Additional Information
Book Details
Abstract
The Fifth Edition of the highly praised Practical Guide for Medical Teachers provides a bridge between the theoretical aspects of medical education and the delivery of enthusiastic and effective teaching in basic science and clinical medicine. Healthcare professionals are committed teachers and this book is an essential guide to help them maximise their performance.
- This highly regarded book recognises the importance of educational skills in the delivery of quality teaching in medicine.
- The contents offer valuable insights into all important aspects of medical education today.
- A leading educationalist from the USA joins the book’s editorial team.
- The continual emergence of new topics is recognised in this new edition with nine new chapters: The role of patients as teachers and assessors; Medical humanities; Decision-making; Alternative medicine; Global awareness; Education at a time of ubiquitous information; Programmative assessment; Student engagement; and Social accountability.
- An enlarged group of authors from more than 15 countries provides both an international perspective and a multi-professional approach to topics of interest to all healthcare teachers.
Table of Contents
Section Title | Page | Action | Price |
---|---|---|---|
Front Cover | cover | ||
Inside Front Cover | ifc1 | ||
A Practical Guide for Medical Teachers | i | ||
Copyright Page | iv | ||
Table Of Contents | v | ||
Foreword | ix | ||
Preface | xi | ||
Contributors | xii | ||
1 Curriculum Development | 1 | ||
1 New horizons in medical education | 2 | ||
Integration of information | 2 | ||
Changing learning situations | 3 | ||
An authentic curriculum | 3 | ||
Students and student engagement | 3 | ||
Summary | 3 | ||
References | 3 | ||
2 Curriculum planning and development | 4 | ||
Introduction | 4 | ||
What is a curriculum? | 4 | ||
Identifying the need | 4 | ||
Establishing the learning outcomes | 5 | ||
Agreeing on the content | 5 | ||
Experience as core content | 6 | ||
Organizing the content | 6 | ||
Deciding the educational strategy | 7 | ||
Student-centred learning | 7 | ||
Problem-based learning (PBL) | 7 | ||
Integration and interprofessional learning | 7 | ||
Community-based learning | 7 | ||
Electives | 8 | ||
Systematic approach | 8 | ||
Choosing the teaching methods | 8 | ||
Preparing the assessment | 9 | ||
Communication about the curriculum | 9 | ||
Promoting an appropriate educational or learning environment | 10 | ||
Managing the curriculum | 10 | ||
Summary | 11 | ||
References | 11 | ||
3 The undergraduate curriculum | 13 | ||
Introduction | 13 | ||
Forces shaping the curriculum | 14 | ||
Critical components of the undergraduate medical education programme as they relate to the continuum of medical education | 16 | ||
Summary | 18 | ||
References | 18 | ||
4 Postgraduate medical education | 20 | ||
Introduction | 20 | ||
Functions of PGME and postgraduate trainees in a healthcare system | 20 | ||
Transitions in PGME | 21 | ||
Admissions and matching | 21 | ||
Transition from junior resident to senior resident | 21 | ||
Transition from PGME to practice | 21 | ||
Models of PGME | 21 | ||
The role of internships or foundational training | 22 | ||
Setting for training | 22 | ||
Responsibility for curricular development and management | 22 | ||
Post-certification training | 22 | ||
Teaching, learning and assessment in PGME | 22 | ||
External assessment in PGME: summative, certification | 24 | ||
PGME quality, accreditation and CQI | 24 | ||
Controversies in PGME | 25 | ||
The debate about generalism versus specialism in PGME | 25 | ||
The challenge of resident duty hours | 25 | ||
Training clinical supervisors: faculty development | 26 | ||
The future of PGME | 26 | ||
Summary | 26 | ||
References | 26 | ||
5 Continuing professional development | 28 | ||
Background | 28 | ||
How clinicians learn | 28 | ||
Recognizing an opportunity for improvement | 28 | ||
Searching for resources for learning | 29 | ||
Engaging in learning | 29 | ||
Considering prior knowledge and experience of clinician participants | 30 | ||
Focusing on outcomes important to clinician participants | 30 | ||
Respond positively to the expectations of clinician participants | 31 | ||
Interactivity with multiple methods and multiple exposures | 31 | ||
Longer sessions | 32 | ||
Supportive learning environment | 32 | ||
Trying out what was learned | 32 | ||
Incorporating what was learned | 32 | ||
Assessment and evaluation | 33 | ||
Summary | 33 | ||
