Menu Expand
Being and Becoming European in Poland

Being and Becoming European in Poland

Marysia H. Galbraith

(2014)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

Overthrowing communism in 1989 and joining the European Union in 2004, the Polish people hold loyalties to region, country and now continent – even as the definition of what it means to be ‘European’ remains unclear. Paying particular attention to those who came of age in the earliest years of the neoliberal and democratic transformations, this book uses the life-story narratives of rural and urban southern Poles to reveal how ‘being European’ is considered a fundamental component of ‘being Polish’ while participants are simultaneously ‘becoming European’. Ultimately, this study demonstrates how the EU is regarded as both an idea and an instrument, and how ordinary citizens make choices that influence the shape of European identity and the legitimacy of its institutions.


Marysia H. Galbraith is an associate professor at the University of Alabama’s New College and Department of Anthropology.


Overthrowing communism in 1989 and joining the European Union in 2004, the Polish people hold loyalties to region, country and now continent – even as the definition of what it means to be ‘European’ remains unclear. This book uses the life-story narratives of rural and urban southern Poles to reveal how ‘being European’ is considered a fundamental component of ‘being Polish’ while participants are simultaneously ‘becoming European’.

Close attention to the individual lives of Poles allows the author to identify cultural patterns and grasp the impact of the EU on its member states, paying particular attention to how the EU has affected the life experiences of Poles who came of age in the earliest years of the neoliberal and democratic transformations. In exploring what it means to be Polish by tracking these parallel processes of change, the author traces Poland’s path from state socialism to European integration and Polish identities as they are reinscribed, revised and reinvented in the face of historic, political and economic processes.

Ultimately, this study demonstrates how the EU is regarded as both an idea and an instrument, and how ordinary citizens make choices that influence the shape of European identity and the legitimacy of its institutions.


Bronislaw Malinowski Social Science Award


“Galbraith’s innovative book is a must for anyone interested in postsocialist transformations. Through the author’s deep understanding of Poles’ cognitive categories, we see the EU as it is experienced in everyday life. Her insights will spark new debates in European studies.” —Jaro Stacul, University of Alberta


“A wise and interesting book based on a fresh field of evidence which highlights issues important to individuals as well as societies.” —Zofia Sokolewicz, Professor Emerita, Institute of Ethnology and Cultural Anthropology, University of Warsaw

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Being and Becoming European in Poland i
Title iii
Copyright iv
CONTENTS v
LIST OF FIGURES AND TABLES ix
Figures ix
Tables x
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS xi
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION: BEING AND BECOMING EUROPEAN IN POSTCOMMUNIST POLAND 1
Long-Term Fieldwork 4
Anthropological Studies of the European Union 10
Anthropological Studies of Nation and Ethnicity 16
Anthropological Studies of Self 20
A Person-Centered Approach to European Integration and Collective Identities 24
Chapter 2 “WE HAVE ALWAYS BEEN IN EUROPE”: DEPLOYING THE PAST TO SHAPE THE PRESENT 27
Bartek: Historical Consciousness in the Twenty-First Century 27
Deploying the Past to Shape the Present 29
National Mythology: Polish Messianism and the Heroic Ideal 30
National Mythologies in Everyday Life 36
Corruption of a glorious past 38
The history that matters is personal 39
Past and future in Europe 41
The Smolensk Disaster 44
History of Katyn 45
Commemoration and controversy 46
A country divided? Competing explanations of the tragedy 50
Moving Forward 52
Aneta: Not the Christ of Nations Anymore 53
Chapter 3 “UNBELIEVABLE! POLES ARE HAPPY”:\rLOOKING TOWARD THE FUTURE 57
Józef: Building a Future 57
Unbelievable! Poles Are Happy! 59
The 1990s: Living in the Present 61
The Twenty-First Century: Looking toward the Future 68
Education 69
Mortgages 72
Children 74
Retirement 75
“Even the Crisis Didn’t Work Out” 77
Wiola: Everything on Schedule 80
Chapter 4 “WE’RE EUROPEAN BECAUSE WE’RE POLISH”: LOCAL, NATIONAL AND EUROPEAN IDENTITIES 83
Wojtek: Pole, European and Euroskeptic 83
Imagining Territorial Scales of Social Organization 85
Attachment to Place: Quality and Intensity at Different Scales 88
Talking about region 89
Talking about nation 93
Talking about Europe 96
European Integration and Territorial Scales of Belonging 98
Do scales of belonging preclude each other? 98
Which do you consider your priority? 101
Which describes you best? 103
Being and Becoming European 107
Marek: I Can Live Anywhere 108
Chapter 5 “EU MEMBERSHIP GIVES POLAND A BETTER CHANCE”: PERSPECTIVES ON EUROPEAN INTEGRATION 113
Ewelina: Prospects for a Better Life in the European Union 113
Becoming European: Overview of the Integration Process 116
Association 118
Candidacy 119
Accession 121
Perspectives on the European Union 123
Economic opportunity vs. consumer market 125
Governance: Transnational order vs. external control 126
Implications for the European Union 131
Krzysiek: Let Someone Else Govern Us 133
Chapter 6 “NOW WE CAN TRAVEL WITHOUT A PASSPORT”: MOBILITY IN THE EUROPEAN UNION 137
Dorota: Opportunity and Loss in England 137
Mobility in the European Union 140
History of Polish Migration 143
“I Can Go Abroad with just My ID Card, and I Can Work Legally” 149
Eased restrictions on mobility 149
Social advancement and social demotion in an imagined world hierarchy 151
Global mobility and the choice to stay home 155
Traveling without a Passport 157
Stasiek: Transnational Entrepreneur 158
Chapter 7 “THIS REGION IS OUR \rPRIORITY”: EU SUBSIDIES AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF A TRANSNATIONAL REGIONAL COMMUNITY 163
Joasia: Social Entrepreneur 163
Using EU Subsidies: Social Entrepreneurs, Public Servants and Flexible Farmers 166
EU Programs and Local Projects 168
Agriculture 169
Infrastructure 173
Regional culture 175
EU Standards and New Ways of Being 181
Transnational Regional Community 187
Halina: Organic Farmer 189
Chapter 8 CONCLUSION:\rCOMING OF AGE IN EUROPE 193
Appendix LIST OF PARTICIPANTS 203
Notes 207
Chapter 1 Introduction: Being and Becoming \rEuropean in Postcommunist Poland 207
Chapter 2 “We Have Always Been in Europe”: Deploying the Past to Shape the Present 208
Chapter 3 “Unbelievable! Poles Are Happy”: Looking toward the Future 210
Chapter 4 “We’re European because We’re Polish”: \rLocal, National and European Identities 210
Chapter 5 “EU Membership Gives Poland a Better Chance”: Perspectives on European Integration 211
Chapter 6 “Now We Can Travel without a Passport”: Mobility in the European Union 211
Chapter 7 “This Region Is Our Priority”: EU Subsidies and the Development of a Transnational Regional Community 211
Chapter 8 Conclusion: Coming of Age in Europe 213
REFERENCES 215
INDEX 229