Menu Expand
Insecure Spaces

Insecure Spaces

Doctor Marsha Henry | Doctor Paul Higate

(2009)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

In recent times, the Blue Berets have become markers of peace and security around the globe. Yet, the iconoclastic symbol of both the Blue Beret and the Blue Helmet continue to engage the international political imagination in ways that downplay the inconsistent effects of peacekeeping missions on the security of local people. In this book, Paul Higate and Marsha Henry develop critical perspectives on UN and NATO peacekeeping, arguing that these forms of international intervention are framed by the exercise of power. Their analysis of peacekeeping, based on fieldwork conducted in Haiti, Liberia and Kosovo, suggests that peacekeeping reconfigures former conflict zones in ways that shape perceptions of security. This reconfiguration of space is enacted by peacekeeping personnel who 'perform' security through their daily professional and personal practices, sometimes with unanticipated effects. Insecure Spaces' interdisciplinary analysis sheds great light on the contradictory mix of security and insecurity that peace operations create.
Paul Higate is a Senior Lecturer in Politics at the University of Bristol. Prior to that, he spent eight years in the Royal Air Force, before becoming involved in critical military sociology. Since then, his academic research has focused on various aspects of the gendered culture of the military. In his future work he plans to look at how the militarization of military sociology in recent years means that it has lost its critical edge. Marsha Henry is a Lecturer in the Politics Department at the University of Bristol. Her research has looked at various aspects of gender in South Asia, focusing on connections between the 'developed' and 'developing' worlds. Her recent research examines gender relations and perceptions of security in peacekeeping missions.
'Insecure Spaces is an innovative analysis of international power in its material, spatial and visual manifestations, an ethnography of peacekeeping and of the effects it produces on the everyday life of the ordinary people who are involved with it. A much needed study that adds a new dimension to the way we understand the making of peace.' Laura Zanotti 'In this innovative analysis of the spaces and performances of peacekeeping and peacekeepers, Higate and Henry take a fresh, critical look at how the practices of peacekeeping are constituted and experienced, and how understandings of security develop as a consequence amongst those whose lives and work are shaped by the presence of the Blue Helmets. Taking a conceptually sophisticated approach, case studies of peacekeeping in Haiti, Kosovo and Liberia are unpacked in order to understand how peacekeepers create and maintain spaces of security and insecurity. This book makes a significant contribution to studies of peacekeeping and post-conflict societies, and speaks to debates in critical international relations, critical geopolitics and contemporary sociology to provide a nuanced and engaging account of how contemporary peacekeeping activities might be more fully understood.' R.E. Woodward 'Working in a genuinely interdisciplinary framework, Higate and Henry are to be commended for this nuanced exploration of power relations in 'everyday' international peacekeeping practices. They provide an array of interesting empirical and theoretical insights into how 'secure' and 'insecure' spaces are constructed and percieved in the interplay of external actors and local populations.' David Chandler 'This contribution to the critical literature on peacekeeping is a hugely important antidote to the hegemonic positivism that claims to measure the ‘success’ or otherwise of operations. The authors use the lens of prosaic spatial practices and perceptions of peacekeeping as performance. Based on in-depth fieldwork the authors uncover peacekeeping as a vehicle of power and its spaces as sites of everyday adaptation and resistance. The work has an intellectual elegance that will be hard to match.' Michael Pugh, University of Bradford

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
About the authors i
Acknowledgements vii
Acronyms and abbreviations ix
Maps xi
Introduction 1
Background 3
Critical peacekeeping theory: a short introduction 7
Insecure spaces 16
Organization of the book 21
1 | From conflict to peacekeeping: Haiti, Kosovo and Liberia 23
Political histories and spatial feels 26
Haiti 26
Kosovo 30
Liberia 35
Conclusion 39
2 | Space, power and peace 42
Security and post-conflict space 43
The UN: conquering geography 43
NATO: expanding spaces of morality 48
Creating securityscapes: the UN/NATO franchise 53
Conclusion 57
3 | Zones and enclaves 58
From slum to zone 59
Kosovo and the enclave 66
Conclusion 72
4 | Free to move? 74
Traversing spaces: security, movement and roads 74
Kosovo: ethnic identity and ‘parallel travel’ 77
Roads, meanings, security 81
Conclusion 82
5 | Contesting and consuming: space and success in Liberia 84
Contesting space: the ‘integrated mission’ 85
Ex-combatants and peacekeepers’ ‘response’: spaces of inaction 92
Liberal market democracy: Liberia and the third space of consumption 95
Conclusion 97
6 | Performing spaces of security 99
Performing social life 100
From performance to performativity: what is expected from peacekeepers? 102
‘Tourista’ peacekeepers 106
The peacekeeper body: performing space and security 109
Bodies, props, performance 113
Conclusion 116
7 | Stereotyping performance: peacekeeping and imagined identities 118
National identity and national ‘character’: framing peacekeepers 119
Performing national identities 120
Conclusion 135
8 | Women, men and gender space 137
Feminist geopolitics and gender relations 139
Context: women, war and after 142
Men and masculinity: after the war 145
Women and gender space 150
Towards a ‘feminization’ of the mission space? 152
Concluding thoughts: the UN, NATO and the problem of gender 154
Conclusion | Locating power in peacekeeping 155
Notes 158
Introduction 158
Chapter 1 159
Chapter 2 162
Chapter 3 164
Chapter 4 167
Chapter 5 168
Chapter 6 170
Chapter 7 171
Chapter 8 172
References 173
Index 185