Menu Expand
The Social Ecology of Border Landscapes

The Social Ecology of Border Landscapes

Anna Grichting | Michele Zebich-Knos

(2017)

Abstract

The collection of essays in The Social Ecology of Border Landscapes defi nes borders and borderlands to include territorial interfaces, marginal spaces (physical, sociological and psychological) and human consciousness. From theoretical and conceptual presentations on social ecology and its agencies and representations, to case studies and concrete projects and initiatives, the contributing authors uncover a thread of contemporary thought and action on this important emerging fi eld. The essays aim to defi ne the territories of social ecology, to investigate how social agencies can activate ecological processes and systems, and to understand how the interactions of people and ecosystems can create new sustainable landscapes across tangible and intangible territorial rifts.


“This extraordinary book is a prime example of the multidisciplinary work that makes a metadiscipline like border studies grow. It zooms innovatively on the intersection of social and natural ecologies in transboundary spaces, drawing from many disciplines and cases to show us how to transit from theory to action in reintegrating humans and nature under territorial conflict, galloping resource extraction and severe environmental stress.” —Tony Payan, Fellow and Director, Mexico Center, James A. Baker III Institute for Public Policy, Rice University, USA


Social Ecology is an emerging concept situated in the field of critical social theory and new integrative sciences that addresses the complex and interrelated relationship between nature and society, offering a perspective on how environmental issues are embedded in a social context. Border landscapes are loosely defined as interstitial spaces between territories or societies, in conflict or in competition, with fixed or moving boundaries. Scholars involved in Critical Border Studies employ interdisciplinary approaches to the study of borders, often charting new territories (scapes) to analyze and intervene in the complex geography of border zones. Adding to the flourishing literature and rising interest in borders, this volume on the social ecology of border landscapes examines case studies and examples of projects that highlight such borders within a social-ecological framework. Social Ecology as a critical social theory was originally founded by Murray Bookchin as a critique of social, political and anti-ecological trends. Other proponents of a social-ecological approach (such as Samantha Stone-Jovicich, and Michael Fabinyi, Louisa Evans, and Simon J Foale) use a less idealistic approach to social ecology than that of Bookchin, urging us to consider the important role of space and its bio-geophysical characteristics that spur both ecological and social change. This attention to locally-defined spaces—be it along the Israeli wall, former Berlin wall or the Korean Demilitarized Zone— yields important human-environmental interactions and consequences that form the basis for a social ecological interpretation of environmental adaptation and change. Social ecology as a framework has expanded to include Social-Ecological Systems (SES), which emerged from critical social and resilience theories as a means of addressing the adaptive and complex structures and processes of the social and natural world.

This edited volume is a collection of essays from a wide range of disciplines that address social-ecological systems, namely in the marginal spaces, landscapes and territorial interfaces of border zones. From theoretical and conceptual presentations on social ecology and its related actions or agency, to case studies and concrete projects and initiatives, the book uncovers a thread of contemporary thought and action on the important emerging field of border ecologies within the larger realm of critical border studies. The authors are worldwide scholars and practitioners from the fields of politics, ecological and environmental sciences, social sciences, geography, and urban and landscape planning. The publication explores how social agency (i.e. social action) can activate ecological processes and systems, creating new sustainable landscapes across tangible and intangible territorial rifts. To overcome the negative impacts of border creation and/or behaviors, the tangible and territorial, as well as the intangible social and cognitive manifestations of the rift must be addressed.


Anna Grichting, a Swiss architect and urbanist, is currently teaching graduate and undergraduate courses in Architecture and urban planning at Qatar University.

Michele Zebich-Knos is Professor Emeritus of Political Science and International Affairs, and founding Director of the Master of Science in International Policy Management Program at Kennesaw State University/University System of Georgia (Atlanta, USA). She is currently a Research Fellow at the University of Vermont’s Institute for Environmental Diplomacy and Security and is author of numerous publications on environmental policy. 