References | 33 | ||
6 The hidden curriculum | 35 | ||
Historical context | 35 | ||
Definitions and metaphors | 36 | ||
Definitions | 36 | ||
Metaphors | 37 | ||
Applications: exploring/assessing the hidden curriculum | 37 | ||
Student mistreatment: a case study in applying the HC lens | 39 | ||
Summary | 40 | ||
References | 40 | ||
2 Learning Situations | 43 | ||
7 Lectures | 44 | ||
Lectures in medical teaching | 44 | ||
Pros and cons of lectures as a primary learning event | 44 | ||
Learning in a lecture environment | 44 | ||
Attention in lecture | 45 | ||
Fostering engagement | 45 | ||
Promoting retention | 46 | ||
Organizing a lecture | 46 | ||
Teaching materials | 47 | ||
Audiovisuals | 47 | ||
Audience response system (ARS) | 47 | ||
Lecture recordings | 47 | ||
Active learning in the lecture hall | 48 | ||
Embedded methods | 48 | ||
Note check | 48 | ||
Low stakes writing assignment | 49 | ||
Think-pair-share | 49 | ||
Buzz groups | 49 | ||
Games | 49 | ||
The flipped classroom | 49 | ||
Out-of-class homework | 49 | ||
Developing the activity | 50 | ||
Running the session | 50 | ||
Evaluation | 50 | ||
Summary | 51 | ||
References | 51 | ||
8 Learning in small groups | 52 | ||
What is a small group? | 52 | ||
When to use small groups? | 53 | ||
What format of small-group teaching? | 54 | ||
What type of instructional methods? | 54 | ||
How to effectively conduct a small-group teaching session | 54 | ||
Preparing for the small-group session | 54 | ||
Leading the small-group session | 55 | ||
Conditions for an effective session | 55 | ||
Evaluating (assessing) the small-group session | 56 | ||
Evaluation of small-group teaching and participation | 56 | ||
Summary | 57 | ||
Further information | 57 | ||
9 Learning with patients | 58 | ||
Introduction | 58 | ||
The ‘learning triad’ | 58 | ||
Patients | 59 | ||
Students | 59 | ||
Tutors | 59 | ||
Appropriate knowledge | 59 | ||
Appropriate skills | 60 | ||
Appropriate attitudes | 60 | ||
Educational strategies for bedside teaching | 60 | ||
Strategies for inpatients | 60 | ||
Cox’s cycle | 60 | ||
MiPLAN | 61 | ||
Strategies for outpatients | 61 | ||
Learner-centred approach | 61 | ||
Microskills for students | 61 | ||
Educational strategies applicable to all clinical settings | 61 | ||
Outcome-based education | 61 | ||
Time-efficient strategies for learning and performance | 62 | ||
Structured logbooks | 62 | ||
Task-based learning | 63 | ||
Problem-based learning | 63 | ||
Study guides | 63 | ||
Case studies | 63 | ||
Hospital ward opportunities – models for managing learning in the ward | 63 | ||
Apprenticeship/shadowing a junior doctor model | 63 | ||
Grand rounds | 63 | ||
Business ward round | 63 | ||
Teaching ward round | 63 | ||
Clinical conference | 64 | ||
Training ward | 64 | ||
Ambulatory care opportunities | 64 | ||
when should ambulatory care teaching be provided? | 64 | ||
Traditional venues | 64 | ||
Sitting-in model | 64 | ||
Apprenticeship/parallel consultation model | 64 | ||
Report-back model | 64 | ||
Grandstand model | 64 | ||
Breakout model | 64 | ||
Supervising model | 64 | ||
Additional venues | 64 | ||
Innovative venues | 65 | ||
Ambulatory care teaching centre (ACTC) | 65 | ||
Integrated ambulatory care programme | 65 | ||
Assessment of bedside learning | 65 | ||
Staff development | 65 | ||
Summary | 66 | ||
References | 66 | ||
10 Learning in the community | 68 | ||
Introduction | 68 | ||
What is community-based medical education? | 68 | ||
Goals of CBME | 69 | ||
Preclinical aims | 69 | ||
Clinical aims | 69 | ||
To learn about general practice/ family medicine | 69 | ||
To learn about a particular specialty other than general practice/family medicine | 69 | ||
To learn about primary care | 70 | ||
To learn multiple disciplines concurrently | 70 | ||
Practical principles for successful CBME | 71 | ||
The clinician–patient relationship | 71 | ||
The university–health service relationship | 72 | ||
The government–community relationship | 73 | ||
The personal–professional relationship | 74 | ||
Summary | 74 | ||
References | 75 | ||
Further reading | 75 | ||
11 Learning in rural and remote locations | 76 | ||
Introduction | 76 | ||
Before the learner arrives | 77 | ||
Program support and preceptor preparation | 77 | ||
A well-prepared physician’s office and staff | 77 | ||
Main preceptor/rural medical teacher and engaged colleagues | 78 | ||
Helpful hospital and healthcare organizations | 78 | ||
Community partnerships | 78 | ||
The first day | 78 | ||
During the rotation | 79 | ||
