Menu Expand
Enlightenment Travel and British Identities

Enlightenment Travel and British Identities

Mary-Ann Constantine | Nigel Leask

(2017)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

‘Weaving together science, history, antiquarianism and art, this stimulating collection of essays amply demonstrates Thomas Pennant’s centrality to a broad range of British Enlightenment debates and discourses, especially those relating to Britain’s so-called “Celtic Fringe”. At the same time, it underscores the epistemological importance of travel and travel writing in the late eighteenth century.’
—Carl Thompson, Senior Lecturer in English, St Mary’s University, UK


‘Weaving together science, history, antiquarianism and art, this stimulating collection of essays amply demonstrates Thomas Pennant’s centrality to a broad range of British Enlightenment debates and discourses, especially those relating to Britain’s so-called “Celtic Fringe”. At the same time, it underscores the epistemological importance of travel and travel writing in the late eighteenth century.’
—Carl Thompson, Senior Lecturer in English, St Mary’s University, UK


Thomas Pennant of Downing, Flintshire (1726–1798), naturalist, antiquarian and self-styled ‘Curious Traveller’, published accounts of his pioneering travels in Scotland and Wales to wide acclaim between 1769 and 1784, directly inspiring Dr Johnson, James Boswell and hundreds of subsequent tourists. A keen observer and cataloguer of plants, birds, minerals and animals, Pennant corresponded with a trans-continental network of natural scientists (Linnaeus, Simon Pallas, Joseph Banks, Gilbert White), and was similarly well-connected with leading British antiquarians (William Borlase, Francis Grose, Richard Gough). Frequently cited as witness or authority across a wide range of disciplines, Pennant’s texts have seldom been themselves the focus of critical attention. There is as yet no biography of Pennant, nor any edition of his prolific correspondence with many of the leading minds of the European Enlightenment.

The ‘Tours’ were widely read and much imitated. As annotated copies reveal, readers were far from passive in their responses to the text, and ‘local knowledge’ would occasionally be summoned to challenge or correct them. But Pennant indisputably helped bring about a richer, more complex understanding of the multiple histories and cultures of Britain at a time when ‘Britishness’ was itself a fragile and developing concept. Because the ‘Tours’ drew on a vast network of informants (often incorporating material wholesale), they are, as texts, fascinatingly multi-voiced: many of the period’s political tensions run through them.

This volume of eleven essays seeks to address the comparative neglect of Pennant’s travel writing by bringing together researchers from literary criticism, art history, Celtic studies, archaeology and natural history. Attentive to the visual as well as textual aspects of his topographical enquiries, it demonstrates how much there is to be said about the cross-currents (some pulling in quite contrary directions) in Pennant’s work. In so doing they rehabilitate a neglected aspect of the Enlightenment in relation to questions of British identity, offering a new assessment of an important chapter in the development of domestic travel writing.


Mary-Ann Constantine is Reader at the University of Wales Centre for Advanced Welsh and Celtic Studies, and a Fellow of the Learned Society of Wales. The author of The Truth against the World: Iolo Morganwg and Romantic Forgery (2007), Constantine has written widely on the Romantic period in Wales and Brittany.

Nigel Leask is Regius Chair in English Language and Literature at the University of Glasgow as well as a Fellow of the British Academy and the Royal Society of Edinburgh. He is the author of Robert Burns and Pastoral: Poetry and Improvement in Late Eighteenth-Century Scotland (2010), which won the Saltire Prize for best research monograph in 2010.


The essays in this collection reflect and bring to life the variety of topics to be found in Pennant's 'Tours', and his treatment of them. Appropriately, given that visual depiction as well as written description was very important to Pennant, this volume is well illustrated in relevant chapters, with reproductions from the 'Tours' and other contemporary images.
—Edward Cole, 'Journal of Historical Geography' 60 (2018) 100–113.


‘Enlightenment Travel and British Identities shows why Thomas Pennant was more than a “curious traveller”, revealing his literary, scientific and antiquarian concerns. Enriching our understanding of Pennant’s Scottish and Welsh tours and how travel made truth, these engaging essays illuminate the making of historical identities in an age of intellectual reform.’
—Charles W. J. Withers, Ogilvie Chair of Geography, School of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh, UK


‘No one did more to map the British cultural imaginary of Scotland and Wales than Thomas Pennant, and this landmark collection details the magnitude of his wide-ranging achievement. Enlightenment Travel will be indispensable for anyone interested in Pennant or the rise of domestic tourism as shaping forces of cultural historiography, scientific enquiry and national identity.’
—Benjamin Colbert, Reader in English Literature, Faculty of Arts, University of Wolverhampton, UK


‘This important and thought-provoking volume persuasively argues the case for a multidisciplinary approach to Pennant. Together the essays offer a fresh and subtly nuanced reading of the writings of this influential traveller and his significant contribution to home tour narratives of regional and national identity in the late eighteenth century.’
—Zoe Kinsley, Senior Lecturer in English Literature, Department of English, Liverpool Hope University, UK

