Menu Expand
Having and Belonging

Having and Belonging

Judy Jaffe-Schagen

(2016)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

The home and the museum are typically understood as divergent, even oppositional, social realms: whereas one evokes privacy and familial intimacy, the other is conceived of as a public institution oriented around various forms of civic identity. This meticulous, insightful book draws striking connections between both spheres, which play similar roles by housing objects and generating social narratives. Through fascinating explorations of the museums and domestic spaces of eight representative Israeli communities—Chabad, Moroccan, Iraqi, Ethiopian, Russian, Religious-Zionist, Christian Arab, and Muslim Arab—it gives a powerful account of museums’ role in state formation, proposing a new approach to collecting and categorizing particularly well-suited to societies in conflict.


“There are many books that attempt to place museums in a national and a subnational context, but Having and Belonging’s innovative methodology and careful research set it apart. It makes a valuable contribution not only to museology but also to studies of immigration, nationalism, and ethnicity.” · Steven Lavine, California Institute of the Arts

“This is a well-written and highly original work combining studies of material culture, life histories, museums, and migration. It offers a kaleidoscopic perspective on the many communities that comprise Israeli society, with an analysis that is multilayered and empathetic.” · Dienke Hondius, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam


Judy Jaffe-Schagen obtained her doctorate in history from Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. She has extensive experience communicating the results of new scholarship to the public through museum exhibitions and related media. Currently, in affiliation with the Amsterdam School for Heritage and Memory Studies, she is researching the role of museums and memorials in helping migrant groups to become acknowledged and respected within society.

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Contents 5
Illustrations 7
Preface—Switzerland? 9
Acknowledgments 11
Introduction 13
Chapter 1 — Establishing Collections, Building a Nation 25
Chapter 2 — Exhibiting Belief: Religious Objects in a Secular Institution: Mrs Marantz and the Israel Museum 48
Chapter 3 — More Than One Story to Tell: Mrs Sapir-Bergstein and Beit Hatfutsot, the Museum of the Jewish People 69
Chapter 4 — A Migration Museum and Its Visitors: Mrs Kaduri and the Babylonian Jewry Heritage Center 87
Chapter 5 — Indigenous Curation Provides a Second Glance: Mr Yeshayahu and Bahalachin, the Ethiopian Jewish Heritage and Cultural Center 104
Chapter 6 — Medals Rather Than High Art: Mr Pens and the Museum of the Jewish Soldier in World War II 122
Chapter 7 — On Colors and Borders: Mrs Romem and the People of Israel Website 139
Chapter 8 — A Holiday as Object: Mrs Salameh and Beit HaGefen 157
Chapter 9 — The Geographical Position of Art and Home: Mrs Abu Ilaw and the Umm el Fahem Art Gallery 169
Chapter 10 — Belonging 185
To Conclude: Switzerland Once More 207
Bibliography 212
Index 230