Menu Expand
Sex Without Consent

Sex Without Consent

Shireen J Jejeebhoy | Iqbal Shah | Shyam Thapa

(2008)

Abstract

The pressing need to break the silence on non-consensual sex among young people – an issue shrouded by denial, underreporting and stigma – is self-evident. Despite the growing body of research regarding young people’s sexual behaviours, the study of coercive sexual experiences has generally been overlooked by both researchers and national programmes. Available evidence has been scattered and unrepresentative and despite this evidence, non-consensual sex among young people is perceived to be a rare occurrence. This volume dispels any such misconception. It presents a disturbing picture of non-consensual sex among girls as well as boys, and among married as well as unmarried young women in a variety of settings. This volume documents, moreover, the expanse of non-consensual experiences that young people face – from unwanted touch to forced penetrative sex and gang rape. Although the focus is on young females, the volume also sheds light on the experience of young males as both victims and perpetrators.

This pioneering volume highlights key factors placing young people at risk, whilst outlining the significant distinctive health and social implications they face. Sex Without Consent also documents the unsupportive – and sometimes abusive or negligent – roles of families, teachers, health care providers and law enforcement agents, outlines promising efforts intended to prevent non-consensual sex or support survivors, and argues for profound changes in norms and values that tolerate or encourage non-consensual sex. The editors, based at the Population Council (New Delhi), the World Health Organization (Geneva), and Family Health International (Virginia) argue compellingly for a radical review and reform of existing programmes designed to prevent this kind of abuse and to support young survivors of sexual trauma in the developing world. Addressing the magnitude, determinants and consequences of sex without consent, this volume provides evidence-based directions for programming.


'This book breaks the silence about sexual abuse of adolescents happening beneath the surface of stable communities. It alerts us to the individual and public health impacts of involuntary sexual involvements that adolescents lack the social, psychological, and economic means to resist. Leading authorities illuminate the subtle pressures that manipulate adolescents into exploitative sexual behaviours in societies that condemn sexual abuse in principle, but condone it in practice. The focus is on developing countries, but its findings are invaluable to understanding adolescent sexual vulnerability worldwide.' Rebecca J. Cook, University of Toronto, Canada 'This timely book does not only raise awareness about a problem that has not received adequate attention and study. It presents the evidence needed for action, based on a rich research experience of some of the best qualified researchers in the field. It provides a lot to learn from comparative findings in Africa, Asia and Latin America. It draws lessons for legal, educational, policy and health system responses. It outlines approaches for further research and for moving forward. The book is a must read for all those who want to learn more and to do more about the problem of sex without consent among people in developing countries.' Mahmoud F. Fathalla, Assiut University, Egypt
Shireen J. Jejeebhoy is a demographer at the Population Council in New Delhi. Iqbal Shah works on abortion issues at the WHO in Geneva. Shyam Thapa manages the YouthNet programme at Family Health International (FHI).

