Menu Expand
Latin America's Turbulent Transitions

Latin America's Turbulent Transitions

Roger Burbach | Michael Fox | Federico Fuentes

(2013)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Over the past few years, something remarkable has occurred in Latin America. For the first time since the Sandinista Revolution in Nicaragua in the 1980s, people within the region have turned toward radical left governments - specifically in Venezuela, Bolivia, and Ecuador. Why has this profound shift taken place and how does this new, so-called Twenty-First-Century Socialism actually manifest itself? What are we to make of the often fraught relationship between the social movements and governments in these countries and do, in fact, the latter even qualify as 'socialist' in reality? These are the bold and critical questions that Latin America's Turbulent Transitions explores. The authors provocatively argue that although US hegemony in the region is on the wane, the traditional socialist project is also declining and something new is emerging. Going beyond simple conceptions of 'the left', the book reveals the true underpinnings of this powerful, transformative, and yet also complicated and contradictory process.
Roger Burbach was director of the Center for the Study of the Americas and a visiting scholar at the University of California, Berkeley. He wrote extensively on Latin America and US foreign policy for over four decades. He died in 2015. Michael Fox is a former editor of NACLA Report on the Americas. He has worked for many years as a freelance journalist, radio reporter, and documentary film-maker covering Latin America. He is the co-author of Venezuela Speaks!: Voices from the Grassroots (2010) and the co-director of the documentary films Beyond Elections: Redefining Democracy in the Americas and Crossing the American Crises: From Collapse to Action, both available through PM Press. He is on the board of Venezuelanalysis.com and his articles have been published in The Nation, Yes Magazine, Earth Island Journal, and more. His work can be found at blendingthelines.org. Federico Fuentes edits Bolivia Rising, is on the board of Venezuelanalysis.com, and is a regular contributor to the Australian-based newspaper Green Left Weekly, serving as part of its Caracas bureau from 2007 to 2010. He has co-authored three books with Marta Harnecker on the new left in Bolivia, Ecuador, and Paraguay. His articles have been published with ZNet, Counterpunch, MRZine, Venezuelanalysis.com, Aporrea, Rebelión, America XXI, Comuna, and other publications and websites in both Spanish and English.
'As the Millennium opened, the World Social Forum met in Brazil with the slogan "A New World is Possible," part of a global reaction to the prevailing practices of neoliberal globalization that held that "There is No Alternative." The remarkable developments in Latin America in the years since demonstrate that a new world may be in the making, not just in Latin America but perhaps reaching well beyond. The insightful and informative studies collected here reveal what has been taking place in Latin America, and the implications of these developments for the emerging world order.' Noam Chomsky 'This book describes the political vision changing the lives of millions in Latin America. It is a manual of thrilling example for us all.' John Pilger, journalist and film-maker ‘This book is essential reading. It looks at the advances made by left forces in the region, the social struggles that preceded them, and the great challenges facing those governments that have set for themselves the goal of constructing an alternative to capitalism.’ Marta Harnecker, Chilean journalist and author of Understanding the Venezuelan Revolution 'A fascinating and passionate overview of the most important social experiment on earth: Latin America's search for economic justice.' Mike Davis, author of Planet of Slums 'An intelligent and informed review of the Latin American left - its past, its prospects, and its internal debates. A first-rate contribution to our efforts to analyze and to transform the world.' Immanuel Wallerstein, Yale University 'Original and insightful analysis.' Saul Landau, Film Director and Author 'Burbach, Fox, and Fuentes have written a thoughtful account of the radical projects that have arisen in Latin America in the wake of the collapse of the "old" socialism and the simultaneous weakening of U.S. hegemony in the region. Anyone who wishes to know more about the forces behind Latin America's "left turn," and the movements from below that have made that left turn possible, will benefit from reading this book.' Fred Rosen, Editor, NACLA Report on the Americas 'A vital guide for anyone seeking to understand where the left is headed in Latin America, as well as the vexing political and social challenges confronted by charismatic leaders and progressive forces on the ground.' Nikolas Kozloff, author of Revolution! South America and the Rise of the New Left 'In a continent of ferment and change like Latin America, where we often live through tumultuous moments, a serious, documented, and critical book like Latin America's Turbulent Transitions is a valuable contribution to deepening our discussions and orienting us in the construction of a new world. Burbach, Fox, and Fuentes's vast and comprehensive chapters tackle many of the current themes and conflicts and serve as small compasses to help us understand where we are and suggest possible paths forward.' Raul Zibechi, Uruguayan Journalist, author of Dispersing Powers: Social Movements as Anti-State Forces 'Little by little, inch by inch the thick, dark velvet curtain thrown over daily events in Latin America by uninterested editors and nervous journalists in the Western media is being tugged back. Roger Burbach, Michael Fox and Federico Fuentes have produced a sparklingly up-to-date account of the "pink tide" of new thinking for the general reader. The lives and politics of the present-day political giants of the Western Hemisphere - Chávez, Lula, Correa, Raúl Castro and many more - are set out with admirable clarity by three authors who know what they are talking about. No student of the New World should be without it.' Hugh O'Shaughnessy, author of Priest of Paraguay 'Turbulent Transitions makes sense of Latin America's leftward turn, both in terms of its origins and what this turn means for some of the main countries involved. As such, it is an essential resource for the general reader and for students of the region. The case study of Venezuela is especially useful in helping us understand Hugo Chavez' historic legacy and the advent of 21st century socialism.' Gregory Wilpert, author of Changing Venezuela by Taking Power: The History and Policies of the Chavez Government 'Anyone seeking to understand the complexities and tensions of the struggles to turn the radical social transformations in contemporary capitalist Latin America into a sustained socialist project, needs to encounter this book's rare combination of open-hearted commitment and hard-headed analysis.' Steve Ludlam, University of Sheffield ‘A profoundly important book. Latin America is the last place in the world where a broad enlightened left not only survives but thrives, setting an idealistic agenda of solidarity, equality, and freedom - though often times rhetoric doesn’t match reality. Deploying a rigorous comparative framework, Latin America’s Turbulent Transitions takes an unflinching look at socialism in the region, both as it is and as it could be.’ Greg Grandin, Professor, New York University, author of Fordlandia: The Rise and Fall of Henry Ford's Forgotten Jungle City

