Menu Expand
Creolizing Hegel

Creolizing Hegel

Michael Monahan

(2017)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

The 19th-century German thinker G.W.F. Hegel is a towering figure in the canon of European philosophy. Indeed, most of the significant figures of European Philosophy after Hegel explicitly address his thought in their own work. Outside of the familiar territory of the Western canon, however, Hegel has also loomed large, most often as a villain, but sometimes also as a resource in struggles for liberation from colonialism, sexism and racism. Hegel understood his own work as aiming above freedom, yet ironically wrote texts that are not only explicitly Eurocentric and even racist. Should we, and is it even possible, to bring Hegelian texts and ideas into productive discourse with those he so often himself saw as distinctly Other and even inferior?

In response to this question, Creolizing Hegel brings together transdisciplinary scholars presenting various approaches to creolizing the work of Hegel. The essays in this volume take Hegelian texts and themes across borders of method, discipline, and tradition. The task is not simply to compare and contrast Hegel with some 'outsider' figure or tradition, but rather to reconsider and reconfigure our understandings of all of the figures and ideas brought together in these cross-disciplinary essays.
Creolizing Hegel is unquestionably the most important collection of critical essays on Hegel to be published in years. None of the essays simply reject Hegel as a simply Eurocentric thinker, although all engage with his Eurocentrism. More importantly, these essays are comprehensive and cover the arch of Hegel's work. This book will be essential to anyone who is interested in political theory, ethics, and jurisprudence. The sophistication of the essays provides a much needed critical engagement with a thinker who has been both controversial and influential in the entire body of philosophical work in the 20th century.
Drucilla Cornell, Professor of Political Science, Comparative Literature, and Women and Gender Studies, Rutgers University
The originality of the organizing theme and the essays in Creolizing Hegel offer something unfortunately missing in a good deal of recent Hegel studies—and much work on canonical thought, for that matter—over the past few decades: something new to say. This installment of ideas inaugurated by scholars from the Caribbean Philosophical Association, especially the groundbreaking writings of Jane Anna Gordon and Michael Monahan on the creolization of theory, is no less than the birth of a classic.
Lewis R. Gordon, author of What Fanon Said
Michael J. Monahan is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Marquette University. He is the author of The Creolizing Subject: Race, Reason, and the Politics of Purity (2011).

Contributors: María Acosta, Philosophy, DePaul University, USA; Stefan Bird-Pollan, Philosophy, University of Kentucky, USA; Norman Ajari, Equipe de Recherche sur les Rationalités Philosophiques et les Savoirs (ERRAPHIS), Université de Toulouse, France; Jeffrey A. Gauthier, Philosophy, Portland University, USA; Nicholas A. Germana, Keene State College, USA; Nigel C. Gibson, Development Studies, Univeristy of Kwa-Zulu Natal, South Africa; Greg Graham, African and African-American Studies, Oklahoma University, USA; Paget Henry, Brown University, USA; Brandon Hogan, Howard University, USA; Craig Matarrese, Mankato State University, USA; Shannon M. Mussett, Philosophy, Utah Valley University, USA; Karen Ng, Philosophy, Vanderbilt University, USA; Carlos Alberto Sánchez, Philosophy, San-Jose State University, USA; Ricardo Sanín Restrepo, Political and Legal Theory, Universidad Autónoma de Ciudad de Mexico, Mexico; Richard Dien Winfield, Philosophy, University of Georgia, USA; Rocío Zambrana, Philosophy, University of Oregon, USA
"The creative inventiveness of the contributors to Creolizing Hegel shows how alive philosophers can be today to drawing surprising connections in their efforts to place philosophy in the service of liberation."
Robert Bernasconi, Pennsylvania State University