Observation/demonstration/feedback | 80 | ||
Assessment and wrap-up | 81 | ||
Troubled and troubling learners | 82 | ||
Summary | 82 | ||
Acknowledgements | 82 | ||
References | 82 | ||
12 Learning in longitudinal integrated clerkships | 84 | ||
Introduction | 84 | ||
Definition | 84 | ||
History | 85 | ||
Rationale | 86 | ||
Learning imperatives | 86 | ||
Professional imperatives | 87 | ||
Health system imperatives | 87 | ||
Societal imperatives | 87 | ||
Model types | 87 | ||
Generalist model LICs | 88 | ||
Multi-specialty ‘streams’ model LICs | 88 | ||
Strengths of LICs | 88 | ||
For individual students, doctors, and patients | 88 | ||
For organisations | 89 | ||
For communities | 89 | ||
Challenges of LICs | 90 | ||
For the individual students and faculty | 90 | ||
For organisations | 90 | ||
For communities | 90 | ||
Future visions | 90 | ||
Summary | 90 | ||
References | 91 | ||
13 Learning in a simulated environment | 92 | ||
Introduction | 92 | ||
Background | 92 | ||
Simulation as design | 93 | ||
Simulated patients | 93 | ||
Simulated patient methodology and trends in medical education | 94 | ||
Fundamental concepts in simulated patient methodology | 94 | ||
Discourses of clinical competence | 94 | ||
Scope of SP practice | 94 | ||
Hybrid simulations | 95 | ||
Patients’ voices | 95 | ||
Qualities of simulated patients | 95 | ||
Supporting simulated patients in role portrayal and feedback | 96 | ||
Simulation technology | 96 | ||
Physical models | 97 | ||
Virtual reality simulators | 97 | ||
Hybrid simulators | 97 | ||
Current and future trends | 98 | ||
Simulation in the twenty-first century | 98 | ||
Summary | 99 | ||
References | 99 | ||
Further reading and resources | 100 | ||
14 Distance education | 101 | ||
Before you begin … | 101 | ||
Introduction to the course | 101 | ||
Learning activities | 102 | ||
Objectives | 102 | ||
Contents | 102 | ||
What is distance learning? | 103 | ||
Technology and distance learning | 104 | ||
Feedback | 105 | ||
Technology | 105 | ||
105 | |||
The structure of a distance learning text | 105 | ||
Feedback | 106 | ||
Providing students with feedback on learning | 107 | ||
Blending different elements of the course | 107 | ||
Managing clinical attachments by distance learning | 108 | ||
Feedback | 108 | ||
The student’s learning experience | 109 | ||
Managing distance learning | 109 | ||
Development of distance learning courses (Table 14.11) | 110 | ||
Quality assurance in distance learning | 111 | ||
Feedback | 111 | ||
Conclusion | 111 | ||
References | 111 | ||
Further reading | 112 | ||
3 Educational Strategies and Technologies | 113 | ||
15 Outcome-based education | 114 | ||
A move from process to product | 114 | ||
The trend towards OBE | 114 | ||
Why the move to OBE? | 115 | ||
Attention to quality of care and neglected areas of competence | 115 | ||
The problem of information overload | 115 | ||
Assessment of the learner’s progress and the continuum of education | 115 | ||
Student-centred and individualized learning | 116 | ||
Accountability | 116 | ||
Implementation of OBE | 116 | ||
Learning outcomes and instructional objectives | 116 | ||
Outcome frameworks | 117 | ||
Selecting or preparing an outcome framework | 117 | ||
Implementing OBE | 118 | ||
An outcome-based curriculum | 119 | ||
Myths about OBE | 120 | ||
Summary | 120 | ||
References | 120 | ||
16 Integrated learning | 122 | ||
Introduction | 122 | ||
Some definitions | 122 | ||
Rationale for integrated learning | 123 | ||
Strategies for integrated learning | 123 | ||
Barriers to integrated learning | 125 | ||
Integrated student assessment | 126 | ||
Summary | 127 | ||
References | 127 | ||
17 Interprofessional education | 128 | ||
Definitions | 128 | ||
History | 128 | ||
The rationale for IPE | 128 | ||
Curriculum development | 129 | ||
Learning activities | 130 | ||
Assessment | 130 | ||
Post-qualification | 131 | ||
Impact and effectiveness of IPE | 131 | ||
Faculty development for IPE | 132 | ||
Overcoming challenges | 132 | ||
Summary | 132 | ||
References | 133 | ||
18 Problem-based learning | 134 | ||
Perspectives in problem-based learning | 134 | ||
Problem-based learning format | 134 | ||
Creating PBL courses: a systems perspective | 134 | ||
Writing PBL cases | 135 | ||
Running PBL small groups | 136 | ||
Faculty as tutor | 136 | ||
Evaluating PBL session outcomes | 137 | ||
PBL controversies | 137 | ||
Outcomes of PBL courses | 137 | ||
Reasons to consider using a PBL approach | 137 | ||
General disadvantages of small-group learning | 138 | ||
