Menu Expand
The Political Economy of Narcotics

The Political Economy of Narcotics

Julia Buxton

(2008)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

This book explores the origins, history and organisation of the international system of narcotic drug control with a specific focus on heroin, cannabis and cocaine. It argues that the century-long quest to eliminate the production, trade in and use of narcotic drugs has been a profound failure. The statistics produced by the international and domestic narcotic drug control agencies point to a sustained expansion of the drug trade, despite the imposition of harsh criminal sanctions against those engaged, as producers, traffickers or consumers, in the narcotic drugs market. The roots of this major international policy failure are traced back to the outdated ideology of prohibition, which is shown to be counterproductive, utopian and a fundamentally inadequate basis for narcotic drug policy in the twenty-first century. Prohibition, championed by many US policy makers, has left the international community poorly positioned to confront those changes to the drug trade and drug markets that have resulted from globalisation. Moreover, prohibition based approaches are causing more harm than good, as is demonstrated through reference to issues such as HIV/AIDS, the environment, conflict, development and social justice. As the drug control system approaches its centenary, there are signs that the global consensus on narcotic drug prohibition is fracturing. Some European and South American states are pushing for a new approach based on regulation, decriminalisation and harm reduction. But those seeking to revise prohibition strategies faces entrenched resistance, primarily by the U.S. This important text argues that successive American governments have pursued a contradictory approach; acting decisively against the narcotic drug trade at home and abroad, while at the same time working with drug traffickers and producer states when it is in America's strategic interest. As a result, US policy approaches emerge as a decisive factor in accounting for the failure of prohibition.
'Buxton does a good job of undermining the case for prohibition. Excellent sources and extensive bibliography [in the book] is a credit to her clear analysis. Her style may be a little cool, but this is authoritative, provocative and just the kind of thing Sunday newspapers should be carrying on the news feature pages..' Phil Chamberlain, Tribune 'The ambivalence and confusion surrounding drugs, what they are, what they do and why they are demanded and supplied needs open, democratic debate. Julia Buxton's The Political Economy of Narcotics sheds invaluable light, raising important issues for discussion which government and society ignore at our peril.' Mike Davis, CHARTIST 'Buxton presents a lucid, compelling critical analysis of the US policies regarding illegal drugs...Buxton provides a logical, rational analysis of America's longest war and the failure of US policy to control the narcotic drug trade. This volume should be mandatory reading for US drug policy makers and will be valuable for academics and social scientists as well.' J.S. Robey, Choice 'Julia Buxton's compelling book provides an account of the history and impacts of international drugs control, and argues that current prohibition policies not only fail, but are counter-productive.' Neil Spicer, Druglink, May/June 2008
Dr Julia Buxton is Senior Research Fellow in the Centre for International Cooperation and Security in the Department of Peace Studies at the University of Bradford, UK.

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover\r Cover
Contents\r v
Tables and figures viii
Acknowledgements ix
Introduction 1
Structure of the book 2
1 | Intoxicating substances in historical perspective 4
The role of drugs in global society 4
Opium and empire 7
The Chinese opium market 11
2 | The drift to regulation and the idea of prohibition 14
Drug consumption in the western market 14
The advent of control: Britain and America contrasted 17
The US modernization experience: tension and protest 19
The alcohol prohibition movement and experience 23
3 | From regulation to control: the internationalization of drug prohibition 27
The anti-opium campaign in Britain 27
Enter America: the anti-opium campaign of the US government 29
The Shanghai Conference of 1909 and its impact 33
4 | The beginnings of international drug control 38
From principle to policy 38
Evaluating the early drug control system 42
Domestic drug control 46
5 | The post-war international drug control regime 51
The United Nations and drug control 54
The post-war model: prohibition victory? 60
Rebellion and division within the drug control system 64
6 | Trends in drug consumption 67
The knowledge gap 67
Patterns of controlled drug use 70
Consumption dynamics in the 2000s 71
7 | Trends in cultivation and production 82
Supply controls phase 1: opiates, supply reduction and the rise of the Golden Triangle 82
Supply controls phase 2: supply expansion and the Golden Crescent 85
Coca and cocaine 91
The manufacture and supply of other controlled drugs 93
The traffic in and traffickers of controlled drugs 96
8 | Accounting for failure: the problem ofprohibition 100
The limits of prohibition 100
The economics of the drug trade 101
9 | Accounting for failure 2: institutions and policy 112
Alternative development 112
Research: a hostile environment 118
Demand-side neglect 122
By way of a conclusion: institutional crisis and decline 124
10 | The political impact of drugs and drug control 126
The importance of state presence 126
Anti-drug responses: more harm than good? 132
United States: the heart of the problem 139
Full circle: more harm than good? 143
11 | HIV/AIDS and intravenous drug use 145
The epidemiology of HIV/AIDS 145
The rise of the post-Soviet drug problem 146
IDU-related sub-epidemics: the global picture 151
From IDUs to broader infection 153
Conclusion 154
12 | International drug control and HIV/AIDS 156
Harm reduction and injecting drug use 156
Injecting drug use and prisons 159
Opposition to harm reduction 160
A problem caused by drug control? 163
Conclusion 165
13 | Cultivation and drug production: the environmental costs 167
The greening of the drugs issue 167
The environmental costs of narcotic plant cultivation 168
Drug production and the environment 172
Drugs and the environment: a credible debate? 173
Conclusion 175
14 | Anti-drug policies and the environment:the role of chemical fumigation 176
US fumigation strategies in historical context: the Mexican experience 176
Contemporary fumigation strategies: Plan Colombia 179
The impact of chemical fumigation with Glyphosate 180
The politics of fumigation 184
By way of a conclusion 187
15 | The new magic bullet: bio-control solutions 190
The evolution of the mycoherbicide strategy 190
The Fusarium debate 193
The direction of mycoherbicide research 195
The politics of mycoherbicides 195
The challenge of US unilateralism 197
Conclusion 198
16 | A note on hemp 200
A brief history of hemp 200
The economic causes of hemp’s decline 202
The political causes of hemp’s decline 203
The contemporary hemp revolution 206
Conclusion 209
By way of a conclusion 211
Bibliography 213
Index 235