BOOK
Marginality and Exclusion in Egypt
Ray Bush | Habib Ayeb | Asef Bayat | Heba Hagrass | Ali Kadri | Reem Saad | Dalia Wahdan | Rabab El Mahdi | Saker El Nour | Kamal Fahmi | Moushira Elgeziri
(2012)
Additional Information
Book Details
Abstract
What does it mean to be marginalized? Is it a passive condition that the disadvantaged simply have to endure? Or is it a manufactured label, reproduced and by its nature transitory?
In the wake of the new uprising in Egypt, this insightful collection explores issues of power, politics and inequality in Egypt and the Middle East. It argues that the notion of marginality tends to mask the true power relations that perpetuate poverty and exclusion. It is these dynamic processes of political and economic transformation that need explanation.
The book provides a revealing analysis of key areas of Egyptian political economy, such as labour, urbanization and the creation of slums, disability, refugees, street children, and agrarian livelihoods, reaching the impactful conclusion that marginalization does not mean total exclusion. What is marginalized can be called upon to play a dynamic part in the future -- as is the case with the revolution that toppled President Mubarak.
'The contributors to this book effectively challenge the category of marginality as it is commonly used and show that "marginal" people and groups are actively created by the processes of neoliberal capitalism in which they have no role or value. At the same time, "marginals" do not acquiesce to their fate but find creative ways to exercise agency in dealing with their situations. Some contributors argue for the utility of a revised notion of marginality; others argue for increased attention to class and exploitation. This lively debate is a valuable contribution to understanding the underside of the neoliberal phase of capitalism in Egypt.'
Joel beinin, Donald J. McLachlan Professor of History, Stanford University, California
'This fascinating collection captures the rhythms of real life for the majority of Egyptians. Along with analytical heft, it features portraits of everyday abjection, struggle and adaptation that ring searingly true. Required reading for serious students of Egypt.'
Chris Toensing, Middle East Research and Information Project
'This exciting book provides superb background to an understanding of the Egyptian "revolution" of 2011 and continuing. It provides fresh data on topics that are not generally covered in the press. The essays in this book are essential to understanding Egypt, both the expected and the unexpected.'
Nicholas Hopkins, Professor Emeritus of Anthropology, The American University in Cairo
'I cannot imagine a more relevant collection of revealing snapshots of Egyptian society in the lead-up to the ousting of Mubarak. This excellent book not only offers an insightful reading of the conditions which led to the struggle of the Egyptian people against a devastating neoliberal economic system but also provides a solid contribution, which is grounded in class analysis and an experience of collective resistance, to our understanding of concepts of marginality and exclusion.'
Maha Abdelrahman, University of Cambridge
Ray Bush is Professor of African Studies and Development Politics at the University of Leeds, UK.
Habib Ayeb is a researcher at the Social Research Center at the American University in Cairo. He has worked in the Ministry of Agriculture in Tunisia, the University of Paris 8-St Denis, CEDEJ (Centre d’Etudes et de Documentation Juridiques et Sociales), IRD (Institute of Research for Development) and the SRC.
Table of Contents
Section Title | Page | Action | Price |
---|---|---|---|
About the editors | i | ||
Tables and figures | vi | ||
Tables | vi | ||
3.1 Growth in real GDP per capita in the Arab Near East | 34 | ||
3.2 List of selected conflicts and wars in the Mashreq region | 43 | ||
3.3 Military spending as a percentage of GDP for selected Arab countries, 1988–2005 | 44 | ||
11.1 Preparatory completion and type of secondary school attended; young people, 15–19 years of age, 2006 | 202 | ||
11.2 Type of technical secondary school attended by year | 202 | ||
11.3 Type of technical secondary school programme attended, by gender, 2005/06 | 203 | ||
11.4 Type of higher education attended by type of secondary completed, age 25–29, 2006 | 203 | ||
11.5 Type of higher education attended by type of secondary school completed and wealth quintiles, young people, age19–23, 2006 | 207 | ||
Figures | vi | ||
5.1 Evolution of the number and area of farms in Egypt of less than one feddan, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 81 | ||
5.2 Evolution of the number of farms in Egypt classified into area categories, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 82 | ||
5.3 Evolution of the area of farms in Egypt classified into area categories, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 82 | ||
5.4 Evolution of the number of owned and rented farms in Egypt, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 83 | ||
5.5 Evolution of the area of owned and rented farms in Egypt, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 83 | ||
11.1 The structure of the education system in Egypt | 200 | ||
Measures | vii | ||
Acknowledgements | viii | ||
PART ONE Marginality, poverty and political economy | 1 | ||
1 | Introduction: Marginality and exclusion in Egypt and the Middle East | 3 | ||
Note | 12 | ||
References | 12 | ||
2 | Marginality: curse or cure? | 14 | ||
Introduction | 14 | ||
The term and its trajectory | 15 | ||
Marginality and modernity | 16 | ||
Marginality and capitalism | 17 | ||
Curse or cure? | 20 | ||
Notes | 26 | ||
References | 27 | ||
3 | Accumulation by encroachment in the \nArab Mashreq | 28 | ||
The Arab Near East | 31 | ||
Table 3.1 Growth in real GDP per capita in the Arab Near East | 34 | ||
An inherently comprador ruling class | 36 | ||
