Menu Expand
Border Walls

Border Walls

Reece Jones

(2012)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

*** Winner of the 2013 Julian Minghi Outstanding Research Award presented at the American Association of Geographers annual meeting *** Two decades after the fall of the Berlin Wall, why are leading democracies like the United States, India, and Israel building massive walls and fences on their borders? Despite predictions of a borderless world through globalization, these three countries alone have built an astonishing total of 5,700 kilometers of security barriers. In this groundbreaking work, Reece Jones analyzes how these controversial border security projects were justified in their respective countries, what consequences these physical barriers have on the lives of those living in these newly securitized spaces, and what long-term effects the hardening of political borders will have in these societies and globally. Border Walls is a bold, important intervention that demonstrates that the exclusion and violence necessary to secure the borders of the modern state often undermine the very ideals of freedom and democracy the barriers are meant to protect.
Reece Jones is an associate professor of geography at the University of Hawai'i at Manoa and a leading authority on political borders. He has published fifteen research articles in highly ranked journals as well as opinion pieces in newspapers around the world on the role borders play in globalization and the global war on terror. He has won awards for both teaching and writing and was recently elected the Secretary/Treasurer for the Political Geography Specialty Group of the Association of American Geographers.
'Reece Jones's Border Walls links the paranoid narratives of terror and security emanating from the great democracies: the United States, India, and Israel. Rather than see the border walls that strangle these countries into delusions of security, these walls are frameworks to thwart the widest aspirations for human freedom. Like graffiti on the border walls, Jones's book tries to bring sunlight into the darkness of these states.' Vijay Prashad, author of The Darker Nations: A People's History of the Third World 'At a time when many commentators are preoccupied by forces undermining the power and authority of the territorial state, Border Walls serves as an important reminder that the modernist political-territorial order still matters. Reece Jones convincingly shows that the border security arrangements of the past decade are likely to be among the most enduring consequences of the global "war on terror" - not just for how people move around and use space, but for how they think about the political geographic organization of the planet.' Alexander B. Murphy, Department of Geography, University of Oregon 'In a compelling analysis of the political agendas, identity politics, and growing civil militarization underlying the construction of barriers between neighboring countries and peoples, Reece Jones makes a significant contribution to the emerging but vital field of securitization studies.' Jeff Halper, director of the Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions (ICAHD) 'Reece Jones provides an incisive and lucid examination of why wall-like barriers have become the tool of choice of so many countries along their geographical perimeters in the post-9-11 era. In doing so, he compellingly demonstrates not only how boundaries are produced, but also how they shape those within, and the relations with peoples and places beyond, in worrisome ways. Empirically rich, theoretically sophisticated, and highly accessible, Border Walls is an important and valuable book.' Joseph Nevins, author of Dying to Live: A Story of U.S. Immigration in an Age of Global Apartheid

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
About the author i
Tables and maps\r vi
Acknowledgements\r vii
Abbreviations ix
Introduction: Fortress Democracy 1
1 | Borders, Barriers, and the War on Terror 5
Globalization and borders 5
The global war on terror 7
The changing purpose of borders 9
Table 1.1 Barriers initiated or substantially fortified since 2000 10
Ungoverned space and uncivilized people 12
Defining state subjects and territory 16
Borders and exceptional enforcement practices 22
Conclusion 24
2 | Securing the ‘Homeland’ in the United States 26
Introduction 26
History of the US–Mexico border 27
Changing narratives after 9/11 31
Representations of Mexico and the American homeland 39
The Secure Fence Act of 2006 45
Map 2.1 US–Mexico border 48
Conclusion 50
3 | Border Fencing and the Global War on Terror in India 53
Introduction: order in the nation 53
The state of security in India 55
Pre-modernizing Bangladesh 60
Map 3.1 Bangladesh and the Indian state of West Bengal 61
Boundary narratives at the border 63
Conclusion 71
4 | ‘Arafat is our bin Laden’: Territory and Terrorism in Israel and Palestine 74
Introduction 74
Imagining state spaces 77
Map 4.1 1947 UN partition plan for Palestine and 1949 armistice boundaries(Green Line) 81
Enclosing a Jewish space … 82
Map 4.2 The West Bank 84
Map 7.1 East Jerusalem/al-Quds 152
… with an iron wall 86
Terrorism is terrorism. Period 88
Building the barrier 93
Conclusion 99
5 | Building Up, Rippling Out: Enforcement Practices at the US–Mexican Border 102
Introduction: commutations 102
Dividing El Paso and Juárez 104
Vision and the other across the border 107
Creeping exception 110
Shifting not stopping movement 118
Who profits? Who is harmed? 121
Conclusion 124
6 | The Agents of Exception in the Indian Borderlands 126
Introduction 126
Securitizing the Bengal borderlands 128
The agents of exception 132
Muslim borderland residents 136
Conclusion 142
7 | The Practices of Insecurity: The Barrier in the West Bank 145
Introduction 145
Colonization, occupation, and separation 147
Ungoverned spaces 150
Map 7.1 EastJerusalem/al-Quds 152
Dehumanized people 154
Map 7.2 North Bethlehem 156
Consequences of the barrier: insecurity and empty space 161
Conclusion: the faceless enemy 166
8 | The Enduring Significance of Borders 170
Introduction: do barriers matter? 170
Security, governance, and the state 171
Borders as performative sites 174
Appendix: Methodology and Methods 182
Notes 185
Bibliography 188
Index 204
About Zed Books 212