Specific disadvantages of PBL as a learning format | 138 | ||
Issues with PBL as an educational methodology | 138 | ||
Matching learning objectives with educational methodology | 138 | ||
Extraneous load | 138 | ||
Variable session experiences | 138 | ||
Scaffolding | 139 | ||
Resource use | 139 | ||
Issues with students | 139 | ||
Small-group dysfunction | 139 | ||
Student preparation | 139 | ||
Evaluation and outcomes | 139 | ||
Issues with tutors | 139 | ||
Active learning beyond the PBL format – expanding the educator toolbox | 139 | ||
Summary | 140 | ||
Reference | 141 | ||
Further reading | 141 | ||
19 Team-based learning | 143 | ||
What is team-based learning? | 143 | ||
How does TBL work? | 143 | ||
Students’ perspective | 143 | ||
TBL recurring steps | 143 | ||
Step 1 – advance assignment | 143 | ||
Out-of-class/individual | 143 | ||
Step 2 – iRAT – individual readiness assurance test | 143 | ||
In-class/individual | 143 | ||
Step 3 – tRAT – team readiness assurance test | 143 | ||
In-class/team | 143 | ||
Step 4 – instructor clarification review | 144 | ||
In-class/instructor | 144 | ||
Step 5 – team application – tAPP | 145 | ||
In-class/team | 145 | ||
Step 3A and/or 6 – appeal | 145 | ||
In-class/out-of-class/team | 145 | ||
TBL nonrecurring steps | 145 | ||
Orientation | 145 | ||
Out-of-class/in-class/individual/team | 145 | ||
Peer evaluation | 145 | ||
Out-of-class/individual | 145 | ||
What does a TBL session look like? | 145 | ||
What are the ingredients for a successful TBL module? | 146 | ||
Instructor’s perspective | 146 | ||
TBL recurring steps | 146 | ||
Step 1 – situational factors and learning goals | 146 | ||
Step 2 – tAPP – team application | 147 | ||
Step 3 – iRAT/tRAT – individual readiness assurance test/team readiness assurance test | 147 | ||
Step 4 – advance assignment | 148 | ||
Step 5 – instructor clarification review | 148 | ||
Step 6 – appeal | 148 | ||
TBL nonrecurring steps | 148 | ||
Team formation | 148 | ||
Orientation | 148 | ||
Peer evaluation | 148 | ||
Why does TBL work? | 148 | ||
Accountability | 148 | ||
Immediate feedback | 148 | ||
Solving authentic problems | 148 | ||
Engagement with course content | 148 | ||
Learning to work collaboratively | 148 | ||
What can go wrong with TBL? | 148 | ||
Is TBL worth the effort? | 150 | ||
One instructor; same message | 150 | ||
One classroom; no spreading around or finding more faculty | 150 | ||
In-class meetings; all happens in the classroom | 150 | ||
Individual accountability; no social loafing | 150 | ||
Simultaneous reporting; no presentations | 150 | ||
Instructor clarification; immediate feedback | 150 | ||
Naturally functional teams; no teamwork instruction | 150 | ||
Self-directed and lifelong learning | 150 | ||
Summary | 151 | ||
References | 151 | ||
Online resources | 151 | ||
20 Using digital technologies | 152 | ||
Introduction | 152 | ||
The digital technology repertoire | 152 | ||
Using technology in medical education | 153 | ||
Why use digital technology? | 153 | ||
Exponential connectivity and integration | 154 | ||
Accelerating speed of action and response | 154 | ||
Defeating geography and temporality | 154 | ||
Observation | 154 | ||
Technology and instructional design | 154 | ||
Who are your learners and what learning processes work best for them? | 155 | ||
What are the learning and performance contexts you are working with? | 155 | ||
What content will be involved, how should it be structured and sequenced? | 155 | ||
What instructional and non-instructional strategies should you use? | 155 | ||
What media and delivery systems will you use? | 156 | ||
How will you actually conduct the design processes? | 156 | ||
Mobile technologies | 156 | ||
Preparing for e-health | 157 | ||
Hidden curriculum and digital technologies | 157 | ||
Digital professionalism | 159 | ||
The role of the medical e-teacher | 159 | ||
Summary | 160 | ||
References | 160 | ||
Further reading | 161 | ||
21 Instructional design | 162 | ||
Introduction | 162 | ||
The ADDIE model | 162 | ||
The universe of ID models | 163 | ||
Outcomes-based models | 163 | ||
Whole-task models | 164 | ||
Examples of ID models | 165 | ||
Cognitive load theory | 165 | ||
Nine events of instruction | 166 | ||
Four-component instructional design (4C/ID) | 166 | ||
Summary | 168 | ||
References | 168 | ||
4 Curriculum Themes | 171 | ||
22 Basic sciences and curriculum outcomes | 172 | ||
Introduction | 172 | ||
The changing medical curriculum | 172 | ||
Authentic learning in basic science courses | 173 | ||