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover 1
Half Title i
Series Information ii
Title Page iii
Copyright Page iv
Table of Contents v
Acknowledgments vii
Introduction: What Is Rational Is Creolizing 1
On Creolization as Movement and Praxis 2
Creolization and the Movement of Reason 9
Brief Sketch of the Work as a Whole 19
Notes 21
Part I Reason, Logic, and Dialectic 23
Chapter 1 Boundary, Ambivalence, Jaibería, or, How to Appropriate Hegel 25
Double Coloniality, Decolonial Strategies 27
Boundaries, Constraints 34
Conclusion 40
Notes 41
Chapter 2 C.L.R. James, Africana Transcendental Philosophy, and the Creolizing of Hegel 43
Foundations of James’ Interest in Hegel’s Dialectic 44
James and Hegel’s Science of Logic 47
Between James and Hegel: Dialectic and Self-Transformation and Creolization 49
Dialectic and Self-Transformation in Hegel 50
Dialectic and Self-Transformation in James 55
The Creole Aspects of James’ Mature Dialectic 57
Conclusion: James, Creolization, and Afro-Caribbean Philosophy 59
Chapter 3 Thinking through the Negative : Adorno’s Reading of Hegel 61
Adorno’s Model of the Subject and the Spontaneity-.Receptivity Thesis 63
Species of Thought, Nonidentity Thinking, Identity Thinking, and Pathological Identity Thinking 67
Adorno’s Reading of Hegel 73
Embracing Hegel 76
Notes 77
Chapter 4 Why I Am So Wise: Hegelian Reflections on Whether Reason Can Be Enhanced 79
Notes 91
Part II History and Aesthetics 93
Chapter 5 Revisiting “Hegel and Haiti”: Postcolonial Readings of the Lord/.Bondsman Dialectic 95
The Struggle for Recognition 97
“Hegel and Haiti” 99
The History of a Fruitful Misreading 102
Biko and Black Consciousness 107
Conclusion 108
Notes 109
Chapter 6 Hegel and Adorno on Negative Universal History: The Dialectics of Species-Life 113
Universal History and Species-Life 116
Two Senses of Negativity in Negative Universal History 121
Conclusion: Negative Universal Histories in Fanon and Lynn Hunt 127
Notes 129
Chapter 7 Hegel among the Cannibals 135
Ways of Seeing and Sighting 137
Hegelian Anthropophagy 141
The Plot Thickens (Voraciously and Infinitely) 144
Hegel’s (Risky) Investment 147
Hegel Invited to Dinner with the Amerindians: Against the Liquidation of the Future 151
Notes 152
Chapter 8 Creolizing Hegel’s Theory of Tragedy 153
Creolization in Context 154
Hegel’s Aesthetics 156
Hegel’s Theory of Tragedy 159
The Radical Africana Tradition and Hegel’s Theory of Tragedy 162
Notes 171
Chapter 9 Hegel, Musical Subjectivity, and Jazz 173
Beneath the Score 174
Selfhood and Musical Time 177
Instrumental Music and Time-Feel 180
Performance, Improvisation, and Style 183
Notes 188
Part III Ethical Life, Law, and Politics 189
Chapter 10 The Future Is Now: Leopoldo Zea’s Hegelianism and the Liberation of the Mexican Past 191
Zea’s Reading of Hegel’s Philosophy of History 193
Zea’s “The Dialectic of Consciousness in Mexico” (1952) 195
The Mexican Case 198
Creolizing Hegel 201
Notes 202
Chapter 11 Crossing Boundaries: Hegel, de Beauvoir, and hooks on Exclusion and Identity 205
The Hegelian Other: Nature, the Feminine, and Africa 206
de Beauvoir Reading with and against Hegel 211
The hooksian Other: Nature, the Feminine, and Africa 214
Conclusion 219
Notes 220
Chapter 12 Ideal Theory and Racial Justice: Some Hegelian Considerations 225
Rawls’ A Theory of Justice 226
Mills on Rawls 227
Rawls and Justification 231
Recognition and Normativity 236
Notes 240
Chapter 13 Oppression, Legal Reform, and Hegel’s Natural Law Internalism 243
Hegel and Natural Law “Internalism” 244
Natural Law Internalism and Social Critique 249
Conclusion 253
Notes 254
Works Cited 257
Index 275
List of Contributors 279