Menu Expand
Marginality and Exclusion in Egypt

Marginality and Exclusion in Egypt

Ray Bush | Habib Ayeb | Asef Bayat | Heba Hagrass | Ali Kadri | Reem Saad | Dalia Wahdan | Rabab El Mahdi | Saker El Nour | Kamal Fahmi | Moushira Elgeziri

(2012)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

What does it mean to be marginalized? Is it a passive condition that the disadvantaged simply have to endure? Or is it a manufactured label, reproduced and by its nature transitory? In the wake of the new uprising in Egypt, this insightful collection explores issues of power, politics and inequality in Egypt and the Middle East. It argues that the notion of marginality tends to mask the true power relations that perpetuate poverty and exclusion. It is these dynamic processes of political and economic transformation that need explanation. The book provides a revealing analysis of key areas of Egyptian political economy, such as labour, urbanization and the creation of slums, disability, refugees, street children, and agrarian livelihoods, reaching the impactful conclusion that marginalization does not mean total exclusion. What is marginalized can be called upon to play a dynamic part in the future -- as is the case with the revolution that toppled President Mubarak.
'The contributors to this book effectively challenge the category of marginality as it is commonly used and show that "marginal" people and groups are actively created by the processes of neoliberal capitalism in which they have no role or value. At the same time, "marginals" do not acquiesce to their fate but find creative ways to exercise agency in dealing with their situations. Some contributors argue for the utility of a revised notion of marginality; others argue for increased attention to class and exploitation. This lively debate is a valuable contribution to understanding the underside of the neoliberal phase of capitalism in Egypt.' Joel beinin, Donald J. McLachlan Professor of History, Stanford University, California 'This fascinating collection captures the rhythms of real life for the majority of Egyptians. Along with analytical heft, it features portraits of everyday abjection, struggle and adaptation that ring searingly true. Required reading for serious students of Egypt.' Chris Toensing, Middle East Research and Information Project 'This exciting book provides superb background to an understanding of the Egyptian "revolution" of 2011 and continuing. It provides fresh data on topics that are not generally covered in the press. The essays in this book are essential to understanding Egypt, both the expected and the unexpected.' Nicholas Hopkins, Professor Emeritus of Anthropology, The American University in Cairo 'I cannot imagine a more relevant collection of revealing snapshots of Egyptian society in the lead-up to the ousting of Mubarak. This excellent book not only offers an insightful reading of the conditions which led to the struggle of the Egyptian people against a devastating neoliberal economic system but also provides a solid contribution, which is grounded in class analysis and an experience of collective resistance, to our understanding of concepts of marginality and exclusion.' Maha Abdelrahman, University of Cambridge
Ray Bush is Professor of African Studies and Development Politics at the University of Leeds, UK. Habib Ayeb is a researcher at the Social Research Center at the American University in Cairo. He has worked in the Ministry of Agriculture in Tunisia, the University of Paris 8-St Denis, CEDEJ (Centre d’Etudes et de Documentation Juridiques et Sociales), IRD (Institute of Research for Development) and the SRC.