The active learning environment | 174 | ||
Use of reflective practice, critical thinking and clinical reasoning | 174 | ||
Innovations in teaching basic sciences | 175 | ||
Basic science integration throughout the curriculum | 176 | ||
Nontraditional discipline-independent skills | 176 | ||
Leadership | 176 | ||
Teamwork | 176 | ||
Professionalism | 176 | ||
Communication skills | 176 | ||
Student well-being | 176 | ||
Assessment of discipline-independent skills | 177 | ||
Learning basic science outside curricular structure | 177 | ||
Summary | 177 | ||
References | 178 | ||
23 Social and behavioural sciences in medical school curricula | 180 | ||
Introduction | 180 | ||
Why are the social and behavioural sciences important in medicine? | 180 | ||
What topics should be included in the curriculum? | 181 | ||
Biological mediators of SBS factors and health | 181 | ||
Social and cultural determinants of health, illness and disease | 182 | ||
Patient behaviour | 182 | ||
The experience of illness | 182 | ||
Physician–patient interactions | 182 | ||
Physician role and behaviour | 182 | ||
Health policy and economics | 183 | ||
Where and when should SBS be presented in the curriculum? | 183 | ||
Discipline-specific curricula | 183 | ||
Multidisciplinary | 183 | ||
Interdisciplinary | 183 | ||
Who should do the teaching design and delivery? | 184 | ||
How can SBS be learnt, taught and assessed? | 184 | ||
Assessment | 185 | ||
How do we implement an SBS curriculum? | 186 | ||
Summary | 186 | ||
References | 186 | ||
Further reading | 187 | ||
24 Clinical communication | 188 | ||
Introduction | 188 | ||
Using role play | 188 | ||
Rationale | 188 | ||
Formats for role play | 189 | ||
Conducting a role play session | 190 | ||
The wider context | 190 | ||
Other aspects of spoken communication | 190 | ||
Medical records | 191 | ||
Communication and HI-FIDELITY simulation | 191 | ||
Communication between colleagues | 191 | ||
Reading and writing | 192 | ||
Language, culture and the international medical graduate (IMG) | 192 | ||
Professionalism | 193 | ||
Assessment | 193 | ||
Conclusion | 193 | ||
References | 193 | ||
Relevant websites | 194 | ||
Teaching resources available online | 194 | ||
Support for the international doctor | 194 | ||
25 Ethics and attitudes | 195 | ||
Introduction | 195 | ||
Critical challenges | 195 | ||
Challenge 1: the changing doctor–patient relationship | 195 | ||
Challenge 2: cultural pluralism | 196 | ||
Challenge 3: the power of the hidden curriculum | 196 | ||
Undergraduate education | 197 | ||
Organizing undergraduate ethics education | 197 | ||
National University of Singapore Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine (NUS YLLSoM) | 197 | ||
David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA (DGSOM) | 199 | ||
Assessment of ethical and professional attitudes | 200 | ||
Fitting outcomes and innovative methods | 200 | ||
Assessment: some difficulties | 200 | ||
The special nature of attitudes | 201 | ||
Consistent expectations | 201 | ||
Summary: effecting culture shift | 201 | ||
References | 201 | ||
26 Professionalism | 203 | ||
Introduction | 203 | ||
Defining professionalism | 203 | ||
Setting expectation: agreeing a framework for professionalism | 204 | ||
Developing a culture of professionalism: role modelling and the hidden curriculum | 205 | ||
Digital professionalism | 206 | ||
Educating faculty on social media | 207 | ||
Building in guidance on the use of social media | 207 | ||
Assessing professionalism | 207 | ||
Summary | 208 | ||
References | 208 | ||
27 Evidence-based medicine | 210 | ||
Introduction | 210 | ||
Approaches to teaching EBM | 211 | ||
Building-block approach | 211 | ||
Whole-task approach | 211 | ||
Integration with other courses and content | 211 | ||
Clinical integration | 211 | ||
Computer assisted and online learning approach | 212 | ||
Timing of EBM | 212 | ||
EBM instructors | 212 | ||
Learning resources for EBM | 213 | ||
EBM assessment | 213 | ||
Future directions for EBM teaching | 213 | ||
Summary | 214 | ||
References | 214 | ||
28 Patient safety and quality of care | 215 | ||
Introduction | 215 | ||
Introduction to patient safety, the tragedy of preventable harm | 216 | ||
New competencies and patient safety | 216 | ||
Reporting and learning from adverse events and close calls | 216 | ||
Establishing the just culture | 216 | ||
Teamwork skills and a deeper understanding of human factors | 217 | ||
Introduction to health care quality | 218 | ||
