Menu Expand
Social Movements and Leftist Governments in Latin America

Social Movements and Leftist Governments in Latin America

Gary Prevost | Carlos Oliva Campos | Professor Harry E Vanden

(2012)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

In recent years, the simultaneous development of prominent social movements and the election of left and centre-left governments has radically altered the political landscape in Latin America. These social movements have ranged from the community based 'piqueteros' of Argentina that brought down three governments in the space of a month in 2001 to the indigenous movements in Ecuador and Bolivia that were instrumental in toppling five governments in the last decade. And in the cases of Venezuela and Brazil, social movements helped to provide the political base from which leftist leaders like Hugo Chávez and Lula were swept into power by election. This wide-ranging volume moves beyond simple discussion of these social movements to address an issue that is crucial for politics in the region today but has yet to be properly analysed - specifically, what is the position of the social movements after progressive governments take power. Are they co-opted in support of government policies or do they remain at arm’s length as continuing opponents? How many of the movement's demands are actually met and what happens when the government almost inevitably disappoints its supporters in such movements? This unique and important work explores these questions, shedding new light on how these social movements continue to operate in Latin America.
Carlos Oliva Campos teaches philosophy and history at The University of Havana. Gary Prevost is Professor in the Department of Political Science, St. John’s University/College of Saint Benedict, Minnesota. Harry E. Vanden is Professor of Political Science and International Studies at the University of South Florida, Tampa.
'This collaborative work is the first to systematically address a fundamental question in twenty-first century Latin American politics: How do the newly elected left governments respond to the social movements that played a major role in bringing them to power as well as the pressing economic and social hardships they seek to alleviate? The edited collection provides first-rate analysis of a range of state-social movement interactions - from facilitation to co-optation and repression - in arguably the most important cases in South America.' Paul Almeida, Associate Professor, School of Social Sciences, Humanities and Arts, University of California, Merced 'This book advances the most exciting debate in the revolutionary Americas: is changing the world by electing radical forces to take state power, or by forging social movements to re-make power locally, the better path to radical social change? Two strong forces meet in these cases studies, and the results are explosive.' John Foran, professor of sociology at the University of California, Santa Barbara 'This valuable examination of Latin America's innovative social movements sheds light on their complex, often uneasy interaction with the region's left-leaning governments. The authors' focus on relations between the state and mass mobilization poses a key question for the post-neoliberal era.' Richard Stahler-Sholk, Department of Political Science, Eastern Michigan University

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
About the editors i
Abbreviations vi
Preface and acknowledgments viii
Introduction 1
Social movements in context 1
Electoral victories of the left 8
How social movements have brought the left to power 12
Social movements and progressive governments 14
Notes 19
1 | Argentina’s social movements: confrontation and co-optation 22
Crisis of 2001 24
Peronist response 27
Argentine social movements today 29
Conclusion 32
Notes 33
2 | The Landless Rural Workers’ Movement \nand their waning influence on Brazil’s Workers’ Party government 34
New social movement in Brazil: the MST 37
Lula and the PT 40
Brazil gains economic strength 41
The Workers’ Party and the MST 42
Conclusion 46
Notes 47
3 | Social movements and revolutionary change in Bolivia 49
Overview 49
Historical and comparative context 50
Decentralization and social movement democracy 53
Social movement wars: water and natural gas 55
Social movements and Evo’s revolution in governance 59
Social movements and the struggle over autonomy 61
Indigenous resurgence and the struggle for the new Constitution 65
Social movements and the drug war 68
Evo and social movements: here to stay (for now) 74
Notes 85
4 | Dilemmas of urban popular movements in popular-sector comunas of Santiago, Chile 88
Introduction: socio-spatial struggle in the neoliberal era 89
Urban socio-spatial conflict in Peñalolen 91
The CMSP’s objectives and strategies: ‘from social movement to communal power’ 97
The dilemmas of popular movements in the context of ‘neoliberal society’ 102
Penetrating the popular sectors and ‘resignifying’ civil society 107
Conclusion 112
Notes 113
5 | Social movements and the government of Rafael Correa: confrontation or cooperation? 116
Rafael Correa 118
2009 elections 119
Indigenous critiques 124
Twenty-first-century socialism 128
Many lefts 133
Notes 134
6 | Venezuela: movements for rent? 137
Figure 6.1 Protests and repressed protests 138
Movements and the petrostate: from Gómez to the collapse of Punto Fijo 138
Social movements and the rise of Chávez 141
Social movements in the Chávez era 144
Figure 6.2 Structure of the consejos comunales 156
Party state and popular power 159
Opposition movements and the state 160
Autonomy – a false ideal? 162
Conclusion 164
Notes 165
Conclusion: future trends in Latin American politics 169
About the contributors 173
Index 175
About Zed Books 182