Menu Expand
The New Maids

The New Maids

Professor Helma Lutz

(2011)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

The New Maids is a pioneering book, grounded on rich, empirical evidence, which examines the relationship between globalization, transnationalism, gender and the care economy. Expertly addressing the thorny questions that surround the increasing number of migrant domestic workers and cleaners, child-carers and caregivers who maintain modern Western households, the author argues that domestic work plays the defining role in global ethnic and gender hierarchies. Using a central ethnographic study of immigrant domestic workers and their German employees as its starting point, The New Maids uses the voices of such women themselves to provide unique conceptual and evidential support for this vital new approach argument. This exciting book will not only enhance the reader's understanding of the new care-economy, it also sets standards for feminist global methodology.
Helma Lutz is professor of women and gender studies in the Department of Social Sciences at Goethe University, Germany. She is an associate editor of the European Journal of Women's Studies.
'Through compelling ethnographic portraits and astute theory, 'The New Maids' takes us beyond narratives of exploitation or empowerment to capture mutual dependences, transnational motherhood, and intimate labor under shifting gender, migration, and welfare regimes. It moves the scholarship on paid domestic work under globalization to new heights!' Eileen Boris, Hull Professor and Chair, Department of Feminist Studies, University of California, Santa Barbara, co-editor of Intimate Labors: Cultures, Technologies, and the Politics of Care 'With insight and conviction, Helma Lutz takes us inside the world of the foreign domestic work. She shares poignant narratives that reveal the paradoxical lives of today's maids as one of simultaneous professionalism and personalism at work, distance and proximity in the family, and the unrecognized dependency on their labor by the state. This is an important book that should be read by policy makers and scholars alike.' Rhacel Salazar Parreñas, Professor of Sociology, University of Southern California, author of 'Illicit Flirtations: Labor, Migration, and Sex Trafficking in Tokyo' 'The insights from Helma Lutz's rich ethnographic research bring a new dimension to the growing literature on women, migration and care work. In this brilliant synthesis, Lutz shows how the household becomes a 'global market for women's labour,' one in which active players 'do ethnicity' as they negotiate care and domestic work. While the focus is on Europe, The New Maids adds to our understanding of transnational women across the globe. As she did with Migration and Domestic Work, Lutz once again raises scholarship on women, migration and work to a new level.' Sonya Michel, Director of United States Studies, Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Washington, DC USA 'In this nuanced, important, big-picture book, Lutz tells us that "old maids" --serving tea, say, in a bourgeois Berlin in 1900 home -- might be an 18 year old from a nearby rural town. In the frightening l930's, she might have been one of 100,000 women the Nazis forcibly moved from the nations it conquered placed in German homes as maids. By contrast, the "new maid" is a willing volunteer of global capitalism. Compared to maids of the past, she is often older, a mother, and a migrant from the educated middle classes of the flagging economies of the Ukraine, Poland, Belorussia. As their harrowing stories reveal, however, the new maid often balances long-distance mothering with fears of being deported as an "illegal," uncertain living circumstances, and the unpredictable hearts of marginal men. A must read.' Arlie Hochschild, author of 'The Second Shift', 'The Time Bind', and co-editor of 'Global Woman' 'This is an absorbing analysis of migrant domestic and care work in Germany. Based on intensive interviews with both household employers and employees, Lutz sensitively unfolds the complex, interlocking but deeply asymmetrical employment relationship. This is a major case study of intersectionality in action. The poignant and moving biographies of transnational mother-workers are interspersed with constant analytical insights which make this book essential reading for anyone researching or working in the field of migration and care.' Fiona Williams, Emeritus Professor of Social Policy, University of Leeds

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
About the author i
Acknowledgements vi
1 | The new division of domestic labour 1
1.1 The male breadwinner: labour of love – love as labour 3
1.2 The adult-worker society 5
1.3 The multiple facets of care work 6
1.4 Commodification – redistribution of care and domestic work to non-members of the household as a new gender arrangement 10
1.5 Research on maidservants 12
The book 15
2 | The household as a global market for women’s labour 18
2.1 The feminization of migration 18
2.2 Care economy 21
2.3 Bottom-up transnationalism? 23
2.4 Transnational services at the intersection of welfare, gender and migration regimes 24
2.5 Doing gender and doing ethnicity – ‘boundary work’ in the private household 28
3 | Domestic work and lifestyles: methods and first results 31
3.1 Terminology and differentiation categories of the study 31
3.2 Data collection, sampling, field access and the mix of methods 36
3.3 Synchronous and single-location research 41
3.4 Participant observation and lifeworld inquiries 41
3.5 Conducting the interviews 42
3.6 The exploration of transnational migration biographies 44
4 | Domestic work – a perfectly normal job? 47
4.1 Introduction: the working week of a domestic employee 48
4.2 The order of things in de-ranged homes 49
4.3 Cleanness, disgust, shame 54
4.4 What children need 59
4.5 Domestic workers’ strategies: Maria la Carrera – ‘la cleaner’, the professional 68
4.6 Provisional conclusions: limits on professionalization 74
5 | Exploitation or alliance of trust? Relationship work in the household 78
5.1 Trust in place of contracts 80
5.2 More than a cleaning lady – cultural surplus value and ‘othering’: Maria la Carrera and Iris Jungclaus 84
5.3 Repairing gender identity with the domestic worker’s help: Aurora Sanchez and Simon Nickel 89
5.4 From ‘skewed nuclear family’ to elective kinship – gender reordering in the family? Tamara Jagellowsk and Ursula Pelz 95
5.5 A ‘blessed’ daughter – elective kinship beyond the grave: Anneliese Metzer and Magda Niemen 104
5.6 Provisional conclusions: egalitarian aspirations versus boundary work 110
6 | Transnational motherhood 111
6.1 The transnational mother 112
6.2 Transnational family 115
6.3 Opportunities and risks of system change: Anita Borner 119
6.4 The realization of a dream: Gizelha Santos 137
6.5 Provisional conclusions: is ‘doing family’ changed by feminized migration? 148
7 | Being illegal 154
7.1 Criminalization of illegality 155
7.2 Double irregularity 158
7.3 Education 162
7.4 Health 164
7.5 Living conditions 166
7.6 ‘Welcome to Hell’: Alexandra Marquez’s struggle for security and freedom 168
7.7 A pre-unification globetrotter: Anna Koscinska 175
7.8 Comparison of cases 182
8 | Migrant women in the globalization trap? 185
8.1 It’s ‘only’ housework … 186
8.2 New identities: ‘doing gender’ – ‘doing ethnicity’ 188
8.3 What is to be done? The necessity to recognize this work as important to society 191
Appendix 1: breakdown of the domestic workers interviewed 195
Appendix 2: breakdown of the employers interviewed 198
Notes 200
Chapter 1 200
Chapter 2 200
Chapter 3 201
Chapter 4 203
Chapter 5 204
Chapter 6 204
Chapter 7 206
Chapter 8 208
Bibliography 209
Index 230
About Zed Books 242