Teaching healthcare quality and patient safety | 218 | ||
A continuum of physician professional development in quality and safety | 218 | ||
Strategies for teaching quality and safety | 219 | ||
Assessment and evaluation | 220 | ||
Challenges that are somewhat unique to establishing a patient safety and healthcare quality educational programme | 220 | ||
Summary | 220 | ||
References | 220 | ||
29 Medical humanities | 222 | ||
Introduction | 222 | ||
What are the medical humanities? | 222 | ||
How do the medical humanities contribute to medical education? | 223 | ||
Preparation for medical practice | 223 | ||
Perspective and personal development | 223 | ||
Bring balance to the medical curriculum | 224 | ||
What educational approaches are useful in medical humanities? | 224 | ||
Curriculum structure | 224 | ||
Framework | 224 | ||
Outcomes-based approach to student learning (OBASL) | 225 | ||
Assessment | 225 | ||
Integration | 225 | ||
Compulsory or elective | 226 | ||
Content and delivery | 226 | ||
Narrative based | 226 | ||
Arts based | 227 | ||
E-learning | 227 | ||
Experiential learning | 227 | ||
Mindful practice | 227 | ||
Historical visits | 227 | ||
Service learning | 227 | ||
What are some practical considerations and challenges? | 227 | ||
Teachers | 227 | ||
Sustainability | 228 | ||
Changing role of doctors | 228 | ||
Cross-cultural and linguistic issues | 228 | ||
Realities of practice | 229 | ||
Summary | 229 | ||
Acknowledgement | 229 | ||
References | 229 | ||
30 Integrative medicine in the training of physicians | 230 | ||
Introduction | 230 | ||
Integrative medicine in undergraduate medical education | 230 | ||
Pre-clinical years | 231 | ||
Experiential learning | 231 | ||
Clinical years | 231 | ||
Clerkships | 231 | ||
Clinical pearls toolkit | 231 | ||
Interprofessional standardized patient exam | 232 | ||
Fourth-year advanced electives | 232 | ||
Integrative medicine in graduate medical education | 233 | ||
Residency | 233 | ||
Fellowship | 234 | ||
Summary | 234 | ||
References | 235 | ||
31 Global awareness | 236 | ||
Introduction | 236 | ||
The rationale for global awareness | 236 | ||
Understanding the global health agenda for medical education | 237 | ||
Integrating activities and resources for global awareness | 238 | ||
Global health training starts by understanding local health issues | 239 | ||
Assessment | 240 | ||
Preparing students for international experiences and electives | 241 | ||
Faculty development for global awareness | 241 | ||
Ethical issues and international electives | 242 | ||
Summary | 242 | ||
References | 242 | ||
32 Medical education in an era of ubiquitous information | 243 | ||
Ubiquitous information | 243 | ||
Data, information, knowledge | 243 | ||
Healthcare in the digital age (and biomedical knowledge in the cloud) | 244 | ||
Electronic health records | 244 | ||
Learning health systems | 244 | ||
Biomedical knowledge in the cloud | 244 | ||
Aids to clinical reasoning and decision making | 245 | ||
The digital native learner | 245 | ||
Three key competencies at a time of ubiquitous information and educational strategies to support the digital learner | 245 | ||
Metacognition and sensing gaps in one’s knowledge | 245 | ||
Metacognition | 246 | ||
Confidence calibration | 246 | ||
Demonstration and assessment of metacognition | 246 | ||
Information retrieval and the ability to form an appropriate question | 247 | ||
Foundational, advanced and specialized medical knowledge | 247 | ||
Framing an appropriate clinical question | 248 | ||
Assessment of information retrieval and analysis | 248 | ||
Evaluating and weighing evidence to make decisions; recognizing patients and interprofessional colleagues as additional sources of information | 248 | ||
Assessment of uncertainty/shared decision making | 249 | ||
Summary | 249 | ||
References | 249 | ||
5 Assessment | 251 | ||
33 Concepts in assessment including standard setting | 252 | ||
Measurement theories | 252 | ||
Classical Test Theory (CTT) | 252 | ||
Generalizability Theory (GT) | 252 | ||
Item Response Theory (IRT) | 253 | ||
Types of assessment | 253 | ||
Formative assessment | 253 | ||
Summative assessment | 253 | ||
Diagnostic assessment | 253 | ||
Qualities of a good assessment | 254 | ||
Validity theory | 254 | ||
Score interpretation | 255 | ||
Norm-referenced score interpretation | 255 | ||
Criterion-referenced score interpretation | 255 | ||
Score equivalence | 255 | ||
Standards | 256 | ||
Relative standards | 256 | ||
Absolute standards | 256 | ||
Blueprints | 256 | ||
