Menu Expand
The New War on the Poor

The New War on the Poor

John Gledhill

(2015)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

When viewed from the perspective of those who suffer the consequences of repressive approaches to public security, it is often difficult to distinguish state agents from criminals. The mistreatment by police and soldiers examined in this book reflects a new kind of stigmatization.

The New War on the Poor links the experiences of labour migrants crossing Latin America’s international borders, indigenous Mexicans defending their territories against capitalist mega-projects, drug wars and paramilitary violence, Afro-Brazilians living on the urban periphery of Salvador, and farmers and business people tired of paying protection to criminal mafias. John Gledhill looks at how and why governments are failing to provide security to disadvantaged citizens while all too often painting them as a menace to the rest of society simply for being poor.


John Gledhill is emeritus professor of social anthropology at the University of Manchester, and a fellow of the British Academy and UK Academy of Social Sciences. He was chair of the UK Association of Social Anthropologists from 2005 to 2009, has served on the executive committees of the World Council of Anthropological Associations and the International Union of Anthropological and Ethnological Sciences, and is co-managing editor of the journal Critique of Anthropology. He is the author of Casi Nada: Agrarian Reform in the Homeland of Cardenismo; Neoliberalism, Transnationalization and Rural Poverty; Power and Its Disguises: Anthropological Perspectives on Politics; and Cultura y Desafío en Ostula: Cuatro Siglos de Autonomía Indígena en la Costa-Sierra Nahua de Michoacán; and editor of State and Society (with B. Bender and M. T. Larsen), and New Approaches to Resistance in Brazil and Mexico (with P. Schell).

'Highly recommended ... the book challenges conventional thinking about how modernizing societies can work toward more inclusive and democratic societies. It belongs in all libraries with extensive Latin American holdings.'
Choice

'Sweeping and compelling, John Gledhill takes us inside the wars that states wage on inconvenient populations. The result is a powerful critique of contemporary global capitalism.'
Daniel Goldstein, author of Outlawed: Between Security and Rights in a Bolivian City

'A powerful analysis that uncovers the relationship between securitization, neoliberal views of development, and repressive intervention. The book will interest – and inspire – a wide readership concerned with suffering and inequality.'
Dimitrios Theodossopoulos, University of Kent

'Gledhill shows that behind the discourses of "war" against drug traffickers hides a war against the poor. He brilliantly articulates two new ethnographies of Mexico and Brazil, providing insight into the trans-nationalization of criminal networks in the Americas.'
Alejandro Isla, Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences , Argentina

'Displaying his hallmark combination of deep ethnography and expansive theory, Gledhill compellingly lays out how the contradictions of neoliberal capital accumulation and securitization affect the livelihoods and politics of ordinary people in violence-ridden Brazil and Mexico, and, above all, how these people struggle to build spaces of popular sovereignty and dignity.'
Wil G. Pansters, Utrecht University/University of Groningen

'Drawing on decades of field research in Mexico and Brazil, Gledhill pries apart recent processes of "securitization" from the ostensibly similar notion of human security. Equal parts searing critique and sensible call to action, this book speaks truth to powerful actors.'
Charles R. Hale, University of Texas at Austin

'Drawing on his own extensive fieldwork, and with a passionate sense of justice, Gledhill shows how contemporary news stories on Latin America – violent drug trafficking, dramatic electoral battles, and the excitement of emerging markets – are best viewed as scenes in a broader canvas of predation, which in recent years has rendered a bitter irony: that security policy is tending to undermine the security of many Latin Americans, and especially the most vulnerable.'
Trevor Stack, University of Aberdeen


Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Front Cover Front cover
About the Author i
Title Page iii
Copyright iv
Contents v
Maps vi
Acknowledgements vii
1: Securitization, the State and Capitalism 1
Poverty, Inequality and Social Mobility 4
The Human Security Paradigm 10
Securitization and the Development–Security Nexus 18
The Structure and Methodology of the Book 26
2: Violence, Urban Development and the Privatization of Public Power in Brazil 29
Understanding Patterns of Violence 32
São Paulo: Criminal Power and State Power 39
Rio de Janeiro: The UPP Experience 47
Favela Pacification as Accumulation by Dispossession 59
3: Pacifying the Urban Periphery: A Case Study of the Bahian UPP 64
The Order of the State and the Order of Crime 67
Securitization as a Reproducer of Insecurity 76
The Bahian Police: Another Deficit of Respect? 91
Lessons from Bahia 103
4: State Transformations, Illegal Economies and Counter-Insurgency in Mexico 108
Establishing ‘Truths’ About State Terror and Insurgency 113
Guerrero: A War That Did Not Pacify 118
Paramilitarism and the State in Chiapas 130
Decentring the EZLN 146
5: Paramilitaries, Autodefensas and the Pacification of Michoacán 153
The State and the Development of the Drugs Trade 158
From Cartel Wars and Wars Against Cartels to Mafias 166
Indigenous and Mestizo Self-Defence Forces 174
Not Seeing, Like a State 188
6: Achieving Human Security: The Contradictions of Repressive Intervention 196
Rural and Urban Dystopias 197
Transnational Perspectives 200
Security That Creates Insecurity 208
Notes 218
Bibliography 225
Index 238
Back Cover Back cover