in the balance. The conclusions underscore the significance of thinking with rather than for the targets of state-building assistance, and appreciating the historical and material conditions which underpin these reform efforts.

Indeed, if international relations as a discipline wants to take forward its aim of better understanding world politics, it can benefit greatly from Sabaratnam’s contribution to debates on the ‘coloniality of power’ and the much wider application of the decolonizing strategies it presents. Decolonising Intervention is an indispensable resource for those interested in the relationship between international intervention and statebuilding.


This powerful book provides a brilliant and devastating critique of international statebuilding interventions. Through a compelling analysis of the politics of intervention in Mozambique and the experiences of those whose lives are affected, Sabaratnam shows how relations of colonial difference have shaped and enabled these practices. Highly engaging and accessible, yet analytically incisive and authoritative, Decolonising Intervention is essential and indelible reading for international relations scholars, aid practitioners, and anyone concerned with questions of conflict, peace, justice and responsibility.
Devon Curtis, Senior Lecturer, Department of Politics and International Studies, University of Cambridge
Meera Sabaratnam is Senior Lecturer in International Relations at SOAS, University of London.
Dr. Sabaratnam has written an original and compelling book on the dialectics of international development practices in Mozambique. Based on sophisticated ethnographic research, combined with a superb grasp of the postcolonial and international relations literature, Decolonising Intervention will quickly establish itself as the benchmark for originality in de-colonial scholarship. Rarely does one find a book on critical international relations, and especially on state-building in Africa, written with such unrelenting clarity.
Randolph B. Persaud, Associate Professor, School of International Service, American University, Washington, DC

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover 1
Half Title i
Series Information ii
Title Page iii
Copyright Page iv
Dedication v
Contents vii
Acknowledgements ix
Chapter One Introduction 1
Exploring the Politics of Intervention 5
Decolonising International Relations 6
Researching Intervention in Mozambique 9
Structure of the Book 10
Notes 12
Part I Decolonising Critique 15
Chapter Two Intervention, Statebuilding and Eurocentrism 17
The Beginner’s Guide to Nation-Building 18
What Is Eurocentrism and How Does It Locate the Political? 20
Critiques of Intervention and the Problem of Eurocentrism 23
Bypassing the Targets of Intervention: Research Design 23
Bypassing the Targets of Intervention: Governmentality Approaches 25
Ontologies of Otherness: Liberal-Local Relations, Hybridity and Resistance 27
The ‘Everyday’ and Hermeneutic Containment 30
Nostalgia for Social Contract Politics, Welfare Democracy and the Liberal Political Subject 32
Conclusion 34
Notes 35
Chapter Three Strategies for Decolonising Intervention 37
Strategies for Reconstructing Subjecthood 38
Recovering Historical Presence 39
Engaging Political Consciousness 42
Investigating Material Realities 45
Feminist Standpoint, ‘Objectivity’ and Epistemic Privilege 47
Conclusion to Part I 54
Notes 55
Part II Rethinking Intervention 57
Chapter Four The State Under Intervention 59
Building the Postcolonial State 60
International Intervention in Mozambique after the War 62
What Kind of State Has Been Built? 64
Fragmentation of State Infrastructure 64
Disappearance of Human Resources 67
Capacity-Building? 69
Citizen Experiences of Public Services under Intervention 72
Thinking Like a Target of International Intervention 74
Notes 81
Chapter Five Intervention and the Peasantry 83
The Political Significance of the Peasantry 85
Peasant Experiences of Intervention in the Agricultural Sector 87
Promoting Productivity 88
Rural Financing 90
Producing for the Market 92
Agricultural Policies, the State and International Intervention 96
The Peasant Movement and Alternative Visions of Development 100
The Mozambican Peasantry and the Long View of Intervention 103
Notes 109
Chapter Six Anti-Corruption and the Limits of Intervention 111
Good Governance and the Prospect of Radical Critique 112
‘Isso Não Acontecia se Samora Estivesse Vivo’ – ‘This Would Not Be Happening If Samora Was Alive’ 116
Bloodsucking, Greed and Power 122
Anti-Corruption and Intervention 126
Notes 129
Chapter Seven Conclusions: Decolonising Intervention, Decolonising International Relations 131
What Have We Learned about International Statebuilding? Protagonismo, Disposability, Entitlement and Dependency 132
Coloniality of Power as Structural Account of International Intervention 135
(How) Can We Decolonise Intervention? 141
Notes 146
References 147
Index 165
About the Author 173