Menu Expand
Liberal Democracy and Its Critics in Africa

Liberal Democracy and Its Critics in Africa

Tukumbi Lumumba-Kasonga

(2008)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Democratic institutional forms and processes are increasingly widespread in Africa as dictatorial regimes have been forced to give way as a result of popular mobilization and external donor pressure. However the premises of the African scholars whose empirical research and analytical explorations are included in this volume are that democratic form and democratic substance are two different things; Western-derived institutional forms are neither necessarily the most appropriate nor the most practical in the current African context; and rooting democratic norms in the political cultures of African polities raises socio-cultural issues with which political scientists must engage. This book explores various critical questions in the context of particular elections and particular countries as diverse as Ghana, Nigeria, Kenya, the Congo, Cameroon and the Central African Republic. They include the continuing impact of police state apparatuses following democratic transition; factors influencing African voters' attitudes and behaviour; the impact of incumbency on electoral competition; women's electoral participation; the phenomenon of often very limited party programmatic choice in the context of huge social diversity and multi-party competition; and the controversial issues around the transplantation of liberal democratic institutions. Underlying these issues is the fundamental question of whether democratic processes as currently practised in Africa are really making any significant difference to the African struggle for economic, social and cultural progress. This volume is valuable for the original perspectives of its African contributors; the issues it explores; and the concrete democratic experiences it analyses; and the challenges it makes to the existing concepts, paradigms and practices of liberal democracy.
Tukumbi Lumumba-Kasongo was trained at Universite Libre du Congo, Harvard University, and the University of Chicago. He is professor of political science at Wells College, and Vice-President of the African Association of Political Science, representing the Central African region.
'An important, well-grounded and stimulating contribution to current debates on democratisation, both in Africa and globally.' New Agenda 'An informative book...Eight African scholars question what is actually on offer with liberal democracy, which today all too easily equates with rampant free-market ideology while social democracy remains off the agenda...the questions asked in this book should also be asked in Washington and Whitehall.' Tribune

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover
Contents v
About the contributors vii
Preface x
1 | The problematics of liberal democracy and democratic process: lessons for deconstructing and building African democracies 1
Introduction: objectives and issues 1
Liberal democracy and democratic process 6
A democratic process 11
Conclusion 19
References 22
2 | Reflections on the question of political transition in Africa: the police state 26
Democratic transition in Africa and the Arab world 28
From historic legitimacy to electoral legitimacy in Algeria 32
Instruments of the security state 35
Privatization and corruption 37
Conclusion: the security state and riots 38
Notes 42
References 44
3 | An explanation of electoral attitudes in Cameroon 1990–92: towards a new appraisal 46
Introduction: aspects of the problem and objectives 46
Elections: a much-visited political subject 48
Elections: a superficially appreciated subject in Cameroon 50
A creative reversion to the ethnic-identity-based theories of the First Republic 55
Electoral delinquency and validation of the paradigm of solidarity voting 56
Ground-level voting in the Grassfields 61
Conclusion 64
Notes 66
References 72
4 | Women’s participation in democratization and electoral processes in Kenya: a case study of Gusii women 1992–97 76
General issues 76
Problem statement 78
Objectives of the study 79
Justification of the study 79
Theoretical framework 80
Introduction to the study area 81
Definitions of the key concepts 82
Review literature, hypotheses and a research methodology 83
Data analysis 90
Conclusion and generalizations 95
References 97
5 | Alliances in the political and electoral process in the Republic of Congo 1991–97 99
Introduction: issues and objectives 99
Alliances during the National Conference and transition 100
Alliances and electoral processes under the transition 105
Alliances and counter-alliances at the end of the transition to the 1997 civil war 109
Conclusion 120
Notes 121
References 122
Other sources consulted 123
6 | The electoral process and the 2000 general elections in Ghana 125
Introduction: objectives and issues 125
Defining the problem 126
Concepts and their usage 127
Overview of election studies in Ghana 130
Methodological and theoretical perspectives 130
Intra-party democracy and the candidate selection process 133
The campaign process 136
Patronage and clientelist factors in the elections 138
The muddy electoral field and the ethnic conundrum 140
Conclusion 143
Notes 144
References 145
Other sources 148
7 | Voting without choosing: interrogating the crisis of ‘electoral democracy’ in Nigeria 149
Defining the situation: the crisis of electoral democracy 150
Understanding the crisis of ‘electoral democracy’ in Nigeria 154
The Nigerian political process 158
The monetization of politics and the influence of ‘moneybags' 160
Electoral commissions and the electoral process 161
Political contestation and election rigging 163
Implications for democratic consolidation 164
Conceptualizing democratic consolidation 165
Conclusion 167
Notes 168
References 169
8 | The electoral process in the Central African Republic in 1993 and 1999: protagonists and challenges 172
Background and underpinnings 172
The political process in the CAR 176
Democratic transition and the stakes of the electoral process in the CAR 181
The Joint Independent Electoral Commission (CEMI) and the 1993 and 1999 elections 182
Electoral attitudes 185
Ethnicity and the electoral process 188
The army and the electoral process in the CAR 190
Conclusion 193
References 194
9 | Conclusion: beyond the current discourse on democracy and democratic process in Africa 196
Index 204