Menu Expand
The New Development Management

The New Development Management

Sadhvi Dar | Professor Bill Cooke

(2008)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

'Development management' is an idea that blends the seemingly innocuous claims of managerialism with notions of modernity and utopian ideals of 'third world' progress. This book views both phenomena as problematic and modernizing interventions. In doing so, it overturns and reclaims such ideas as participation, community, governance, NGOs, and civil society. The contributors argue that the practices of development are often threaded together by the language of managerialism - reports, logframe, encounters with the boss - yet all of these serve to further development's disengagement from the mundane. In voicing such concerns about the way development is going, and about the encroachment of managerialism, The New Development Management will breathe fresh life into post-development debates.
Sadhvi Dar is Lecturer in Corporate Social Responsibility and Business Ethics at Queen Mary, University of London. She holds a degree in Psychology and received her PhD in Management Studies from the University of Cambridge. She has worked in the development sector in India and the UK and is involved in a number of development projects in London. Bill Cooke is Professor of Management and Society at Lancaster University Management School. Previously he worked at the Institute for Development Policy and Management, Manchester School of Management, and Manchester Business School, all within what is now the University of Manchester, and at Teesside University. He is co-editor, with Uma Kothari, of Participation: The New Tyranny? (Zed 2001).
'This critical treatment of development management is a sorely needed and very persuasive intervention. Dar and Cooke remind us that development management is never simply a technical matter, but comes with its own historical baggage, perennially entangled in complex sets of unequal power relations. The everyday tools of the trade will never seem the same again.' Samuel Hickey, University of Manchester 'Critical thinking on the intersection between development and management studies is a rarity. From amongst those engaged in such thinking, the leading light and the rising star have combined forces to edit this outstanding collection. It should provoke debate amongst academics in both fields, as well as amongst development practitioners and policy makers, and will no doubt become a classic statement of what is at stake in the immensely complex and hugely important politics concealed within the apparently innocuous term "development management".' Christopher Grey, University of Warwick. 'This is an impressive collection that provides a much-needed critical perspective on contemporary discourses of development. Provocative but rigorous, this book will add new insights to the debate on development management.' Bobby Banerjee, University of Western Sydney 'An excellent book that brings together two disparate bodies of thinking: critical management studies (CMS) and critical development studies (CDS) ... This book thus fills a lacuna in engaging these literatures, ...The editors do a remarkable job in bringing together noted scholars in both fields ... Highly recommended for scholars and practitioners in development and management, and anyone engaging in studying, researching, or working with 'Third World Others' in the fields of geography, anthropology, sociology, and related fields.' Environment and Planning C: government and policy

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Contents v
Acknowledgements viii
Contributors x
Foreword xii
1 Introduction: The New Development Management 1
A Dual Modernization 1
Overview of the Book\r 11
Why a 'New' Development Management?\r 8
The Continuation\r 17
2 The Rise of the Global Managers\r 18
The Roots of Global Managerial Theory\r 19
The Four Propositions of Global Managerial Theory\r 21
The Historical Phases of the World Bank's Global Managerialism\r 24
'Naive' Globalization: The Origins of the World Bank\r 25
Opportunistic Growth\r 27
The Poverty Bank\r 29
Global Managerialism Theorizes Itself\r 33
Global Managerialism in Practice\r 35
Future Prospects for Global Managerialism\r 38
3 Nongovernmentalism and the Reorganization of Public Action\r 41
Development Meets Management: the Case of NGOs\r 42
Debate within NGOs about the Role of Management\r 45
External Pressures towards Managerialism\r 48
The Rise of Nongovernmentalism: the Managerialist Reorganization of Public Action\r 50
Conclusion\r 53
4 'Arrive Bearing Gifts ...': Postcolonial Insights for Development Management\r 56
Postcolonialism\r 57
Organizational Discourse Theory\r 59
Studying EWH\r 59
Colonial Ways of Knowing\r 61
Colonial Assumptions in Saving and Knowing the Other\r 64
Ambivalence and Contradiction\r 65
Silent Discourses\r 67
Saving and Knowing the Other: Persistent Discourses\r 68
My Role in the Process\r 71
Conclusion\r 72
Notes\r 73
5 Managerialism and NGO Advocacy: Handloom Weavers in India 74
Urban Experiences of Crafts: Cyberabad and Shilparamam 75
A Recent History of Two Policy Assumptions 78
An Organizational Example: Dastkar’s Approach 81
Discussion 84
Conclusions 88
Notes 89
6 International Development and the New Public Management\r 91
The Critique of Instrumental Reason 92
Critical Discourse Analysis 93
The Project Approach: Science, Planning, and War 95
The New Public Management and the Governance of International Development 98
Instrumental Technologies in International Development: the Logical Framework 100
The Logical Framework: Accountability Across Time and Space 103
Conclusion: the Carnivalesque and What Escapes the Instrumental? 108
Note\r 110
7 Participatory Management as Colonial Administration 111
Logic and Structure of the Chapter 112
Colonial Administration and Indirect Rule 112
Development Management and Participation 115
Managerialist Participation’s Debt to Indirect Rule 120
Conclusion 127
Note\r 128
8 Borders in an (In)Visible World: Colonizing the Divergent and Privileging the ‘New World Order’ 129
A Borderless World 131
Borderless Public Administration 132
(Re)Emerging Borders 135
What is Going On? 138
The Challenge for Public Administration 140
Divergence, Development and ‘Academic Imperialism’ 143
Conclusion: Towards a New Divergence in a ‘Borderless’ World 146
Coda: from New ‘Alphas’ to New Gulags 148
Note\r 149
9 The Managerialization of Development, the Banalization of Its Promise and the Disavowal of ‘Critique’ as a Modernist Illusion\r 150
Andean Villagers and the Promises that Arrive only in Their Dreams 153
Development Theories and Their Inability to Deal with the Promise of Development 156
The Postmodernization of Development: the Loss of the Object 158
Development and the Third Way: Reflexive Modernization 164
The New Ideology of Cynicism: I Know, But … 168
The Return of the Disavowed Object and the Radicalization of Development Theory 169
Interrogating the Poststructuralist Agenda: Utopianism and the Ethics of the Real 171
Notes\r 176
10 Real-izing Development: Reports, Realities and the Self in Development NGOs 177
Reports as Artefacts of Modernity 179
Reports and Real-izing Development 184
The Material Consequences of Reports 195
Conclusions 196
Afterword 198
Bibliography 204
Index 231