Menu Expand
Reclaiming the Land

Reclaiming the Land

Sam Moyo | Paris Yeros

(2008)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Rural movements have recently emerged to become some of the most important social forces in opposition to neoliberalism. From Brazil and Mexico to Zimbabwe and the Philippines, rural movements of diverse political character, but all sharing the same social basis of dispossessed peasants and unemployed workers, have used land occupations and other tactics to confront the neoliberal state. This volume brings together for the first time across three continents - Africa, Latin America and Asia - an intellectually consistent set of original investigations into this new generation of rural social movements. These country studies seek to identify their social composition, strategies, tactics, and ideologies; to assess their relations with other social actors, including political parties, urban social movements, and international aid agencies and other institutions; and to examine their most common tactic, the land occupation, its origins, pace and patterns, as well as the responses of governments and landowners. At a more fundamental level, this volume explores the ways in which two decades of neoliberal policy - including new land tenure arrangements intended to hasten the commodification of land, and new land uses linked to global markets -- have undermined the social reproduction of the rural labour force and created the conditions for popular resistance. The volume demonstrates the longer-term potential impact of these movements. In economic terms, they raise the possibility of tackling immiseration by means of the redistribution of land and the reorganisation of production on a more efficient and socially responsible basis. And in political terms, breaking the power of landowners and transnational capital with interests in land could ultimately open the way to an alternative pattern of capital accumulation and development.

Sam Moyo is a Zimbabwean social scientist, now director of the newly founded Pan-African research organization The African Institute for Agrarian Studies (AIAS).

Paris Yeros is a Greek social scientist who, amongst other subjects, has researched the controversial land issue in Zimbabwe.


'This is a very important book which rows against the current. According to the dominant liberal paradigm, capitalist expansion has already abrogated (or is abrogating) the agrarian question, organising the transfer of labour to urban activities and modernising the rural sector, such that land reform programmes have become obsolete. The cases precisely studied in the book, covering Africa, Asia and Latin America, show that actually it is not so. On the contrary, imperialism appears thoroughly unable to resolve the agrarian question and to respond to the challenge of growing social dislocation. That structural failure is one of the major sources of growing poverty, as well as progressive political mobilisation in the countryside.'
Samir Amin, director, Third World Forum, Dakar

'This remarkable book is a much welcome contribution to our understanding of the nature and dilemmas posed by recent capitalist development in rural areas of Asia, Africa and Latin America. The essays collected in this volume combine in-depth analyses of the political dynamics unleashed in the countryside by a host of very powerful social movements with a careful survey of the cleavages and ruptures produced by the harsh introduction of neoliberal policies. The reader will gain access to a wider and deeper understanding of all the complexities of the agrarian question under the impact of neoliberal globalisation from an analytical perspective in which sound social science research fruitfully combines with the impassioned visions of rural activism.'
Atilio Boron, executive secretary of the Latin American Council of Social Sciences, Buenos Aires

'This book is a good read for anyone interested in understanding how rural social movements are organizing, evolving, and changing in the current global neo-liberal context.'
Isabella Kenfield, University of California

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover\r cover
Contents v
Introduction 1
References 6
1. The Resurgence of Rural Movements under Neoliberalism 8
The National and Agrarian Questions under Neoliberalism 10
Socio-economic Change in the Countryside 25
Politics in the Countryside 35
Conclusion 55
Notes 56
References 57
Part I AFRICA\r 65
2. Rural Land and Land Conflicts in Sub-Saharan Africa 67
Colonial Establishment and Consolidation,1880s–1930s 67
Late Colonialism, 1940s-1950s 73
Independence and Developmentalism, 1960-1970s 76
The Era of Structural Adjustment, 1980s to the Present 79
Labour and Land, Reproduction and Class 82
Politics of Land 86
Conclusion 91
Notes 92
References 96
3. Night Harvesters, Forest Hoods and Saboteurs: Struggles over Land Expropriation in Ghana 102
Land Policy in Historical Perspective 103
Forest Land: Alienation, Encroachment and Resistance 106
Agricultural Land: Alienation and Resistance 110
Problems of Political Articulation 115
Conclusion 116
References 117
4. Land Occupations in Malawi: Challenging the Neoliberal Legal Order 118
The History of Land Alienation and Reform 121
Spatial Distribution and Social Composition of Land Occupations 127
Strategies and Alliances of the Landless Movement 130
Conclusion 137
Notes 138
References 138
5. Land Occupations in South Africa 142
Land Alienation: From Apartheid to Neoliberalism 143
The Sources and Composition of Land Occupations 146
Post-Apartheid Land Policy 150
Strategies and Alliances of the Landless Movement 152
Conclusion 160
Notes 161
References 161
6. Land Occupations and Land Reform in Zimbabwe: Towards the National Democratic Revolution 165
The Political Economy of Neocolonialism 166
Land Occupations and Land Reform 182
The National Democratic Revolution at a Crossroads 193
Notes 202
References 202
Part II ASIA 207
7. Rural Land Struggles in Asia: Overview of Selected Contexts 209
Land Occupations: Moving to the Highlands 210
Land Struggles and the Collapse of Collective Agriculture 213
Land Occupations within Agrarian Reform Programmes 217
The Dull Compulsion of the Market 223
Global Migration and Rural Land Ownership 227
Conclusion 230
References 232
8. Occupation of Land in India: Experiences and Challenges 235
Land Policies and Reforms 236
State-led Land Alienation 239
The Dynamics of Land Occupations 245
Conclusion 252
Notes 253
References 254
9. Stretching the ‘Limits’ of Redistributive Reform: Lessons and Evidence from the Philippines under Neoliberalism 257
The Political Economy of the Philippines 259
Agrarian Politics before and after CARP 265
Rightful Resistance: The UNORKA Experience 272
Conclusion 278
Notes 280
References 280
Part III LATIN AMERICA 283
10. The Dynamics of Land Occupations in Latin America 285
Posing the Problem: Primitive Accumulation, Landlessness and Rural Poverty 286
Three Paths towards Reform 294
Social Movements in Latin America, Old and New 305
Conclusion 308
Notes 308
References 310
11. The Occupation as a Form of Access to Land in Brazil: A Theoretical and Methodological Contribution 317
Mobilization, Spatialization and Negotiation 319
Processes of Occupation: Types and Forms 324
The Encampments: Spaces of Struggle and Resistance 330
The Occupation as a Form of Access to Land 334
The Reaction of the Cardoso Government 336
Notes 339
References 339
12. Agrarian Reform in Brazil under Neoliberalism: Evaluation and Perspectives 341
Historical Overview of Land Policies and Reforms 341
Is There Still an Agrarian Question in Brazil? 344
Agrarian Reform under Cardoso’s Government 348
Neoliberalism versus Agrarian Reform 353
Conclusion 356
Notes 357
References 357
13. The Agrarian Question and Armed Struggle in Colombia 359
The Political Economy of Colombia 360
The Agrarian Political Economy 364
The Social and Political Structure of the FARC–EP 367
The Strategic Objectives of Armed Struggle 371
Conclusion 378
Note 378
References 379
14. Indian Peasant Movements in Mexico: The Struggle for Land, Autonomy and Democracy 383
History and Concepts 384
Indian Peoples and the Mexican State 388
The Zapatista Indians 399
Conclusion: Beyond Ethnic Specificity 405
Note 407
References 408
Notes on Contributors 411
Index 415