Menu Expand
The Delusions of Economics

The Delusions of Economics

Gilbert Rist | Patrick Camiller

(2011)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

In The Delusions of Economics, Gilbert Rist presents a radical critique of neoclassical economics from a social and historical perspective. Rather than enter into existing debates between different orthodoxies, Rist instead explores the circumstances that prevailed when economics was 'invented', and the resultant biases that helped forge the construction of economics as a 'science'. In doing so, Rist demonstrates how these various presuppositions are either obsolete or just plain wrong, and that traditional economics is largely based on irrational convictions that are difficult to debunk due to their 'religious' nature. As a result, we are prevented from properly understanding the world around us and dealing with the financial, environmental, and climatic crises that lie ahead. Provocative and original, this essential book provides incontrovertible proof that the construction of a new economic paradigm - pluralistic, ecologically compatible, grounded in reality - has now become a necessity.
'This is a work of sustained blasphemy. It lays bare the absurd assumptions of that lethal religion called 'mainstream economics'. Rist's book undermines the faith at the deepest level. True believers beware!' - Edward Fullbrook, Editor of Real-World Economics Review 'Rist has put before us a very powerful critique of economics. ... This book is a great contribution to getting beyond the contemporary pseudo-religion of economics and warrants the widest audience and discussion.' - Trent Schroyer, Ramapo College of New Jersey 'Drawing on a wealth of historical and anthropological evidence, Professor Rist brilliantly explains how mainstream economic doctrines - including the latest Green Economy initiative - rest on quasi-religious beliefs and assumptions that are deeply committed to the further commodification of social relations and nature. In this remarkable book, Gilbert Rist invites us to think outside the box and collectively invent radically different forms of economic exchange and ways of 'living well together'. The intellectual audacity of this book will no doubt fire peoples' social imagination: a fundamentally new economic paradigm is indeed possible and can be consciously invented by citizens. Gilbert Rist makes it also abundantly clear that human dignity, social justice, equity, cultural diversity, and ecological survival on Earth now depend on such a transformation.' - Dr Michel Pimbert, International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) 'A fine, extensive and accessible synthesis, which for that reason one can only hope will be widely read.' - Le Portail francophone des sciences sociales 'The book dispels the basic myths of economics and cleverly brings the reader to glimpse a new paradigm.' - Aziz Fall, Relations, Montréal 'With his new way of thinking of society, Rist makes us relive - from a different angle and in a different age - what Marx achieved in the 'Critique of Political Economy' with his ethnological focus on society' - Aziz Fall, Relations, Montréal 'Gilbert Rist proposes a different way of conceiving of the economy and therefore society' - L'Ecologiste 'The work remains a clear and useful antidote to mainstream economic thinking.' - Gilles Raveaud, Alternatives économiques
Gilbert Rist is professor emeritus at the Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies in Geneva. He first taught at the University of Tunis, became the Director of the Europe-Third World Centre in Geneva and, later on, Senior Researcher on a United Nations University Project. Afterwards he joined the Graduate Institute of Development Studies where he taught intercultural relations and social anthropology. His main interest is in an anthropological approach of our contemporary society. He is the author of The History of Development: From Western Origins to Global Faith (Zed Books, London, 3rd edition, 2008)

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
About the Author ii
Introduction 1
1 Economics between History and Anthropology 11
The trap of autonomous disciplines 12
Changing the optic 14
From reductionism to complexity 20
2 A Failed Scientific Ambition 22
The triumph of mechanics 24
Thermodynamics and the irreversibility of time 27
The impotence of economic ‘reason’ 32
3 Homo Oeconomicus: A Dangerous Phantom 37
The unlocatable individual 42
How to construct society? 45
The tautologies of methodological individualism 47
4 Exchange 54
The right words for it 55
Prescription or proscription 57
Giving, receiving and giving back 60
Market exchange or inverted logic 64
Do the axioms of self-interest serve the interests of exchange partners? 74
5 The Fairy Tale of Scarcity 80
The two faces of scarcity 81
The means of abundance 84
How to conquer violence in society? 87
The dual paradox 90
6 Utility and Futility 93
Questions for Jeremy Bentham 94
How to define utility? 97
Reductionist assumptions 101
7 Equilibrium 106
The Walrasian model 107
8 The Growth Obsession 117
What economic ‘science’ has chosen to exclude 118
National accounting and the invention of GDP 120
The growth obligation and its consequences 123
9 Growth Objection 131
Actually occurring ‘degrowth’ 134
Avoiding the economic trap 137
‘Sustainable development’ or another model? 141
What about the well-being of the South? 145
10 Economic ‘Science’ as Religion 150
From Émile Durkheim to Louis Dumont 150
Naturalist dogmas 154
The self-immunization of economic religion 159
11 Towards a New Paradigm? 162
Heterodoxy as the solution? 163
The diversity of economic forms 166
The Newtonian impasse 169
Conclusion 177
A look back at the origins of the crisis 178
Polanyi is back 180
Changing everything so that it remains the same 183
The blindness of ordinary economics 186
Hopes of change? 189
Critique as the precondition of a new paradigm 191
Bibliography 194
Index 204
About Zed Books 212