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Contents v
Figures and tables viii
Preface xi
Part One | Introduction 1
1 | Non-consensual sexual experiences of young people in developing countries: an overview 3
Defining and operationalizing non-consensual sex 4
Data sources and limitations 9
The context of non-consensual sexual experiences 12
Perpetrators of non-consensual sex 21
Outcomes of non-consensual sex 24
Underlying risk factors 26
Promising directions 35
Conclusions 38
References 38
Part Two | Non-consensual sexual experiences and underlying gender norms 47
2 | Sexual violence against women and girls: recent findings from Latin America and the Caribbean 49
Prevalence of sexual violence against women by an intimate partner 49
Sexual violence against adolescent women by intimate partners 51
Forced sex on women and girls by non-partners 53
Sexual coercion and high-risk sexual behaviour 55
Conclusions 56
References 57
3 | Young women’s experiences of forced sex within marriage: evidence from India 59
Forced sexual experience 62
Underlying risk factors 64
Divergent sexual experiences later in marriage 68
Conclusions 69
Notes 71
References 71
4 | Sexual coercion among ever-partnered women in Thailand 74
The study 75
Operationalizing sexual coercion 76
Results 77
Conclusion 81
References 84
5 | Non-consensual sex among South African youth: prevalence of coerced sex and discourses of control and desire 86
The prevalence of rape in South Africa 87
Why does South Africa have such a high prevalence of coerced sex? 89
Rape and performed masculinity 91
Conclusion 94
References 94
6 | Attitudes, norms and experiences of sexual coercion among young people in Ibadan, Nigeria 96
Setting 96
Study design 97
Findings 98
Summary and way forward 102
Note 103
References 104
7 | Investigating exchange in sexual relationships in sub-Saharan Africa using survey data 105
The theoretical framework of exchange in sexual relationships 105
Vulnerability of adolescent girls in commodity exchange relationships 108
Measuring exchange in sexual relationships using survey data 109
The Kisumu study 112
Prevalence of exchange relationships 113
Exchange relationships and reproductive health outcomes 119
Conclusion 120
Notes 121
References 122
Part Three | Young men as victims and perpetrators 125
8 | Assessing young people’s non-consensual sexual experiences: lessons from Peru 127
Background 128
Methodology 129
Findings 130
Discussion and conclusions 136
Note 137
References 137
9 | Non-consensual sexual experiences of young people in Kenya: boys as perpetrators and victims 139
Background 140
Methodology and the operationalization of non-consensual sex 141
Findings 143
Correlates of non-consensual sex among boys 148
Limitations of the study 152
Discussion and moving ahead 153
Notes 155
References 155
10 | Youth gang rape in Phnom Penh 158
Bauk in the context of Cambodia’s sociocultural milieu 158
Findings 159
Discussion 165
Possible future directions 167
References 168
Part Four | Outcomes of non-consensual sex 169
11 | Childhood and adolescent sexual abuse and incest: experiences of women survivors in India 171
Data 171
The abuse 172
Reported outcomes of sexual abuse in childhood and adolescence 180
Conclusion 184
Note 185
References 185
12 | Coerced first intercourse and reproductive health among adolescent women in Rakai, Uganda 186
Methods 188
Results 190
Discussion 196
Notes 198
References 199
13 | Coercive sex and psycho-social outcomes in adolescents: exploring the role of parental relationships 203
Setting 204
Findings 206
Discussion 208
Note 211
References 211
Part Five | Legal, education and health system responses 213
14 | The vulnerability of adolescence: legal responses to non-consensual sexual experiences of young persons in India 215
Definitions of ‘child’, ‘adolescent’ and ‘young person’ 216
Types of sexual violence 217
Sexual violence in fiduciary and non-fiduciary relationships 219
Minors as perpetrators of sexual violence 222
Procedures in court for minor victims 222
Procedures for minors as perpetrators 224
General remedies 224
Ethical concerns 225
Conclusion 225
References\r 225
15 | Synchronizing traditional legal responses to non-consensual sexual experiences with contemporary human rights jurisprudence 227
The meaning of ‘non-consensual’ in sexual experiences 228
Non-consensual sexual experiences of young people in South Africa 229
Legal responses in the South African context 230
The application of international human rights norms within the state 233
Conclusion 234
References 234
16 | Developing opportunities within the education sector to prevent non-consensual sexual experiences: an emerging issue for human rights, public health and education development goals 236
The extent and impact of non-consensual sexual experiences within the education sector 237
A multi-level approach to addressing non-consensual sexual experiences within the education sector 238
Safety and ethical considerations 246
Conclusion 247
References 248
17 | The health service response to sexual violence: lessons from IPPF/WHR member associations in Latin America 251
History of the IPPF/WHR initiative 252
Evaluation methods 253
Findings 255
Discussion and programme recommendations 265
Conclusion 266
Notes 266
References 267
18 | Non-consensual adolescent sexual experiences: policy implications 269
Guiding concepts 269
General intervention strategies 273
Settings for the implementation of interventions 278
Developing policies for non-consensual sex among young people 278
Concluding comments 282
References 282
Part Six | Approaches to the study of non-consensual sex 285
19 | Pitfalls in the study of sexual coercion: what are we measuring and why? 287
Methodology 289
Findings 289
Measuring coercion using reports 294
Conclusions 297
Note 299
References 299
20 | Research designs for investigating non-consensual sexual experiences among young people 301
Measuring non-consensual sex 302
Understanding non-consensual sexual experiences of young people 307
Evaluation of programmes 311
Conclusions 313
Notes 314
References 315
21 | Obtaining accurate responses to sensitive questions among Thai students: a comparison of two data collection techniques 318
Data collection methods 320
Results 321
Summary and conclusions 329
Notes 331
References 331
22 | Ethical issues in research on sexual coercion among youth 333
Informed consent 334
Participation of the community 335
Legal context 336
Ensuring the safety of respondents and interviewers 336
Ensuring benefits for individuals 337
The use of findings in the public interest 337
References 338
Part Seven | Moving forward 339
23 | Non-consensual sex and young people: looking ahead 341
Programme recommendations 344
Research recommendations 348
Conclusions 353
Notes on contributors 354
Index 364