Menu Expand
ICTs and Development in India

ICTs and Development in India

T. T. Sreekumar

(2011)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

‘ICTs and Development in India’ is a unique attempt to study the nature and consequences of the growing presence of Information Technology in development projects in India, focusing particularly on E-governance and Information & Communication Technologies (ICT) development programs initiated by Civil Society Organizations (CSOs). Sreekumar persuasively argues that there is in fact a wide chasm between the expectations and the actual benefits of CSO initiatives in rural India, and that recognising this crucial fact yields important lessons in conceptualizing development and social action in rural areas.


'ICTs and Development in India' provides a critical account of the impact of the use of Information Technology in development projects in India, focusing particularly on E-governance and Information & Communication Technologies (ICT) development programs initiated by Civil Society Organizations (CSOs). Sreekumar challenges the conventional wisdom concerning the potential of ICT to provide unprecedented social and economic opportunities for vulnerable groups such as women and marginalized communities by highlighting its failure to bridge social divides. He argues that in addition to reinforcing existing social divides, the patterns of ICT deployment and control have in certain cases created new divides. Given such tensions and contradictions, this book questions whether it is appropriate to consider civil society as an independent realm of social action separated from State and Market.

Sreekumar offers a fresh perspective and added depth to the discussions on the social impacts of new technologies in rural areas, especially in terms of methods, analytics and approach. The recognition of the shortcomings of CSO initiatives plays an important part in redefining the role of civil society and understanding its fractured relations with the State and Market. Sreekumar therefore creates a powerful critique on the interpretation of agency and the structure of rural transformation as mediated by new technologies in the particular context of India's social and economic transition.


T. T. Sreekumar is Assistant Professor at the Department of Communications and New Media at the National University of Singapore. His research interests focus on the social impact of ICTs, the impact of mobile phones in developing countries, and the social impacts of tourism, civil society and new social movements and youth techno-culture in Asia.


‘Rural India has become a model laboratory for global experiments in a new era of market-driven development communication. T. T. Sreekumar’s critical and empirically rich study of India’s emerging “rural network society” offers a much needed counter-history to the dominant techno-utopian narratives that continue to fuel both policy and scholarly discussions.’ — Paula Chakravartty, Associate Professor, Department of Communication, University of Massachusetts

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Front Matter i
Half Title i
Title Page iii
Copyright Page iv
CONTENTS v
LIST OF FIGURES AND TABLES vii
PREFACE ix
Main Matter 1
Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION: EXPLORING THE RURAL NETWORK SOCIETY 1
Two Rural Vignettes and the Beginning of a Story 1
ICTs, ICT4D and the Neo-Liberal Discourse 6
ICTs and the Civil Society Argument 13
Research Questions, Contexts and Conceptual Framework 19
Analytical Issues for Discussion 24
Methodology and Sources of Information 27
Organization and Focus 30
Chapter 2: CIVIL SOCIETY AND CYBER–LIBERTARIAN DEVELOPMENTALISM 33
The Cyber–Libertarian Turn 33
ICTs and Neo-Liberal Developmentalism: The Rise of the Social Enterprise Model 35
Information Village Research Project (IVRP) 40
TARAkendras 45
Expectations and Outcomes 48
State–CSO Relations: Emerging Contradictions 56
Narratives of Success and the Sustainability Puzzle 58
Lessons and Non-Lessons 63
Chapter 3: DECRYPTING E-GOVERNANCE 67
Technology and Governance 67
The Beginnings of E-Governance in India 68
Gyandoot: Organization and Technology 72
E-Governance and the Kiosks: The Social Dynamics 74
E-Governance and the Network Society: Deciphering the Narratives of Success 82
QUANGOs, Civil Society and the Private Sector 91
Beyond Technocratic Definitions 93
Chapter 4: CYBER-KIOSKS AND DILEMMAS OF SOCIAL INCLUSION 97
ICTs and Social Change 97
Gender and Information Technology 98
Women and ICTs: Rhetoric and Reality of Participation 101
Gyandoot: Tribal Women at Large 103
TARAkendras: Accepting Gender Divisions 106
Knowledge Centres and Women’s Participation 109
Social Enterprises as Social Movements 112
Participation in Net-Based Social Action 116
ICTs and Limits of Developmental CSOs 122
Chapter 5: INNOVATING FOR THE RURAL NETWORK SOCIETY 125
The Appropriate Technology for the Masses 125
Innovation and CSOs in Rural ICT Interventions 128
CSOs and the Triple Helix Model 130
The Simputer: ‘Gandhi’s Invention, Steve Jobs’ Ad Campaign’ 134
The Case of CorDECT WLL: ‘The MIDAS Touch’ 144
ICT Innovations, CSO and the State 149
Chapter 6: ICT AND DEVELOPMENT: CRITICAL ISSUES 151
Civil Society, Community and ICTs 151
Structure and Agency 155
Technology and Sustainability 161
Rural Network Society: The Politics of Transformation 168
End Matter 175
NOTES 175
Chapter 1. Introduction: Exploring the Rural Network Society 175
Chapter 2. Civil Society and Cyber–Libertarian Developmentalism 177
Chapter 3. Decrypting E-Governance 180
Chapter 4. Cyber-Kiosks and Dilemmas of Social Inclusion 183
Chapter 5. Innovating for the Rural Network Society 185
Chapter 6. ICT and Development: Critical Issues 186
BIBLIOGRAPHY 187
INDEX 207