Menu Expand
Caste, Entrepreneurship and the Illusions of Tradition

Caste, Entrepreneurship and the Illusions of Tradition

Geir Heierstad

(2017)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Caste, Entrepreneurship and the Illusions of Tradition is an ethnographic study of the potters of Kolkata’s Kumartuli, an analysis of their lives and the related commodification and instrumentalization of caste. This group of artisans turned artists do not display passive responses to colonial and capitalist encounters but engage actively with the modern and economic developments of society at large, redefining the concept of caste identity in the process. Caste, Entrepreneurship and the Illusions of Tradition suggests a new academic direction for the study of modern India, and of caste in particular, through an empirically grounded portrayal of the synthesis of traditional categories and contemporary realities.


‘Through a meticulous ethnographic study, this book offers an interesting account of how caste identity and the potters' craft of the Kumars of Kumartuli have survived in a competitive modern world of global capital. As there are not many serious academic studies on artisanal castes of Bengal, this book will be welcomed by scholars.’
–Sekhar Bandyopadhyay, Head, School of History, Philosophy, Political Science and International Relations, and Director, New Zealand India Research Institute, Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand


In Kolkata’s traditional potter quarter of Kumartuli, a modern and a competitive market oriented approach to life is concealed behind tradition. Among the potters inhabiting the dirt-floored workshops of this caste-based neighbourhood, the history of a modern and economicly neoliberal-minded India unfolds. To these contemporary potters, caste is in their blood, caste is about being a creative and independent artist, and caste is about business as they engage in a competitive market to sell their artworks. This ethnographic study presents an analysis of these potters’ lives and the related commodification and instrumentalization of caste. An important insight is that Kumartuli consists of a group of artisans turned artists who do not display passive responses to colonial and capitalist encounters. On the contrary, this monograph unearths an ingenious and business-minded group that engages actively with the modern and economic developments of society at large, and, in the process, redefines the concept of caste identity. This study suggests a new academic direction for the study of modern India, and of caste in particular, through an empirically grounded portrayal of the synthesis of traditional categories and contemporary realities.


‘This ethnographically based study of the potter caste of Kolkata is a solid account that helps us understand how tradition adapts to globalization. It is also a loving account of Kolkata and its society.’ –Arild Engelsen Ruud, Professor of South Asia Studies, University of Oslo, Norway


Geir Heierstad is research director of international studies at the Norwegian Institute of Urban and Regional Research, and former associate professor in South Asia studies at the Department of Cultural Studies and Oriental Languages, University of Oslo, Norway. Heierstad is co-author of Indiske utfordringer (Indian Challenges, 2014), and coeditor of The Politics of Caste in West Bengal (2016), India’s Democracies: Diversity, Co-optation, Resistance (2016) and Demokrati på indisk (Democracy Indian Style, 2010).

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover 1
Front Matter i
Half-title i
Series information ii
Title page iii
Copyright information iv
Dedication v
Table of contents vii
List of Figures xi
Acknowledgments xiii
Transliteration And Terminology xv
Chapter (Prologue-7) 1
Prologue: The Durga Puja Business 1
The Old World 4
A New World 5
Chapter 1 On Kumars, Modernity, Caste and Commodification 7
Comprehending the Kumars 10
Making Modernity the Context 12
Indian origins 15
Caste between Structure and Practice 19
Short depiction of the caste system and the Bengali case 20
Conceptualizing and contextualizing caste 25
Dumont, critiques and alternatives 26
Caste today 31
Commodification and Authenticity 33
Fieldwork in Kumartuli 33
On oral history 36
Kumartuli and the world 39
An Outline of the Book 41
Chapter 2 The Civilized Potters and their Neighbourhood 45
The First Kumar 46
Of Rudraksha and the forefather of Bengali Kumbhakars 47
Burning jungle and the first pottery 51
Behind the Potter’s Wheel 53
The Development of Kumartuli – the Story without Kumars 56
Kolkata 57
Kumartuli before and after Durga hits town 60
Life and Work as Seasonal Image-Makers of Kumartuli 65
The Potters’ History and their Society 72
Contemporary Kumartuli Realities 74
Numbers and classes 76
The people – Maliks, Kumars and Kumbhakars 78
The pujas and/as the Maliks’ work 79
Constructing an unbaked clay murti 85
In the end 91
Chapter 3 Birth of Tradition, Coming of Modernity 95
Gopeshwar Pal – an Artist? 95
‘We Used to Listen to These People’s Names’ 104
‘I Have to Accept My Father First, Only Then Can I Accept My Son’ 108
‘The age of reproduction’ 112
Innovation and pride 117
When Modernity Settled in Kumartuli 119
Chapter 4 Ancestral Homes – East Versus West 125
On the Ground 126
The fight for independence 128
Partition 133
Bangal, East Bengal 135
Edeshi, West Bengal 142
West Ghotis and East Bangals Today 145
Chapter 5 Turmoil and Economics 147
Patron–Client Economy 148
Kumartuli Bazaar 149
Political Turmoil 151
Indira Gandhi – the Nationalization Redeemer 156
Maliks and Labourers 158
A Renewed Kumartuli Emerges 165
Chapter 6 Accumulated Value: Education and Caste as Assets 167
Successful Kumars of the Twenty-First Century 168
Prodyut – broadband connected 169
Parimal – presenting one’s portfolio 175
Joyanta – aspiring artist 180
Kumartuli reinvented, reimagined, reconfigured 184
A Kumartuli without Mud Floors 185
Modernity at Large: Caste for Sale 191
Chapter 7 Commodification of Caste 193
Caste versus Modernity 194
Caste in twenty-first century Kumartuli 196
Hierarchy and purity 198
A Kumartuli Lesson 200
An image of the Kumars of Kumartuli 203
Commodification and the Illusions of Tradition 205
End Matter 207
References 207
Index 215