Menu Expand
Co-operatives in a Post-Growth Era

Co-operatives in a Post-Growth Era

Tom Webb | Sonja Novkovic

(2014)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

For the past three decades, neoclassical doctrine has dominated economic theory and policy. The balance of power has shifted to protect private interests, resulting in unprecedented damage to the environment and society, with no solution in sight as more austerity and less government continues to be posited as the answer to the oncoming waves of crisis. It doesn't have to be this way. Featuring a remarkable roster of internationally renowned critical thinkers, Co-operatives in a Post-Growth Era presents a feasible alternative for a more environmentally sustainable and equitable economic system - specifically, the co-operative business model. With more than 100 million people working in co-operatives and more than a billion members around the world, the time has never been better for co-operatives everywhere to recognise their potential to change the economic landscape. An essential book for students, policymakers and concerned citizens looking for a practical way to change the current stagnant economic paradigm.
'More than ever, the world needs economic systems whose objectives are not to make a small fraction of humanity monetarily rich but, rather, to build a more inclusive society where quality of life for all is the metric of success. Co-operatives have proven track records of generating just such outcomes. The ideas presented in this publication can serve to further our understanding of the possibilities and challenges associated with unleashing the power of a healthier view of sustainable economics.' Kathy Bardswick, president and CEO, The Co-operators, Canada 'This collective work brings very useful insights on how cooperatives, in a plural economy, can help build a better world and reach sustainable prosperity. A must read for those who wants to learn about the cooperative model and its economics.' Monique F. Leroux, chair of the board, president and chief executive officer, Desjardins Group 'This is an outstanding collection of new economics, reflecting a growing and creative body of work on the practice and the theory of a more inclusive and authentically sustainable economy.' Ed Mayo, secretary general, Co-operatives UK 'When markets fail, co-operatives bring needed products and services, competition and opportunity for people. Building a global co-operative economy will ensure fewer economic crises and greater food security around the world.' Paul Hazen, executive director of US Overseas Cooperative Development Council and former CEO of the National Cooperative Business Association 'Co-operative leaders need to understand the economy from a perspective that is consistent with their purpose, values and principles. Neoclassical economics is off the mark in too many ways. These chapters provide a more realistic reading of the economy and will be helpful in understanding the challenges we face and how best we can contribute to making this a better world through co-operative action.' Dame Pauline Green, president, International Co-operative Alliance 'Imagine 2012 was an acmé for the International Summit of Co-operatives during the International Year of Co-operatives. The recent financial crisis revealed much disarray in our ability to foresee our future and Imagine has been the silver lining behind the cloud for those who believe that co-ops are enterprises to build a better world.' Jean Louis Bancel, president of Crédit Coopératif, chair of International Cooperative Banks Association, and member of the board of International Cooperative Alliance 'The co-operative model provides a most effective institutional mechanism of addressing the development challenges of the African continent on a sustainable basis. Co-operatives can simultaneously promote wealth creation, poverty alleviation and more equitable distribution of resources. The poor don’t need sympathy or pity; they need empowerment and dignity that true co-operatives facilitate through bringing the marginalized population into the mainstream of socio-economic activity. The ideas about economics in this book will help co-operative leaders move co-operative development forward.' Nelson Kuria, CEO, Co-operative Insurance Company, Kenya 'A unique collection of essays that offers both theoretical arguments and practical insights into how co-operatives can provide the basis for a more socially and environmentally sustainable economy. This should be required reading for all students in business and economics, and a must read for all interested in the future of the planet.' Professor Darryl Reed, York University Canada 'The timing of this book is perfect! The findings from the 2012 Imagine Conference summarise ways to create prosperity and stability in this new economic, social and environmental reality. Leading economic thinkers provide critical insights in how the co-operative enterprise model meets the growing complex global problems while building a better world. Kudos to Tom Webb and Sonja Novkovic for making this happen.' Denyse Guy, executive director, Co-operatives and Mutuals Canada
Sonja Novkovic is a professor of economics at Saint Mary’s University, and academic co-director in the Co-operative Management Education programme. Currently, she is the chair of the International Co-operative Alliance Research Committee and academic co-lead of the Measuring the Co-operative Difference Research Network in collaboration with Co-operatives and Mutuals Canada. Tom Webb is an adjunct professor at Saint Mary’s University School of Business and former programme manager of the master’s degree in the Management of Co-operatives and Credit Unions (MMCCU).

