Menu Expand
Citizenship and Social Movements

Citizenship and Social Movements

Eghosa E. Osaghae | Arilson Favareto | Ranjita Mohanty | Laurence Edward Piper | Simeen Mahmud | Linda Waldman | Lyla Mehta | Angela Alonso | Carlos Cortez Ruiz | Lisa Thompson | Professor Chris Tapscott

(2010)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Debates over social movements have suffered from a predominate focus on North America and western Europe, often neglecting the significance of collective action in the global South. Citizenship and Social Movements seeks to partially redress this imbalance with case studies from Brazil, India, Bangladesh, Mexico, South Africa and Nigeria. This volume points to the complex relationships that influence mobilization and social movements in the South, suggesting that previous theories have underplayed the influence of state power and elite dominance in the government and in NGOs. As the contributors to this book clearly show, understanding the role of the state in relation to social movements is critical to determining when collective action can fulfil the promise of bringing the rights of the marginalized to the fore.
Lisa Thompson is Director of the African Citizenship and Democracy (ACCEDE) and Professor at the School of Government, University of the Western Cape. Her work focuses on issues of socio-economic development in the context of the global political economy. She has published widely on research pertaining to regional development and democratisation processes in southern Africa. She serves as South African coordinator of the Development Research Centre on Citizenship, Participation and Accountability. Chris Tapscott is Professor and Dean of the Faculty of Economic and Management Sciences at the University of the Western Cape in South Africa and was formerly the founding director of the School of Government in the same institution. He has been an active member of the Development Research Centre on Citizenship, Participation and Accountability.
'This book offers a significant corrective to the Northern/western centric bias in much of the social movement literature and many of the case studies included offer evidence and insights through which the theoretical understandings of social movements could be refined and developed. Furthermore, through its specific focus on social movements, this volume makes an important contribution to the range of conceptual tools through which 'claiming citizenship' maybe understood and analysed.' Neil Stammers, University of Sussex 'Analysing social movements in Bangladesh, India, Brazil, Mexico, Nigeria and South Africa, this book presents a distinct and diverse picture of collective action – and also shows how this picture defies many of the theoretical assumptions of Northern literature on the subject. With a combination of concerns with historical and contextual background, specific characteristics of states and political systems, and cultural and political identities, this thorough and sophisticated analysis of the struggles around citizenship and rights provides a splendid venue for the debate on the limits and possibilities of social mobilization in confronting the deeply rooted and multidimensional inequality of Southern societies.' Evelina Dagnino, University of Campinas 'Citizenship is back in the centre-stage of scholarly research on state and society in the contemporary world. This collection of essays, made up of original studies from across the global South, examines the ways in which through everyday action, citizens organise to extend the boundaries of rights, deepen the foundations of participation and exact accountable governance. Individually and collectively, the essays make an important statement about comparative democracy and governance enriched with the insights from the vast experiences of Southern social movements. Students across the social and human sciences will find the perspectives that are very ably presented on contemporary citizenship and social movements by some of the best scholars based in the global South both refreshing and invigoriating' Adebayo Olukoshi, African Institute for Economic Development and Planning

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
About the editors ii
Acknowledgements vii
Abbreviations and acronyms viii
Foreword xi
1 | Introduction: mobilization and social movements in the South – the challenges of inclusive governance 1
The structure of the book, key themes and issues 6
Mobilization and social movements in the North and South: analytical debates and comparative understandings 12
The transformative potential of social movements in the South 20
Globalization, marginalization and social movements 22
Who speaks for whom? Global social movements in the global political economy 23
Social movements in the North and South: towards more synthetic understandings 25
Notes 27
References 27
PART ONE | Socio-economic rights and social movements 33
2 | Social movements and rights claims: the case of action groups in the Niger Delta 35
Setting the framework: rights and social movements 37
The Niger Delta in perspective 41
Rights struggles and the emergence of social movements 44
The nature of social movements 51
The rights framework and the future 55
Notes 57
References 58
3 | Why do garment workers in Bangladesh fail to mobilize? 60
The institutional context and political opportunity structures 61
Garment manufacturing and the labour contract 64
Workers’ associations: framing the collective struggle 72
Workers’ mobilizations and struggles: horizontal participation 74
The ‘cost’ of protest 80
Conclusions 82
Notes 83
References 84
4 | Mobilization through litigation: claiming health rights on asbestos issues in South Africa 87
Litigation and social movements 89
Context and identity: Prieska and Griquatown 92
Legal compensation and dissatisfaction 97
Conclusion 103
Notes 105
References 107
PART TWO | Social movements and global development discourses 111
5 | Water and rights: state management in South Africa and India 113
The right to free basic water in South Africa: the ideal and the reality 116
Violations of rights in India’s Narmada Valley: state policies and community responses 119
The linkage between ‘bestowed’ rights and ‘claimed’ rights 123
Conclusions 124
Notes 126
References 126
6 | Environmental activism in Brazil: the rise of a social movement 132
Formation of environmental groups (1970–85) 134
The formation of the Brazilian environmental movement 141
Conclusion 154
Notes 156
References 157
Newspapers and reports 159
7 | The struggle towards rights and communitarian citizenship: the Zapatista movement in Mexico 160
Crisis and social movements in Chiapas 163
Phases of the Zapatista movement 165
Levels of action 168
From the Zapatista movement to autonomous rebel government: characteristics, success and challenges 173
Conclusion 179
Notes 180
References 181
PART THREE | Mobilization, social movements and inclusive governance 185
8 | Participation, inclusion and development under conditions of social mobilization 187
About social participation and development 189
History, social mobilization and conflicts in the Vale do Ribeira 192
The participatory forums 198
Participation, dams and development 204
Conclusion 206
Notes 209
References 209
9 | Popular mobilization, party dominance and participatory governance in South Africa 212
Theorizing state–society relations through invented and invited spaces 213
Invented spaces: the changing patterns of popular mobilization in South Africa 214
Invited spaces: ‘participatory governance’ and local government reform 216
Popular mobilization and ‘participatory governance’ in Msunduzi and eThekwini 218
Msunduzi 2001–06: the sleepy hollow 218
eThekwini 2001–06: the neoliberal battleground 226
Conclusion 233
Note 235
References 235
10 | Contesting development, reinventing democracy: grassroots social movements in India 239
Development and dominance: birth of a people’s movement 240
The deepening democracy tasks the movements perform 244
Conclusion 255
Notes 256
References 257
11 | Social mobilization in Cape Town: a tale of two communities 260
The space economy of Cape Town 263
The Green Point Common Association 264
The Coalition for Langa Community Concerns 266
Leadership 268
Litigation as protest 270
The use of the media 272
Conclusions 274
Notes 276
References 276
About the contributors 279
Index 283