Self-assessment | 257 | ||
Objective versus subjective assessments | 257 | ||
All assessment requires judgement | 258 | ||
Summary | 258 | ||
References | 258 | ||
34 Written assessments | 260 | ||
Introduction | 260 | ||
Question format | 260 | ||
Quality control of items | 261 | ||
Response formats | 261 | ||
Short-answer open-ended questions | 261 | ||
Description | 261 | ||
When to use and when not to use | 261 | ||
Tips for item construction | 261 | ||
Essay questions | 262 | ||
Description | 262 | ||
When to use and when not to use | 262 | ||
Tips for item construction | 262 | ||
True–false questions | 263 | ||
6 Staff | 305 | ||
40 Staff development | 306 | ||
Introduction | 306 | ||
Common practices and challenges | 306 | ||
Key content areas | 306 | ||
Educational formats | 307 | ||
Decentralized activities | 307 | ||
Self-directed learning | 307 | ||
Peer coaching | 308 | ||
Online learning | 308 | ||
Mentorship | 308 | ||
Learning in the workplace | 309 | ||
Frequently encountered challenges | 309 | ||
Programme effectiveness | 310 | ||
Designing a staff development programme | 310 | ||
Understand the institutional/organizational culture | 310 | ||
Determine appropriate goals and priorities | 310 | ||
Conduct needs assessments to ensure relevant programming | 310 | ||
Develop different programmes to accommodate diverse needs | 311 | ||
Incorporate principles of adult learning and instructional design | 311 | ||
Offer a diversity of educational methods | 311 | ||
Promote ‘buy in’ and market effectively | 312 | ||
Work to overcome commonly encountered challenges | 312 | ||
Prepare staff developers | 312 | ||
Evaluate – and demonstrate – effectiveness | 312 | ||
Summary | 313 | ||
References | 313 | ||
41 Academic standards and scholarship | 315 | ||
Introduction | 315 | ||
Double standard: research, patient care and teaching | 315 | ||
Professionalizing teaching | 316 | ||
Broadening the definition of scholarship | 316 | ||
Criteria for scholarship in teaching and education | 316 | ||
Recognizing and evaluating a scholarly approach to teaching and educational scholarship | 317 | ||
Increasing support for a scholarly approach to teaching and educational scholarship | 317 | ||
Leadership: promoting the scholarship of teaching | 318 | ||
Adaptive action: leadership for scholarship | 319 | ||
Summary | 320 | ||
References | 321 | ||
7 Students | 323 | ||
42 Student selection | 324 | ||
Introduction | 324 | ||
Why select? | 324 | ||
Selection of students by the medical school | 324 | ||
Selection by applicants of medicine as a career | 324 | ||
Implicit selection of the medical schools by applicants | 324 | ||
Explicit selection of medical schools by applicants | 324 | ||
Selection for a particular academic curriculum | 325 | ||
Selection by staff for staff | 325 | ||
The limits of selection | 325 | ||
Which are the canonical traits in selection? | 325 | ||
Intellectual ability | 325 | ||
Learning style and motivation | 326 | ||
Communicative ability | 326 | ||
Personality | 326 | ||
Surrogates for selection | 326 | ||
Methods and process of selection | 327 | ||
Assessing methods of selection | 327 | ||
Different methods of selection | 327 | ||
Open admissions and lotteries | 327 | ||
Administrative methods | 327 | ||
Assessment of application forms | 327 | ||
Biographical data (biodata) | 328 | ||
Referees’ reports | 328 | ||
Interviewing | 328 | ||
Multiple mini-interviews (MMIs) | 328 | ||
Psychometric testing | 328 | ||
Situational judgement tests | 328 | ||
Assessment centres | 329 | ||
The costs of selection | 329 | ||
Routine monitoring of selection | 329 | ||
Widening access | 329 | ||
Studying selection and learning from research | 329 | ||
Evidence-based medicine and the scientific study of selection | 329 | ||
Summary | 330 | ||
References | 330 | ||
43 Student support | 332 | ||
Supporting student learning | 334 | ||
Enhancing study and learning skills | 334 | ||
Providing support for knowledge deficits | 334 | ||
Monitoring student performance | 334 | ||
Supporting student mental and physical wellbeing | 335 | ||
Mentoring | 335 | ||
Supporting health and wellness | 335 | ||
Providing health and psychological services | 336 | ||
Providing other support services | 336 | ||
Supporting student career choice | 336 | ||
Providing financial aid services and counselling | 337 | ||
Creating a comprehensive student services system | 337 | ||
Identifying and maintaining adequate resources | 337 | ||
Overcoming student resistance | 337 | ||