“The authors offer a comprehensive panorama of environmental issues in border areas and the zones of conflict. They apply a robust multiscale and multidisciplinary approach to integrating social ecology and critical border studies and opening a new view on complex relations between borders and nature. The book provides scholars and practitioners involved in peace processes with valuable information on the use of environment protection in reconciliation and peace keeping.”
—Vladimir Kolosov, Professor, Institute of Geography, Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia


“This book’s inventive application of the multilevel social ecological approach exposes hard borders of confl ict as landscapes of microscale human innovation, adaptability and porosity […] the struggle for human meaning and interaction continues amid the macro-borders of larger political conflict.” —Scott A. Bollens, Professor of Urbanism, School of Social Ecology, University of California, Irvine, USA

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover 1
Front Matter i
Half-title i
Series information ii
Title page iii
Copyright information iv
Contents v
List of Illustrations vii
Preface ix
Contributors x
Introduction: Social Ecologies and Borderlands 1
Border Landscapes: Charting New Territories 2
Fluidity of Borders, Society and the Environment 3
Border Ecologies and Edge Effects 4
An Integrative Conceptual Framework 5
Structure of this Volume 8
Notes 13
Bibliography 14
Chapters (1-13) 1
Part I Frames: mapping social ecologies in border territories 17
Chapter One On The Agency Of Borderlands 19
Introduction: Borderlands, Limits and Liminalities 19
Borders Beyond our Territorialist and Geopolitical Traditions 21
Borders, Ecology and Peace Parks 23
Borders, Ecology and Globalization 24
Borders, Power and Politics 25
Borders, State Increase and Vacillation 27
Conclusion: Borders, Here, There, Everywhere? 29
Notes 30
Bibliography 33
Chapter Two Social Ecology and Transboundary Conservation: (Re)Connecting Nature and People in Borderlands 37
Introduction 37
The Rationale for and Definitions of Transboundary Conservation 38
Global Trends and Distributions 39
The Principles and Processes to be Applied for Successful Transboundary Conservation Initiatives 40
Transboundary Conservation Principles: Building Trust, Confidence and Capacity 41
The Processes from Pre-feasibility, to Feasibility, to Implementation, to Evaluation 43
A Mechanism to Build Social Ecological Resilience 44
The Evolution of Thinking within the Conservation Fraternity 45
Nature’s Value to Society 46
A Mechanism to Promote Peace in Border Regions 47
Notes 49
Bibliography 50
Chapter Three Social Ecologies and Structural Violence: Boundary-Making as Nature-Making in A Gated Globe 53
Introduction: Boundary-Making as Nature-Making 53
A Sense of Urgency 54
Security Fencing 54
Security Fencing in a “Borderless” World 55
Security Fencing in a Bordering World: Walls and Gates 57
Security Fencing as Structural Violence 58
Edge Effects: Reframing Human Displacement as Social Ecology 58
Displacement: From “Homelessness” to “Globelessness” 59
Fatal Journeys 60
Borders as Biotic Meeting Places 60
Nature and Structural Violence: Ecological “Footprints” at the US–Mexico Wall 61
Conclusion 62
Notes 63
Bibliography 66
Part II Bridges: Resilience, Restoration and Reclamation 69
Chapter Four Borders as Zones of Experiential Learning: The Case of the Balkans Peace Park Project 71
Introduction 71
The Birth of the Balkans Peace Park Project (B3P) 72
Organizational Structure 77
Strategy Evolves—Future Activities 78
Challenges and Dynamics 79
Critiques: Pitfalls of Peace Park Development 83
Conclusion 85
Notes 85
Bibliography 87
Chapter Five Social Ecologies in Borderlands: Crane Habitat Restoration and Sustainable Agriculture Project in the Democratic Project in the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea 89
Introduction 89