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
More praise for Latin America’s Turbulent Transitions i
About the authors iii
Contents vii
Illustrations viii
Acknowledgments ix
Abbreviations xii
Map xiv
Introduction: turbulent transitions and thespecter of socialism 1
1 | Globalization, neoliberalism, and the rise of the social movements 13
Illustration 1 Argentine piqueteros demonstrate in Buenos Aires during the 2001–2 financial crisis 12
The challenge of the social movements 18
2 | The pink tide and the challenge to US hegemony 27
Illustration 2 The presidents of Saint Vincent and the Granadines, Bolivia, Cuba, and Venezuela 26
Globalization and nation-state autonomy 33
Reform left and radical left in power in Latin America 35
3 | Between neo-extractivism and twenty-first-century socialism 39
Illustration 3 Bolivia begins testing to exploit the world’s largest reserve of lithium on theUyuni salt flats in November 2009 38
A real anti-capitalist challenge? 40
The conundrum of the state 42
The radical left in government 43
Concluding perspectives on the left in power 45
4 | Venezuela’s twenty-first-century socialism 49
Illustration 4 Hundreds of thousands of supporters of Venezuelan president Hugo Chávez flood Bolívar avenue in Caracas 48
Revolution in an unlikely country 50
Reclaiming control over the military and oil 52
Challenging US hegemony 56
Eradicating poverty by giving power to the people 58
Building a parallel Venezuela 62
Table 4.1 Distribution of income by quintiles (1998–2006) 63
Table 4.2 Gini index of income distribution (1998–2006) 63
Radicalization and the advance of socialism 65
Bureaucracy, corruption, and popular power 69
Twenty-first-century socialism without Chávez? 73
5 | Bolivia’s communitarian socialism 79
Illustration 5 Thousands of Bolivian campesinos and indigenous farmers raise their hands during a people’s assembly in La Paz, Bolivia, in 2005 78
Economic roots of social revolution 80
Nationalizing the economy 82
‘Refounding’ the state 86
Resisting US imperialism and the rise of an indigenous-popular hegemony 88
Class showdown 89
‘Creative tensions’ on the path to communitarian socialism 92
6 | Ecuador’s buen vivir socialism, by Marc Becker 99
Illustration 6 An indigenous Ecuadoran blows a conch shell at the opening march for the June 2010 Meeting of Original Peoples and Nations of Abya Yala in Quito, Ecuador 98
Citizens’ revolution 101
Economic policies 103
Anti-imperialism 105
Extractive enterprises 106
Whither Ecuador? 112
7 | Brazil: between challenging hegemony and embracing it 115
Illustration 7 Brazilian president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and presidential candidate Dilma Rousseff attend a campaign rally in São Bernardo do Campo, São Paulo 114
Dictatorship 117
The birth of the PT and the MST 119
Foreign policy – ‘South–South relations’ 121
Domestic policy – ‘cautious, calm … solid’ 126
Poverty alleviation 127
Big business – big winners 129
Social movements – socialism and decline 132
Neo-extractivism and renewable energy 135
Trade policy – neo-developmentalism and contradictions 136
Beyond Lula 138
Challenging hegemony and embracing it 139
8 | Cuba: ‘updating’ twentieth-century socialism? 143
Illustration 8 Santiago de Cuba, 2010 142
Conclusion: socialism and the long Latin American spring 153
Illustration 9 Seven hundred women from Vía Campesina and Brazil’s Landless Workers’ Movement march against a eucalyptus plantation in Rio Grandedo Sul, Brazil 152
Appendix: nationwide elections in Venezuela, Bolivia and Ecuador 159
Notes 161
Introduction 161
1 Globalization 161
2 The pink tide 162
3 Neo-extractivism and socialism 163
4 Venezuela’s socialism 164
5 Bolivia’s socialism 168
6 Ecuador’s socialism 171
7 Brazil 173
8 Cuba 180
Conclusion 180
Bibliography 183
Index 201
About Zed Books 210