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Front Cover Front cover
About the Editors i
More praise for Co-operatives in a Post-Growth Era ii
Title Page\r iii
Copyright\r iv
Contents\r v
Tables and Figures vii
Introduction: Co-operative Economics, Why Our World Needs It 1
Table 0.1 Types of co-operative and their members 3
What economics do we use? 6
The structure of the book 9
Notes 10
References 10
Part One: What is the New Economy and Why Do We Need It? 13
1 The World on a Collision Course and the Need for a New Economy 15
Preamble 15
The quadruple convergence 16
Crisis or crises? 17
The myths that sustain the dominant model 18
A new economy 22
Foundations of the new economy 23
Table 1.1 Matrix of needs and satisfiers 26
Figure 1.1 Genuine Progress Indicators and Indices of Sustainable Economic Welfare for selected countries 29
Figure 1.2 The classic approach to the economic process 31
Figure 1.3 The ecological economic approach 32
Figure 1.4 Humanity’s ecological footprint, 1961–2001 34
Table 1.2 World population, per capita income and number of ecosons 36
Table 1.3 The real size of the United States 36
Notes 37
References 37
2 The New Economy 39
Introduction 39
Scale and growth – or not? 41
Table 2.1 Six possible scenarios 42
Issues of resource scarcity and quality 43
The meaning for economic theory – and production 45
Using prices to achieve goals 46
Work 49
The ideal economy 51
How standard wage theory must adapt 53
Conclusions 55
Notes 60
References 60
3 The World We Need 61
Figure 3.1 Income per head and life expectancy in rich and poor countries 62
Figure 3.2 Real income per head and life expectancy 63
Figure 3.3 Child well-being is not related to average incomes in rich countries 66
Figure 3.4 Health and social problems are not related to average incomes in rich countries 67
Figure 3.5 Health is not related to income differences between rich societies 68
Figure 3.6 Health is related to income difference within rich societies 69
Figure 3.7 Child well-being is better in more equal rich societies 70
Figure 3.8 Health and social problems are worse in more unequal countries 71
Notes 80
References 80
4 Are Prosperity and Sustainability Compatible? 83
Introduction: on the nature of prosperity and sustainability 83
What makes us unsustainable? 84
Our excessive ecological footprint 87
Box 4.1. The human ecological footprint – in overshoot 87
Human potential subverted 88
Facing the new reality 92
What to do? Towards a co-operative model for global sustainability 92
The spectrum of behavioural possibilities 94
Table 4.1 Elements of the human behavioural spectrum 94
Implications for economic life 95
Table 4.2 The shift in economic values and assumptions (getting better is better than getting bigger) 95
Epilogue 97
Notes 98
References 99
5 Living Well: Explorations into the End of Growth 101
Introduction 101
Exploring alternatives to economic growth 103
The LowGrow model 104
Figure 5.1 The high-level structure of LowGrow 106
Figure 5.2 Business as usual 108
Figure 5.3 A low- or no-growth scenario 108
Policy directions for a low- or no-growth scenario 109
Notes 113
References 114
6 Complexity: Shock, Innovation and Resilience 115
Introduction 115
Examples of shock 115
Figure 6.1 Deepwater Horizon 116
Figure 6.2 July temperature anomalies in Moscow since 1950 117
Figure 6.3 National income: change from the previous year 118
Figure 6.4 National income: percentage change from the previous year 118
The causes of shock 120
Figure 6.5 Converging stresses 121
Figure 6.6 Global risks map, 2012 122
Figure 6.7 June–July–August temperature anomaly distribution, 1951–2011 124
Figure 6.8 Multiple equilibria 126
From risk to uncertainty 128
Resilience 129
Figure 6.9 Shock and innovation 130
What we can do 131
Note 132
References 132
7 Finance for the Anthropocene 134
Introduction 134
The art of finance 135
Figure 7.1 Interdependent embedded hierarchies 137
Real investment 138
The monetary system 142
The financialisation of the economy 146
Figure 7.2 After 1980, financial asset growth accelerated 147