The Korean Peninsula: Social Ecological Perspectives 90
Political, Geopolitical Contexts 90
Social Ecological Perspectives: Transfrontier Park’s Potential to Help Reintegrate Humans and Nature 91
Spiritual and Symbolic Components 93
Social and Cultural Components 93
Crane Habitat Restoration and Sustainable Agriculture Project 95
Background 95
Project Goals 96
Project Objectives 96
Helping Farmers Develop Sustainably Productive Agricultural Practices 96
Organic Farming Practices 97
Crane Habitat Restoration 99
Public Education 101
Project Funding 101
Future Steps and Needs 102
Notes 102
Bibliography 104
Chapter Six Socio-Ecological Transformations in Riparian Zones: The Production of Spaces of Exclusion and the Uneven Development of Resilience in The Sonoran Borderlands 107
Contextualizing the San Pedro River in the Sonoran Borderlands 112
Theorizing Uneven Resilience and Riparian Enclosure 114
Three Mechanisms of Riparian Enclosure 117
Privatization 118
Expropriation 121
Conservation 121
Discussion 123
Conclusion: Toward a Socio-ecological Approach to Management 124
Notes 125
Bibliography 127
Chapter Seven From No-Man’s Land To Every-Man’s Land: Socio-Ecological Approaches To Reclaiming Shared Spaces In Border Landscapes, With Examples From Germany and Cyprus 131
Introduction 131
Socio-ecological Approaches to Borders in Conflict Zones: Toward Rhizomatic Systems and Thirdscapes 132
Beuys, Berlin and the Border Effects: Third Pathways, Urban Ecology and the German Green Belt 135
Co-creating Ecological and Social Shared Spaces for Increased Resilience in Cyprus and Beyond 140
Home for Cooperation, Temporary Occupations and Future Landscapes of Forgiveness 141
Conclusion 144
Notes 146
Bibliography 147
Part III Corridors: Catalysts And Collaboration In Confined Spaces 151
Chapter Eight Ensuring Hope in Militarized Landscapes: The Case of Lebanon 153
Introduction 153
Reclaiming Traditional Water Conservation Practices in South Lebanon: The Case of Marwaheen Village 155
Jabal Amel—A Militarized Landscape 155
Steadfastness in a Homeland 157
Birkit Marwaheen 159
Urban Agriculture and the Women’s Vocational Training Center (WVTC) in the Ein El Hilwi Palestinian Refugee Camp 160
Ein el-Hilwi—Capital of the Palestinian Diaspora 160
The Kingdom of Women 161
Green Stories 163
Green Center 164
Conclusion 165
Notes 166
Bibliography 167
Chapter Nine Domesticating and Enlarging One’s Territory: Day-To-Day Politics in a Confined Space—The Shu’fat Refugee Camp in East Jerusalem 169
The Regime of Perception and the Familiar World 170
Living and Living Better: A Political Meaning 172
Domesticating the Environment 173
Proximity and Politics: The Political Aims of an Ecology of Social Activities 175
Notes 178
Bibliography 179
Chapter Ten Urban Alternatives and Collaborative Economics in Belfast’s Contested Space 181
Introduction 181
The Neoliberal City 182
Collaborative Economics on the Interface 187
Conclusions 191
Notes 192
Bibliography 193
Part IV Portals: Dialogue, Exception and Reterritorialization 195
Chapter Eleven Australia Day: A Social Ecology Dialogue Across Aboriginal and White Cultures 197
Notes 206
Bibliography 207
Chapter Twelve Re-Legislating The Soil: Enclosures and Exception at The Amazon Frontiers 209
Insurgency 210
Re-legislating the Soil 212
The Legal Nature of Land 213
The Ecological Nature of the Law 225
Law and Land, Politics and Ecology 226
Notes 227
Bibliography 229
Chapter Thirteen Mediterranean Edges: Reterritorializing Natural and Social Ecologies 231
Introduction 231
Looking North 232
The Algerian Shore 233
The Jardin d’Essai: A Common Space? 234
Notes 240
Bibliography 240
Conclusion Making Sense of Social Ecology, Borders and The Environment 243
Borders, Culture and Equity 243
Seeking Balance and Community 245
Trade and Activism: Local Developments in Bounded Spaces 247
Implications for the Future 249
Notes 251
Bibliography 252
End Matter 255
Index 255