Menu Expand
A Radical History of Development Studies

A Radical History of Development Studies

Uma Kothari

(2016)

Abstract

In this book some of the leading thinkers in development studies trace the history of their multi-disciplinary subject from the late colonial period and its establishment during decolonization all the way through to its contemporary concerns with poverty reduction. They present a critical genealogy of development by looking at the contested evolution and roles of development institutions and exploring changes in development discourses. These recollections, by those who teach, research and practise development, challenge simplistic, unilinear periodizations of the evolution of the discipline, and draw attention to those ongoing critiques of development studies, including Marxism, feminism and postcolonialism, which so often have been marginalized in mainstream development discourse. The contributors combine personal and institutional reflections, with an examination of key themes, including gender and development, NGOs, and natural resource management. The book is radical in that it challenges orthodoxies of development theory and practice and highlights concealed, critical discourses that have been written out of conventional stories of development. The contributors provide different versions of the history of development by inscribing their experiences and interpretations, some from left-inclined intellectual perspectives. Their accounts elucidate a more complex and nuanced understanding of development studies over time, simultaneously revealing common themes and trends, and they also attempt to reposition Development Studies along a more critical trajectory.. The volume is intended to stimulate new thinking on where the discipline may be moving. It ought also to be of great use to students coming to grips with the historical continuities and divergences in the theory and practice of development.
Uma Kothari is a senior lecturer in development studies at the School of Environment and Development, University of Manchester. She has carried out research in India and Mauritius and her research interests include histories and theories of development, colonial and post-colonial discourse, social development and migration and development. She is co-editor of Participation: The New Tyranny? (Zed Books, 2001, with B. Cooke) and Development Theory and Practice: Critical Perspectives (2002, with M. Minogue). She has recently published the chapter ‘Sweetening Colonialism: A Mauritian Themed Resort’ (2003) in M. Lasansky and B. McClaren (eds), Architecture and Tourism (with T. Edensor), edited a special issue of Journal of International Development on ‘Migration, Staying Put and Poverty’ (2003) and published ‘Authority and expertise: the professionalisation of international development and the ordering of dissent’ in Antipode (2005).

'Provides a critical analysis of the history of international development...the contributors adopt a distinct radical perspective on the subject.'
International Review of Social History

'Overall, it is a stimulating book ... very well documented, it facilitates a retracing of the history of the field and it also highlights how individuals involved had to continually rethink or revisit what they had been doing.'
Development and Change

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover
Title Page iii
Copyright iv
Contents v
Acknowledgements viii
1: A Radical History of Development Studies: Individuals, Institutions and Ideologies 1
Why a Radical History of Development Studies? 1
Understanding Development Studies 3
What the Book Says 7
One: Individuals and Institutions 15
2: Great Promise, Hubris and Recovery: A Participant’s History of Development Studies 17
Prologomenon: The Era of the ‘Positivist Orthodoxy’ 19
The Promise of Development Studies 23
Hubris in the 1980s? 30
Reinvention in the 1990s and the Challenge of Act V 36
Conclusion: Critical Engagement with Globalization 38
3: From Colonial Administration to Development Studies: A Post-Colonial Critique of the History of Development Studies 47
Understanding the Colonial Legacy of Development Studies 48
Obscuring a Colonial Genealogy 50
Memory, Narratives and History 52
From Colonial Administration to Development Studies 55
Continuities and Divergences 61
4: Critical Reflections of a Development Nomad 67
Nomad and Journey 68
Reflections 73
A Radical Agenda for Future Development Studies: Qualifications, Caveats and Context 80
Conclusion: A Radical Reconfiguration? 82
5: Secret Diplomacy Uncovered: Research on the World Bank in the 1960s and 1980s 88
The Purposes of Aid: Early Illusions at the Overseas Development Institute 88
Research on the World Bank: An Encounter with Reality 91
Reality Is Not for Publication: The World Bank’s Attempts to ‘Bury’ the ODI Report 95
The World Bank Revisited 99
The World Bank Is Finally Exposed 107
Two: Ideas and Ideologies 109
6: Development Studies and the Marxists 111
Development Studies I. The Founding Moment: Big Issues and Big Ideas 112
Development Studies II. The Age of Neo-Liberalism: How Less Becomes More, and More Less 115
And the Marxists? I. Political Struggle and Intellectual Dynamism 121
And the Marxists? II. Political Defeats and Beyond 126
Conclusion 130
7: Journeying in Radical Development Studies: A Reflection on Thirty Years of Researching Pro-Poor Development 138
The Original Context 139
The Mid-1970s: Marxian Modes of Production Analysis 140
The Early 1980s: Engaging with a Potentially Developmentalist State 142
Later 1980s: Malign External Hands and Neo-Liberal Resource Allocation Priorities 144
The Early 1990s: Thinking Development Anew, Ancient and Postmodern 147
The Mid-1990s: Closely Observing Poverty 149
The Late 1990s: Back to Basics 150
The Present Looking to the Future 151
8: The Rise and Rise of Gender and Development 157
The Birth of Gender 158
Integrating Gender into Development Analysis and Planning 160
From Equality to Empowerment 163
Mainstreaming Gender in International Development 166
What Is the Development Agenda That Needs Gendering? 168
Is It Better to Travel Hopefully Than to Arrive? 175
9: Development Studies, Nature and Natural Resources: Changing Narratives and Discursive Practices 180
Colonial Administration and the Management of Nature 181
Modernist and Populist Narratives 183
The Crisis of Modernization and the Rise of Populist Environmentalism: The 1970s and 1980s 187
‘Incorporated Environmentalism’ and Political Ecology: The 1990s 192
Conclusion 195
10: Individuals, Organizations and Public Action: Trajectories of the ‘Non-Governmental’ in Development Studies 200
Encountering the Non-Governmental 200
NGOs in Development Studies 203
Re-Remembering Hidden Histories? 207
Problems of NGO Research in Development Studies 209
Looking Back at the Rise of Non-Governmentalism 214
Conclusion 215
About the Contributors 222
Index 226