Figure 7.3 Interest rate derivatives, 1987–2008 148
Conclusion: a challenge to our belief system and implications for reform 150
Notes 152
References 152
Part Two: Co-operatives and the New Economy 155
8 Choices, Incentives and Co-operative Organisation 157
Co-operatives and investor-owned enterprises: what is the difference? 159
How to facilitate co-operation? 161
Two propositions 164
What are the challenges for the co-operative movement today? 166
A paradigm shift 171
In lieu of a conclusion 172
Notes 174
References 174
9 Are Co-operatives a Viable Business Form? Lessons from Behavioural Economics 176
Introduction 176
Behavioural economics and co-operative organisations 181
Figure 9.1 Unit production costs and the costs of being co-operative 184
Extending a behavioural model of co-operative organisations 186
Figure 9.2 Surplus in profit-maximising co-operatives and hierarchical firms 188
Conclusion 191
References 192
10 The Co-operative Enterprise: A Valid Alternative for a Balanced Society 194
Introduction 194
Physical capital’s strategic importance to industrial development during the age of Fordism 197
The crowding-out effect of capitalist economic power 198
The crowding-out effect of the state-based alternative 200
Dependent employment and hierarchical governance 201
The rise of the service economy and the emergence of new spaces for co-operation 204
Concluding remarks 206
Notes 207
References 208
11 Employee Ownership and Health: An Initial Study 210
Introduction 210
Background 211
Theory: the evolution of humanity 211
Hypothesis 213
Figure 11.1 Differences between Cooptown and Normaltown 215
Figure 11.2 Death rates in Cooptown and Normaltown 217
Figure 11.3 The mortality–co-operative relationship 218
Conclusion 219
Note 219
References 219
12 Co-operatives in a Global Economy: Key Issues, Recent Trends and Potential for Development 221
Introduction 221
Co-operatives, unemployment and economic crises 223
Table 12.1 Co-operatives in selected countries 224
Table 12.2 Co-operatives and job creation, 1976–81: increase in employment 225
Figure 12.1 Employment in Italy in the co-operative sector and in the economy as a whole, 2007–11 225
Figure 12.2 Employment in France in the co-operative sector and in the economy as a whole, 2005–11 226
Figure 12.3 Employment in Germany in the co-operative sector and in the economy as a whole, 2003–10 227
Figure 12.4 Employment in Spain in the co-operative sector and in the economy as a whole, 2004–10 228
Figure 12.5 Employment in Canada in the co-operative sector and in the economy as a whole, 2000–08 229
Figure 12.6 Employment in Quebec in the co-operative sector and in the economy as a whole, 2001–09 229
Figure 12.7 Survival of co-operatives and for-profit firms in Quebec 230
Table 12.3 Co-operative survival in Quebec: survival probability 230
Table 12.4 Co-operative survival in Alberta 231
Figure 12.8 Employment in Colombia in the co-operative sector and in the economy as a whole, 2000–10 231
Figure 12.9 Total co-operative entries and exits in Chile, 1990–2005 232
12.10 Co-operative entries and the institutional environment in Chile,1960–2006 232
Co-operatives and long-term growth 234
Conclusion 237
Notes 238
References 239
13 A Role for Co-operatives in Governance of Common-Pool Resources and Common Property Systems 242
The Workshop 243
The challenge: how to frame the problem 245
Rules as institutional arrangements 247
‘Discovering’ polycentricity 248
Conclusion 259
Notes 261
References 261
14 Is the Debt Trap Avoidable? 264
Introduction 264
A truly global crisis 264
The global financial crisis as a debt trap 269
Why so much debt in the real economy? 272
Resilience of co-operatives in times of crisis and their contribution to the future 274
Conclusions 278
Notes 281
References 282
Conclusion 285
Setting the stage 285
Shaping the new economy 287
Co-operatives and the ‘new economy’ 288
Conclusion 294
Co-operative economics? 296
Notes 297
References 298
About the Contributors 300
Index 303
Back Cover Back cover