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Front Matter i
Half-title i
Series information ii
Title page v
Copyright information vi
Dedication vii
Table of contents xi
List of Figures xiii
List of contributors xvii
Preface xix
Acknowledgments xxi
List of abbreviations xxiii
Chapter Int-11 1
Introduction: Thomas Pennant, Curious Traveller 1
‘Travels at home’: Pennant’s British Identities 2
Worlds of Text and Image: Travel Writing and Enlightenment Networks 4
Multiple Voices: About this Volume 7
Notes 12
Chapter 1 ‘A round jump from ornithology to antiquity’: The Development of Thomas Pennant’s Tours 15
The Genesis of Pennant’s Interest in Natural History: A Passion for Minerals and Fossils 16
The Birth of a Naturalist: A Shift of Interest from Geology to Ornithology and Zoology 18
Friendship with Joseph Banks and Peter Simon Pallas 18
The Urge to Explore and Discover the Fauna of Scotland 19
The Expedition of 1769 – the ‘Tour of a Naturalist’ 21
Preparing for a Second Scottish Expedition – ‘Desirous of Being at once Directed to the Objects Most ... 25
The 1772 Tour of Scotland: ‘The Longest of My Journies in Our Island’ 27
Preparation and Reception of the 1772 Tour 30
Addressing the Deficiencies in the Tour: ‘No Part of North Britain, or Its Islands, Should Be Left Unexplored’ 31
Conclusion: ‘I Beg to Be Considered Not as a Topographer but as a Curious Traveller’ 32
Notes 33
Part I History, Antiquities, Literature 39
Chapter 2 Thomas Pennant: Some Working Practices of an Archaeological Travel ... 41
Introduction 41
Early Influences 42
Pennant’s Tours 45
The 1769 Tour to Scotland 45
The 1772 Tour to Scotland and the Hebrides 46
Castlerigg Stone Circle 46
Cordiner and Low: Pennant’s most northerly informants 48
The Welsh Tours 50
The route over Penmaenmawr: Braich-y-dinas 51
Merioneth monuments 53
The Llanarmon excavation 53
Conclusions: The Archaeological Legacy of Thomas Pennant 55
Notes 57
Chapter 3 Heart of Darkness: Thomas Pennant And Roman Britain 65
Conclusion 79
Notes 81
Chapter 4 Constructing Identities in the Eighteenth Century: Thomas Pennant And the Early Medieval Sculpture ... 85
Introduction: Travel, Taste and the Antique 85
Travel, Taste and the Antique in Britain 87
Travel, Taste and the Antique: Thomas Pennant in Scotland 89
Conclusion 100
Notes 100
Chapter 5 Shaping a heroic life: Thomas Pennant on Owen Glyndwr 105
Notes 118
Chapter 6 ‘The First Antiquary of his Country’: Robert Riddell’s Extra- Illustrated And Annotated ... 123
The Glenriddell Connection 125
The Making of Riddell’s Extra-Illustrated Pennant 127
Riddell’s Marginal Annotations 130
Notes 137
Chapter 7 ‘A galaxy of the blended lights’: The Reception of Thomas Pennant 141
Agreeable Miscellany: Responses to the Welsh and Scottish Tours 143
Not by Victory Crowned: History and Tourism in 1790s Wales 147
Future Minstrelsy: Rethinking Bardic Nationalism with Pennant 150
Notes 156
Part II Natural History and the Arts 161
Chapter 8 ‘As if Created by Fusion of Matter after some Intense Heat’: Pioneering Geological Observations ... 163
Notes 177
Chapter 9 Geological landscape as antiquarian ruin: Banks, Pennant And the Isle Of Staffa 183
Notes 196
Chapter 10 Pennant, Hunter, Stubbs and the Pursuit of Nature 203
Animalia 205
Topographia 215
Natura 218
Notes 219
Chapter 11 Pennant’s Legacy: The Popularization of Natural History in Nineteenth-Century Wales through ... 223
Introduction 223
Travel and the Systematic Study of the Distribution of Plants 225
The Post-1773 Botanizing Adventurers:Their Approach to the Natural Landscape 225
Touring and Botanical Observation: The Role of Societies and Field Clubs 227
Botanizing Travellers 229
The Impact of Pteridomania 231
The Parson–Naturalists 233
Amateurs and Professionals: The Rise of an Ecological Approach to Botanical Recording 235
Conclusion 237
Notes 238
End Matter 245
Short Bibliography of Thomas Pennant’s Tours in Scotland and Wales 245
1. Tour in Scotland in 1769 245
2. Tour in Scotland and Voyage to the Hebrides 1772 (Parts I and II) 246
3. Tour in Wales 247
Index 249