Menu Expand
Speaking Our Minds

Speaking Our Minds

Thom Scott-Phillips

(2014)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Language is an essential part of what makes us human. Where did it come from? How did it develop into the complex system we know today? And what can an evolutionary perspective tell us about the nature of language and communication?

Drawing on a range of disciplines including cognitive science, linguistics, anthropology and evolutionary biology, Speaking Our Minds explains how language evolved and why we are the only species to communicate in this way.

Written by a rising star in the field, this groundbreaking book is required reading for anyone interested in understanding the origins and evolution of human communication and language.
Language is an essential part of what makes us human. Where did it come from? How did it develop into the complex system we know today? And what can an evolutionary perspective tell us about the nature of language and communication?

Drawing on a range of disciplines including cognitive science, linguistics, anthropology and evolutionary biology, Speaking Our Minds explains how language evolved and why we are the only species to communicate in this way.

Written by a rising star in the field, this groundbreaking book is required reading for anyone interested in understanding the origins and evolution of human communication and language.

"This I believe is the most important and the best book ever written on the evolution of language. It is the most important because it integrates like never before the different perspectives of linguistics, psychology, primatology, evolutionary biology, and anthropology into a novel and compelling explanation of how language emerged and evolved. It is the best because, moreover, it achieves this level of integration with great simplicity and clarity. A must-read.' - Dan Sperber, Emeritus Research Professor, CNRS, Paris, France & Professor of Cognitive Science, Central European University, Budapest, Hungary

"Scott-Phillips has done an amazing job, combining approaches from fields as disparate as linguistics, cognition and evolutionary theory, to bring clarity to our understanding of human language. He explains what is special about human language, where it came from, and why it mattered for evolution. He has cut through the jargon to produce a highly readable book that will appeal to all users and students of communication, from humpty dumpty to eminent linguists." - Stu West, Professor of Evolutionary Biology, University of Oxford, UK

"Clear, engaging, both serious and yet fun to read, this book offers a fresh perspective on what often seems to be a well-worn topic. It will reinvigorate debate, and encourage new ways of thinking." - Louise Barrett, Professor of Psychology & Canada Research Chair in Cognition, Evolution and Behaviour, University of Lethbridge, Canada

"This is a highly accessible account of the nature of human language that challenges many common assumptions and makes a compelling argument for how we should approach language evolution." - Katie Slocombe, Evolutionary Psychologist & Senior Lecturer, University of York

"This book is very impressive. The spirit of scientific endeavour and the excitement of understanding a complex topic come across strongly." – Andrew Wells, formerly Senior Lecturer in Psychology at LSE, UK

"'Speaking Our Minds' is an engagingly written and convincingly argued work that promises to stimulate much new research in the field. The book offers a unifying account that tackles many of the questions surrounding the evolution of language." - Journal of Language Evolution


Thom Scott-Phillips is a research fellow in Evolutionary and Cognitive Anthropology, at Durham University, UK. He currently holds an Addison Wheeler Fellowship and a prestigious ESRC Future Research Leaders grant, and was previously a Leverhulme Early Career Fellow at the University of Edinburgh. He has spent the past 10 years studying and researching the evolutionary origins of human communication and language. His work has received multiple prizes and accolades, including the New Investigator Award from the European Human Behaviour and Evolution Association in 2011, and the British Psychological Society's award for Outstanding Doctoral Research in 2010.

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Cover\r Cover
Half-Title\r i
Title\r iii
Copyright\r iv
Dedication\r v
Contents\r vii
1. Two Approaches to Communication 1
1.1 “A good old fi ddle” 1
1.2 The code model 2
1.3 The expression and recognition of intentions 7
1.4 The ostensive-inferential model 10
1.5 Natural codes and conventional codes 13
1.6 Two meanings of meaning 21
2. The Emergence of Communication Systems 27
2.1 Combinatorial communication 27
2.2 The functional interdependence of signals and responses 29
2.3 A chicken-and-egg problem 33
2.4 The improbability of combinatorial communication 36
2.5 Ostension and inference: a third route to communication 40
2.6 The creation of combinatorial communication 42
2.7 Continuity and discontinuity in the origins of language 45
3. Cognition and Communication 52
3.1 Pragmatic competence 52
3.2 The maxims of conversation 54
3.3 A paradigm for pragmatics 57
3.4 Recursive mindreading and ostensive communication: the theory 63
3.5 Recursive mindreading and ostensive communication: the data 69
3.6 Cooperation and communication 75
4. The Origins of Ostensive Communication 79
4.1 Communication and the comparative method 79
4.2 The difference between intentional and ostensive communication 83
4.3 Do great apes communicate with ostension and inference? 86
4.4 Do great apes communicate with natural codes? 91
4.5 Mindreading in non-human primates 95
4.6 The social brain 99
4.7 The advent of ostensive communication 101
5. Building a Language 106
5.1 Evolutionary linguistics 106
5.2 Early ostensive communication 108
5.3 The fi rst symbols 111
5.4 A pragmatic perspective on protolanguage 115
5.5 A short note on grammaticalization 119
5.6 Cultural attraction, and the naturalness of languages 120
5.7 The role of communication in language evolution 124
6. Evolutionary Adaptation 131
6.1 Adaptationism 131
6.2 Language and adaptation 133
6.3 Linguistic communication as social navigation 138
6.4 Vigilance and argumentation 141
6.5 The boy who cried ‘Wolf!’, and how he might be stopped 145
6.6 The evolutionary stability of human communication 149
6.7 A major transition in the evolution of life? 152
Epilogue: The Big Questions Answered 154
Glossary 157
References 161
Index of Names 183
Subject Index 189