Menu Expand
Acts of Citizenship

Acts of Citizenship

Engin F. Isin | Greg M. Nielsen

(2008)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

This book introduces the concept of 'act of citizenship' and in doing so, re-orients the study of what it means to be a citizen. Isin and Nielsen show that an 'act of citizenship' is the event through which subjects constitute themselves as citizens. They claim that such an act involves both responsibility and answerability, but is ultimately irreducible to either. This study of citizenship is truly interdisciplinary, drawing not only on new developments in politics, sociology, geography and anthropology, but also on psychoanalysis, philosophy and history. Ranging from Antigone and Socrates in the ancient world to checkpoints, euthanasia and flash mobs in the modern one, the 'acts' and chapters here build up a dynamic and wide-ranging picture. Acts of Citizenship provides important new insights for all those concerned with the relationship between individuals, groups and polities.
'Acts of Citizenship is itself an exuberant, startling, act of social theory about the acts that create and transform our bonds as citizens. The names of Derrida, Levinas, and Agamben fly from the pages, along with a range of figures such as the Tank Man of Tiananmen square, Socrates, Seneca and Pat Tillman. This is the book to read if you want to know where social theory is now.' Stephen Turner, University of Southern Florida 'Without nostalgia or sentimentality, this volume revives even as it disseminates and complicates an appreciation of active citizenship. Philosophically rich, culturally wide-ranging and eminently readable, this is a marvelous, indeed inspiring book' Wendy Brown, University of California
Engin F. Isin is Chair and Professor of Citizenship in Politics and International Studies at the Faculty of Social Sciences, the Open University. He is also director of the Centre for Citizenship, Identities, Governance at the Faculty of Social Sciences.His books include Cities Without Citizens (1992) and Being Political (2002). Greg M. Nielsen is Professor of Sociology and Director of the Centre for Broadcasting Studies at Concordia University in Montreal.

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Contents v
List of Illustrations vii
Preface viii
About the Contributors ix
Introduction 1
Acts of Citizenship 1
Politics, Ethics, Aesthetics 3
Citizens, Strangers, Aliens, Outcasts 6
Sites and Scales of Answerability 8
Conclusion 10
Part I: Politics, Ethics,\rAesthetics 13
Chapter 1 Theorizing\rActs of Citizenship 15
Citizenship in Flux: Subjects, Sites, Scales 15
Theorizing Citizenship: Status, Habitus, Acts 17
Orders, Practices, Acts 19
Theorizing Ethical Acts: Responsibility and Answerability 28
Theorizing Political Acts: Law and Justice 35
Investigating Acts of Citizenship: Becoming Activist Citizens 37
Acknowledgements 39
References 40
Chapter 2 Can an Act of Citizenship Be Creative? 44
Bergson’s Method of Intuition 46
The Habits of Citizenship 47
Creativity and the Act of Citizenship 51
Conclusion 55
Acknowledgments and References 56
Chapter 3 What Levinas Can and Cannot Teach Us About Mediating Acts of Citizenship 57
Thesis 1: The Impossible Passage from the Face-to-Face to the Third Party 60
Thesis 2: Whose Metaphysics, Whose Hospitality? 65
Notes and References 70
Acts I: Heroic Intrusions and the Body of Law\r 73
Act 1 Abraham’s Sacrifice 75
Act 2 Antigone’s Offering 79
Act 3 The Death of Socrates 83
Act 4 Euthanasia 86
Act 5 Pat Tillman: Soldier-Citizen-Hero? 89
Part II: Citizens, Strangers, Aliens, Outcasts 93
Chapter 4 Citizenship Without Acts? With Tocqueville in America 95
The Political and the Social 96
Equality, Association and Dissociation 100
Self and Other 105
Similarity and Difference 109
Notes 116
References 119
Chapter 5 Acts of Piety:The Political and the Religious, or a Tale of Two Cities 121
The Body and Religion 124
Justification and the City 128
Rituals of Intimacy in South-east Asia 131
Conclusion: the Global Umma and the Crisis of Secularism 133
References 135
Chapter 6 Arendt’s Citizenship and Citizen Participation in Disappearing Dublin 137
Citizen Participation and Dublin 137
Hannah Arendt, Democracy and Citizen Participation 139
Action and the Human Condition 143
Citizenship, Freedom and the Public World 145
Labouring, Work and Citizenship Acts 149
A Reflexive Analysis of the Tension between the Planning Discourse and the Culture of Dublin 153
Notes 157
References 158
Chapter 7 No One Is Illegal Between City and Nation 160
Acts of Non-Citizenship 160
Vocalizing Acts of Citizenship 163
Border Lives 165
Autonomous Acts of Self-Representation 168
Acts of Regularization: Between City and Nation 171
Mediating Acts of Citizenship 173
Conclusions 177
Notes and References 179
Chapter 8 Acts of Demonstration: Mapping the Territory of (Non-)Citizenship\r 182
Sangatte, 1999–2002 182
Unauthorized Migration and Homo Sacer 185
The Autonomy of Migration 188
Mapping the Territory of (Non-)Citizenship 194
Notes 204
References 205
Acts II: Exclusions Without Names 207
Act 6 Promising to Become European 209
Act 7 Checkpoint Gazes 211
Act 8 The Romani 215
Act 9 Return to Guatemala 217
Act 10 Unintentional Acts of Citizenship \r(The Joke) 221
Part III: Sites and Scales of Answerability 225
Chapter 9 Citizenship, Art and the Voices of the City: Wodiczko’s The Homeless Projection 227
‘The Voice of the City’ 227
Plato and Jacobs on the City 228
A City of Voices 228
Voices and Dialogic Hybridity 230
Citizenship and Art in the Multi-voiced City 233
Beyond Communitarianism and Political Liberalism 240
Notes 242
References 245
Chapter 10 Acts of Chinese Citizenship: The Tank Man and Democracy-to-Come 247
The Tiananmen Protest 249
Moments of Political Rupture for Justice and Democracy-to-Come 251
(Un)Making Political Identity 257
Conclusion 262
Acknowledgement, Notes and References 264
Chapter 11 Answerability with Cosmopolitan Intent: An Ethics-Based Politics for Acts of Urban Citizenship 266
Similarities and Differences 267
Defining Acts of Citizenship 268
Necessary Indifference and Answerability with Cosmopolitan Intent 269
Bakhtin: The Bus Uncle and the Limits of Dialogic Pluralism 269
Simmel: Cosmopolitan States of Co-being? 274
Derrida: Citizen Politics and the Political after 9/11 277
Derrida and Simmel: Catching Acts between Law and Justice 281
Conclusion 283
Acknowledgements, Note and References 285
Acts III: Rituals and Performance 287
Act 11 Acts of \rCommemoration 289
Act 12 Non-Citizens’ Politics 292
Act 13 Flash Mobs 295
Act 14 Spike Lee’s \r25th Hour 297
Index\r 300