The casus belli | 39 | ||
Evolving conditions | 42 | ||
Table 3.2 List of selected conflicts and wars in the Mashreq region | 43 | ||
Table 3.3 Military spending as a percentage of GDP for selected Arab countries, 1988–2005 | 44 | ||
Peripheralization in the Arab Near East | 45 | ||
A post-revolutionary age? | 48 | ||
Notes | 50 | ||
References | 50 | ||
PART TWO Creating and reproducing \rmarginality | 53 | ||
4 | Marginality or abjection? The political economy of poverty production in Egypt | 55 | ||
Introduction | 55 | ||
Poverty in the Middle East | 57 | ||
Egypt | 59 | ||
The (re)production of poverty | 61 | ||
Conclusion | 65 | ||
Notes | 68 | ||
References | 69 | ||
5 | The marginalization of the small peasantry: Egypt and Tunisia | 72 | ||
Introduction | 72 | ||
Social marginalization in Egypt | 76 | ||
Economic liberalization and the marginalization of Egypt’s peasants | 79 | ||
Law 96 of 1992: the revenge of large landowners and the marginalization of small farmers and tenants | 80 | ||
Figure 5.1 Evolution of the number and area of farms in Egypt of less than one feddan, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 81 | ||
Figure 5.2 Evolution of the number of farms in Egypt classified into area categories, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 82 | ||
Figure 5.3 Evolution of the area of farms in Egypt classified into area categories, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 82 | ||
Figure 5.4 Evolution of the number of owned and rented farms in Egypt, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 83 | ||
Figure 5.5 Evolution of the area of owned and rented farms in Egypt, 1982, 1990, 2000 | 83 | ||
Land fragmentation and peasant marginalization in Egypt | 84 | ||
Near-landless – less than two feddans: the losers | 85 | ||
Landholdings of two to five feddans: dispossession and accumulation | 86 | ||
The Tunisian south-east: social and spatial marginalization | 86 | ||
Oasis in danger: from palms to concrete | 89 | ||
Shortage of water: dried springs | 90 | ||
Agribusiness marginalizes small farmers and reduces local biodiversity | 90 | ||
Conclusion | 93 | ||
Notes | 94 | ||
References | 94 | ||
6 | Margins and frontiers | 97 | ||
Intellectuals and lifestyle choices | 98 | ||
The Nagada story3 | 102 | ||
Ascribed marginality: the Upper Egyptian low-status tribe | 105 | ||
Notes | 110 | ||
References | 110 | ||
7 | Transport thugs: spatial marginalization in a Cairo suburb | 112 | ||
Introduction | 112 | ||
Sitta October | 114 | ||
Debt and the city | 117 | ||
Struggles over transport | 119 | ||
Spatial marginality and livelihoods | 127 | ||
Notes | 130 | ||
References | 131 | ||
8 | Against marginalization: workers, youth and class in the 25 January revolution | 133 | ||
Policed neoliberalism | 134 | ||
Trade unions, workers and the struggles for justice | 140 | ||
Class and revolution | 143 | ||
Conclusion | 145 | ||
Notes | 146 | ||
References | 146 | ||
9 | National geographical targeting of poverty in Upper Egypt | 148 | ||
Introduction | 148 | ||
The geographical targeting approach to poverty reduction | 149 | ||
Poverty mapping trials in Egypt | 150 | ||
Determining poor areas | 151 | ||
Egypt’s poverty map in 2007 | 152 | ||
Geographical targeting and social policies in Egypt | 154 | ||
Targeting the poorest 1,000 villages: project design and implementation | 155 | ||
Geographical targeting of poverty: Asyut governorate | 156 | ||
Project operational structure in Asyut | 157 | ||
Administrative and local power | 158 | ||
The village and targeting | 159 | ||
Data validity and reliability | 160 | ||
Poverty relief projects | 161 | ||
Local definitions of poverty | 163 | ||
Conclusion | 164 | ||
Notes | 165 | ||
References | 166 | ||
10 | Working with street kids: unsettling accounts from the field | 169 | ||
Introduction | 169 | ||
Street children | 170 | ||
Participatory action research (PAR) | 171 | ||
Methodological challenges | 173 | ||
The kids’ manipulations and the workers’ acculturation | 177 | ||
Invisible others: the gatekeepers | 177 | ||
Managing emotions: fear and prejudice | 178 | ||
Witnessing destitution | 179 | ||
Sensitive issues: drug consumption and sexuality | 180 | ||
Silent practices | 183 | ||
Violence | 186 | ||
Conclusion | 187 | ||
Note | 189 | ||
References | 189 | ||
11 | Marginalization and self-marginalization: commercial education and its graduates | 191 | ||
Introduction | 191 | ||
The 1952 revolution and education | 192 | ||
Problems of education: marginality and inequality | 195 | ||
Figure 11.1 The structure of the education system in Egypt | 200 | ||
Table 11.1 Preparatory completion and type of secondary school attended; young people, 15–19 years of age, 2006 | 202 | ||
Table 11.2 Type of technical secondary school attended by year | 202 | ||
Table 11.3 Type of technical secondary school programme attended, by gender, 2005/06 | 203 | ||
The beginning of the crisis: who pays the price? | 203 | ||
Table 11.4 Type of higher education attended by type of secondary completed, age 25–29, 2006 | 203 | ||
Chronic problems of technical education | 205 | ||
Table 11.5 Type of higher education attended by type of secondary school completed and wealth quintiles, young people, age 19–23, 2006 | 207 | ||
Recent developments | 208 | ||
The labour market and university education | 212 | ||
Conclusion | 212 | ||
Notes | 214 | ||
References | 215 | ||
12 | Disability in transition in Egypt: between marginalization and rights | 219 | ||
Reveal or conceal?: disability figures in Egypt | 219 | ||
The services provided by governmental and non-governmental institutions | 221 | ||
Governmental institutions | 222 | ||
Non-governmental institutions | 226 | ||
Legislation | 228 | ||
The boiling point: pre-revolutionary and revolutionary times | 231 | ||
References | 232 | ||
Contributors | 236 | ||
Index | 238 | ||
About Zed Books | 248 |