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
About the editors i
Tables and figures vi
Tables vi
3.1 Growth in real GDP per capita in the Arab Near East 34
3.2 List of selected conflicts and wars in the Mashreq region 43
3.3 Military spending as a percentage of GDP for selected Arab countries, 1988–2005 44
11.1 Preparatory completion and type of secondary school attended; young people, 15–19 years of age, 2006 202
11.2 Type of technical secondary school attended by year 202
11.3 Type of technical secondary school programme attended, by gender, 2005/06 203
11.4 Type of higher education attended by type of secondary completed, age 25–29, 2006 203
11.5 Type of higher education attended by type of secondary school completed and wealth quintiles, young people, age19–23, 2006 207
Figures vi
5.1 Evolution of the number and area of farms in Egypt of less than one feddan, 1982, 1990, 2000 81
5.2 Evolution of the number of farms in Egypt classified into area categories, 1982, 1990, 2000 82
5.3 Evolution of the area of farms in Egypt classified into area categories, 1982, 1990, 2000 82
5.4 Evolution of the number of owned and rented farms in Egypt, 1982, 1990, 2000 83
5.5 Evolution of the area of owned and rented farms in Egypt, 1982, 1990, 2000 83
11.1 The structure of the education system in Egypt 200
Measures vii
Acknowledgements viii
PART ONE Marginality, poverty and political economy 1
1 | Introduction: Marginality and exclusion in Egypt and the Middle East 3
Note 12
References 12
2 | Marginality: curse or cure? 14
Introduction 14
The term and its trajectory 15
Marginality and modernity 16
Marginality and capitalism 17
Curse or cure? 20
Notes 26
References 27
3 | Accumulation by encroachment in the \nArab Mashreq 28
The Arab Near East 31
Table 3.1 Growth in real GDP per capita in the Arab Near East 34
An inherently comprador ruling class 36
The casus belli 39
Evolving conditions 42
Table 3.2 List of selected conflicts and wars in the Mashreq region 43
Table 3.3 Military spending as a percentage of GDP for selected Arab countries, 1988–2005 44
Peripheralization in the Arab Near East 45
A post-revolutionary age? 48
Notes 50
References 50
PART TWO Creating and reproducing \rmarginality 53
4 | Marginality or abjection? The political economy of poverty production in Egypt 55
Introduction 55
Poverty in the Middle East 57
Egypt 59
The (re)production of poverty 61
Conclusion 65
Notes 68
References 69
5 | The marginalization of the small peasantry: Egypt and Tunisia 72
Introduction 72
Social marginalization in Egypt 76
Economic liberalization and the marginalization of Egypt’s peasants 79
Law 96 of 1992: the revenge of large landowners and the marginalization of small farmers and tenants 80
Figure 5.1 Evolution of the number and area of farms in Egypt of less than one feddan, 1982, 1990, 2000 81
Figure 5.2 Evolution of the number of farms in Egypt classified into area categories, 1982, 1990, 2000 82
Figure 5.3 Evolution of the area of farms in Egypt classified into area categories, 1982, 1990, 2000 82
Figure 5.4 Evolution of the number of owned and rented farms in Egypt, 1982, 1990, 2000 83
Figure 5.5 Evolution of the area of owned and rented farms in Egypt, 1982, 1990, 2000 83
Land fragmentation and peasant marginalization in Egypt 84
Near-landless – less than two feddans: the losers 85
Landholdings of two to five feddans: dispossession and accumulation 86
The Tunisian south-east: social and spatial marginalization 86
Oasis in danger: from palms to concrete 89
Shortage of water: dried springs 90
Agribusiness marginalizes small farmers and reduces local biodiversity 90
Conclusion 93
Notes 94
References 94
6 | Margins and frontiers 97
Intellectuals and lifestyle choices 98
The Nagada story3 102
Ascribed marginality: the Upper Egyptian low-status tribe 105
Notes 110
References 110
7 | Transport thugs: spatial marginalization in a Cairo suburb 112
Introduction 112
Sitta October 114
Debt and the city 117
Struggles over transport 119
Spatial marginality and livelihoods 127
Notes 130
References 131
8 | Against marginalization: workers, youth and class in the 25 January revolution 133
Policed neoliberalism 134
Trade unions, workers and the struggles for justice 140
Class and revolution 143
Conclusion 145
Notes 146
References 146
9 | National geographical targeting of poverty in Upper Egypt 148
Introduction 148
The geographical targeting approach to poverty reduction 149
Poverty mapping trials in Egypt 150
Determining poor areas 151
Egypt’s poverty map in 2007 152
Geographical targeting and social policies in Egypt 154
Targeting the poorest 1,000 villages: project design and implementation 155
Geographical targeting of poverty: Asyut governorate 156
Project operational structure in Asyut 157
Administrative and local power 158
The village and targeting 159
Data validity and reliability 160
Poverty relief projects 161
Local definitions of poverty 163
Conclusion 164
Notes 165
References  166
10 | Working with street kids: unsettling accounts from the field 169
Introduction 169
Street children 170
Participatory action research (PAR) 171
Methodological challenges 173
The kids’ manipulations and the workers’ acculturation 177
Invisible others: the gatekeepers 177
Managing emotions: fear and prejudice 178
Witnessing destitution 179
Sensitive issues: drug consumption and sexuality 180
Silent practices 183
Violence 186
Conclusion 187
Note 189
References 189
11 | Marginalization and self-marginalization: commercial education and its graduates 191
Introduction 191
The 1952 revolution and education 192
Problems of education: marginality and inequality 195
Figure 11.1 The structure of the education system in Egypt 200
Table 11.1 Preparatory completion and type of secondary school attended; young people, 15–19 years of age, 2006 202
Table 11.2 Type of technical secondary school attended by year 202
Table 11.3 Type of technical secondary school programme attended, by gender, 2005/06 203
The beginning of the crisis: who pays the price? 203
Table 11.4 Type of higher education attended by type of secondary completed, age 25–29, 2006 203
Chronic problems of technical education 205
Table 11.5 Type of higher education attended by type of secondary school completed and wealth quintiles, young people, age 19–23, 2006 207
Recent developments 208
The labour market and university education 212
Conclusion 212
Notes 214
References 215
12 | Disability in transition in Egypt: between marginalization and rights 219
Reveal or conceal?: disability figures in Egypt 219
The services provided by governmental and non-governmental institutions 221
Governmental institutions 222
Non-governmental institutions 226
Legislation 228
The boiling point: pre-revolutionary and revolutionary times 231
References 232
Contributors 236
Index 238
About Zed Books 248