Menu Expand
Politics of Origin in Africa

Politics of Origin in Africa

Morten Bøås | Kevin C. Dunn

(2013)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

In this revealing new book, Bøås and Dunn explore the phenomenon of 'autochthony' - literally ‘son of the soil’ - in African politics. In contemporary Africa, questions concerning origin are currently among the most crucial and contested issues in political life, directly relating to the politics of place, belonging, identity and contested citizenship. Thus, land claims and autochthony disputes are the hallmark of political crises in many places on the African continent. Examining the often complex reasons behind this recent rise of autochthony across a number of high-profile case studies - including the Democratic Republic of Congo, Côte d'Ivoire, Liberia, and Kenya - this is an essential book for anyone wishing to understand the impact of this crucial issue on contemporary African politics and conflicts.
Morten Bøås is senior researcher at Fafo Institute for Applied International Studies in Oslo. His recent publications include Global Institutions and Development: Framing the world? (with Desmond McNeill, 2004), New and Critical Security and Regionalism: Beyond the nation state (with James J. Hentz, 2003), African Guerrillas: Raging against the machine (with Kevin Dunn, 2007) and, most recently, International Development, Volumes I-IV (with Benedicte Bull, 2010). Kevin C. Dunn is an associate professor of political science at Hobart and William Smith Colleges in Geneva, NY, USA. His publications include Imagining the Congo: The international relations of identity (2003), Africa’s Challenge to International Relations Theory (with Timothy M. Shaw, 2001), Identity and Global Politics: Theoretical and empirical elaborations (with Patricia Goff, 2004) and African Guerrillas: Raging against the machine (with Morten Bøås, 2007).
'In this compelling study of how identity and conflict may be linked in Africa, Bøås and Dunn provide detailed case studies of the Ivory Coast, DRC, Liberia and Kenya to show how the narrative of autochthony is deployed to create the Other, often with violent consequences. As the authors convincingly substantiate, the construction and exploitation of labels and identifications, such as autochthony, reflect a symptom, rather than a cause, of Africa's maldevelopment.' Ian Taylor, School of International Relations, University of St. Andrews 'This book addresses a critical and badly neglected issue in the politics of modern Africa, and makes a vital contribution to understanding the dynamics of conflict in the continent.' Christopher Clapham, Centre of African Studies, Cambridge University 'Politics of Origin in Africa argues that the definition of citizenship on exclusionary terms or the activation of ethnicity and autochthony discourses are an integral component of state-making practices. Through detailed empirical studies of violent manifestations observed in Liberia, Côte d'Ivoire, Kenya and the DRC, Morten Bøås and Kevin Dunn decipher interactions between space and identity, politics and memory, land ownership and landlessness. The outcome is an insightful and stimulating discussion of strategies associated with situations where the redistribution of resources within the neopatrimonial state and through its big men is highly dysfunctional.' Daniel C. Bach, University of Bordeaux 'Authocthony has become an important term for discussing identity politics and its relations in francophone Africa. Showing its centrality to the non-francophone countries as well, Politics of Origin in Africa reveals the inadequacy of the literature purporting resource curse on the one hand and resource scarcity on the other as the root cause for conflicts in the continent. Highlighting authocthony as "a strategy and not a fact", the authors bring the issue of local conflicts over land control and property rights to the fore, connecting them to political discourses and practices of both local and national character. This gives the book a truly refreshing, insightful and not least necessary perspective on African conflicts.' Mats Utas, The Nordic Africa Institute 'The authors' compelling insights, rooted in a deep understanding of the politics of patronage, reveal how powerful forces in the global economy disrupt old patterns of stability and how the introduction of democratic elections and administrative decentralization can in fact aggravate conflict. This is an essential book both for scholars and analysts seeking to understand the new trajectories of conflicts in African countries, and the decisive shift away from top-down networks of authority to uncertain and often contentious centres of power.' William Reno, Northwestern University 'Empirically rich and beautifully written, this book's account of the rise of an exclusionary autochtony discourse in Africa in the legitimization of political violence is paradigm-busting. It shows how and why conventional arguments focusing on natural resources, environmental scarcity, or even ethnicity miss the mark entirely and instead how the disruptions of economic liberalization, decentralization, and political liberalization have exacerbated melancholic uncertainty and nervousness about belonging and its inextricable tie to land and citizenship rights -- with parallels throughout the world. It is a must read for anyone interested in civil war, its cycles of recurrence, the potential for civil war, and the need for change in current policies of peace-building.' - Susan L. Woodward, The Graduate Center, City University of New York

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
About the authors i
Title page iii
Copyright page iv
Contents v
Acknowledgements vi
Abbreviations vii
1 | Introduction: conflict, land scarcity and tales of origin 1
Resource scarcity and armed conflict 3
Land and conflict in Africa 5
Outline of the book 8
2 | Autochthony, melancholy and uncertainty in contemporary African politics 12
The melancholy of autochthony 12
Autochthony and ontological uncertainty 16
The inherent paradox of autochthony discourses 26
Autochthony and the production of violence 29
Conclusion 32
3 | Liberia: civil war and the ‘Mandingo question’ 34
Lofa County 40
Lofa tales of origin 42
Autochthonous ‘stranger-father’ relations 44
Post-war challenges 47
Figure 3.1 Returnees after the war, by group and by year 49
A funeral for a friend – some concluding comments 50
4 | Kenya: majimboism, indigenous land claims and electoral violence 52
The 2007 election 52
Land and identity in Kenya 56
The employment of majimbo in Kenyan political discourse 62
Autochthony and violence in the 2007 general election 66
The nervous language of autochthony: the case of Mount Elgon 72
Future concerns 74
5 | Democratic Republic of Congo: ‘dead certainty’ in North Kivu 77
Belgian colonialism, the Mobutist state and the Congo War 78
North Kivu – narratives of belonging and melancholy of the past 86
Non-state armed actors and land rights issues: epitaphs to a broken dream 90
Laurent Nkunda and Rwandophones: protection and predation 98
Conclusion 102
6 | Côte d’Ivoire: production and the politics of belonging 103
A political economy of land, cocoa and labour 105
From French colonialism to the state of Félix Houphouët-Boigny 111
The melancholic nostalgia of Ivoirité and the ‘Chocolate War’ 114
Elections and civil war redux 118
Conclusion 121
7 | Conclusion 123
Notes 132
Bibliography 135
Index 144
About Zed Books 150