Menu Expand
Who Owes Who

Who Owes Who

Damien Millet | Eric Toussaint

(2008)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Using 50 questions and answers, this book explains the debt impasse for developing countries in a simple but precise manner. It details the roles of the various actors involved, the mesh in which indebted countries are caught, the possible scenarios for getting out of the impasse, and the various alternatives to future indebtedness. It also sets out the various arguments - moral, political, economic, legal and environmental - on which the case for a wholesale cancellation of developing countries‘ external debt rests. It replies to the range of possible objections and proposes new ways of financing development at both local and international level.
Damien Millet is a secretary general of The Committee for the Cancellation of Third World Debt (CADTM), a member of ATTAC in France, and a contributor to the journal Alternative. Eric Toussaint is a historian and political scientist, president of CADTM, member of the International Council of the World Social Forum, and of the scientific committee of ATTAC in France.
'As this fine study demonstrates, lucidly and persuasively, the debt that is strangling much of the world is largely a "scam". In significant measure, it is an ideological fiction, devised in the service of wealth and power, with no legitimacy or moral force. With skill and precision, the authors unravel the layers of deceit and distortion that conceal the ugly reality, and provide an important tool for liberating the great mass of suffering people who are caught in these shackles. It is a very important achievement.' Noam Chomsky 'The authors try to explain how the debt has come about. In detail, the roles of various players are discussed, as well as the mesh in which the developing countries are now caught and possible ways of escaping it.' Development and Environment

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover Cover
Contents v
Abbreviations viii
Introduction ix
ONE | The Third World in the context of globalization 1
Q1 What is meant by the Third World? 1
Q2 Are the living conditions of the poorest populations improving? 5
Q3 What are the different kinds of debt? 12
Q4 What impact does the external debt have on human development? 14
TWO | The origins of the developing countries’ (DCs’) debt 19
Q5 What were the main factors leading to the indebtedness of the DCs? 19
Q6 What is the geopolitical context of the over-indebtedness of the DCs? 21
Q7 Who were the actors in the indebtedness of the countries of the South 23
THREE | The debt crisis 27
Q8 How can the debt crisis be explained? 27
Q9 How has the external debt of the DCs evolved over the last thirty years? 30
Q10 How have the creditors responded to the debt crisis? 34
FOUR | Management of the debt crisis 36
Q11 Who is the main actor in the management of the debt crisis? 36
Q12 What does the IMF do? 38
Q13 How does the World Bank operate? 46
Q14 What is the logic behind the IMF’s and the World Bank’s economic policy? 52
Q15 What are the short-term or shock measures imposed by structural adjustment …? 54
Q16 What are the long-term or structural measures imposed by structural adjustment …? 57
Q17 What is the role of the Paris Club? 66
Q18 Are all the DCs in the same boat? 70
FIVE | Anatomy of the developing countries’ debt 74
Q19 What does the external debt of the DCs consist of? 74
Q20 Who are the main creditors of the different DCs? 75
Q21 How have the roles of the different creditors evolved over the last thirty years? 79
Q22 Do the DCs repay their debts? 82
Q23 How are the debt-related financial flows managed? 85
SIX | Ongoing moves to reduce the debt -burden 88
Q24 How did the debt-reduction initiative come about? 88
Q25 What is the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) initiative? 89
Q26 What are the results of the HIPC initiative? 94
Q27 What are the limitations of the HIPC initiative? 96
Q28 What is the New Partnership for African Development (NEPAD)? 102
Q29 What are vulture-funds? 105
SEVEN | Debt cancellation and suspensions of payment in the past 108
Q30 Have there ever been debt cancellations in the past? 108
Q31 Why do the governments of the South continue to repay the debt? 114
EIGHT | The case for cancelling the DCs’ debts 117
Q32 Will debt cancellation be enough to ensure the development of the DCs? 117
Q33 What are the moral arguments in favour of cancelling the DCs’ debts? 118
Q34 What are the political arguments in favour of cancelling the DCs’ debts? 120
Q35 What are the economic arguments in favour of cancelling the DCs’ debts? 122
Q36 What are the legal arguments in favour of cancelling the DCs’ debts? 124
Q37 What are the environmental arguments in favour of cancelling the DCs’ debts? 127
Q38 What are the religious arguments in favour of cancelling the DCs’ debts? 130
Q39 Who owes what to whom? 133
Q40 Should there be conditions attached to debt cancellation? 135
NINE | Issues raised by debt cancellation 138
Q41 If the creditors decided to cancel the debt, would it cause a global financial crisis? 138
Q42 Could cancelling the debt cause an impoverishment of the North, particularly for tax-payers? 143
Q43 How can alternative funding be found for the development of the DCs? 146
Q44 Won’t the dictatorial regimes currently in office benefit most from debt cancellation? 151
Q45 If and when the debt is cancelled, how can a new round of indebtedness be avoided? 154
Q46 Should recourse to borrowing be avoided at all costs? 155
Q47 Can the DCs’ external public debt be compared to the public debt of the North? 156
Q48 How can we achieve cancellation of the DCs’ debt …? 159
TEN | The international campaign for debt -cancellation 164
Q49 How did the international campaign for the cancellation of the debt start? 164
Q50 How was the CADTM founded? 166
Appendix: Lists of countries 169
165 DCs (authors’ count) 169
Triad 170
42 HIPCs 170
Glossary 171
Bibliography 182