Summary | 338 | ||
References | 338 | ||
44 Student engagement in learning | 339 | ||
Expertise | 339 | ||
Mastery | 340 | ||
Addressing our expert blind spot and developing student mastery | 341 | ||
Contextual learning and thinking | 342 | ||
Strategies for developing medical students’ contextual thinking | 342 | ||
Student engagement in the management of the learning environment | 343 | ||
Summary | 344 | ||
References | 344 | ||
45 Peer-assisted learning | 345 | ||
Introduction | 345 | ||
Defining PAL | 345 | ||
PAL and collaborative learning | 346 | ||
Theoretical basis for PAL | 346 | ||
Cognitive factors: challenge and support | 346 | ||
Communication factors | 346 | ||
Affective and social factors | 346 | ||
Organizational factors and the PAL process | 347 | ||
Evidence for PAL | 347 | ||
Advantages for tutors | 347 | ||
Advantages for tutees | 347 | ||
Advantages for the institution | 348 | ||
Potential disadvantages and concerns about PAL | 348 | ||
Components and choices in PAL | 348 | ||
Background | 349 | ||
Aims | 349 | ||
Tutors | 349 | ||
Tutees | 349 | ||
Interaction | 349 | ||
Evaluation | 350 | ||
Institution | 350 | ||
Realization | 350 | ||
Applications and examples of PAL in healthcare education | 350 | ||
Skills training in shoulder ultrasound (Knobe et al. 2010, Germany) | 350 | ||
Online formative assessment and feedback in clinical examination (O’Donovan & Maruthappu, 2015, United Kingdom and Malaysia) | 350 | ||
Researching and developing an undergraduate mental health curriculum (Furmedge et al., 2014) | 351 | ||
Conclusions | 351 | ||
Summary | 352 | ||
References | 352 | ||
8 Medical School | 353 | ||
46 Understanding medical school leadership | 354 | ||
Where and how decisions are influenced in complex organizations | 354 | ||
Top-down decisions | 354 | ||
Matrix-model decisions | 355 | ||
Venn diagram decisions | 355 | ||
Relationships with the medical school departments | 356 | ||
Relationships with the clinical learning sites | 357 | ||
Relationship with the graduate medical education programmes | 357 | ||
Relationship with the research institutes and research centres | 357 | ||
Relationships with the parent university administration | 357 | ||
Summary | 358 | ||
References | 358 | ||
47 Medical education leadership | 359 | ||
Introduction | 359 | ||
The ‘leadership triad’ | 359 | ||
Our current understanding of medical education leadership | 360 | ||
Leadership theory and practice | 361 | ||
Personal qualities and attributes | 361 | ||
Leadership is context dependent | 363 | ||
Leading groups and teams | 364 | ||
A systems perspective | 364 | ||
Summary | 365 | ||
References | 365 | ||
Additional reading | 367 | ||
48 The medical teacher and social accountability | 368 | ||
Introduction | 368 | ||
The concept of social accountability of medical schools | 368 | ||
Medical teachers and social accountability | 369 | ||
Medical teachers comprehensive roles in socially accountable medical schools | 370 | ||
Practical examples of medical teacher social accountability | 371 | ||
Research | 373 | ||
Summary | 374 | ||
References | 374 | ||
Further reading | 375 | ||
49 The educational environment | 376 | ||
Introduction | 376 | ||
What is the educational environment? | 376 | ||
The person level | 377 | ||
The group level | 378 | ||
Learner–learner interactions | 378 | ||
Learner–faculty interactions | 378 | ||
Learner–patient/staff interactions | 379 | ||
The organization level | 379 | ||
Physical factors | 379 | ||
Cultural factors | 379 | ||
The community and society levels | 380 | ||
How is the educational environment measured? | 380 | ||
Teaching with the educational environment in mind | 380 | ||
Addressing student mistreatment | 380 | ||
Curriculum change and the educational environment | 381 | ||
Faculty behaviours | 381 | ||
The effect of the educational environment on faculty | 382 | ||
Time and space | 382 | ||
Community building | 382 | ||
Summary | 383 | ||
References | 383 | ||
50 Medical education research | 384 | ||
Quantitative and qualitative research | 385 | ||
Mixed-methods research | 387 | ||
Reflection | 387 | ||
Building capacity | 388 | ||
Funding | 389 | ||
Summary | 389 | ||
References | 389 | ||
Index | 391 | ||
A | 391 | ||
B | 392 | ||
C | 392 | ||
D | 394 | ||
E | 394 | ||
F | 395 | ||
G | 395 | ||
H | 396 | ||
I | 396 | ||
J | 397 | ||
K | 397 | ||
L | 397 | ||
M | 398 | ||
N | 399 | ||
O | 399 | ||
P | 399 | ||
Q | 401 | ||
R | 401 | ||
S | 402 | ||
T | 403 | ||
U | 404 | ||
V | 404 | ||
W | 405 | ||
Y | 405 |