Menu Expand
Modern European Tragedy

Modern European Tragedy

Annamaria Cascetta

(2014)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

The idea of the tragic has permeated Western culture for millennia, being closely bound with the concept of the limit of inescapable necessity that has been embodied in and expressed through theatre since the time of the ancient Greeks. This book addresses the question of how the twentieth century – one of the most violent periods of human history – dealt with the fundamental structure that is the tragic. Examining the consciousness of the era through an in-depth analysis of some of the twentieth century’s most outstanding texts – including works by Ibsen, Claudel, O’Neill, Brecht, Camus, Beckett, Pasolini, Grotowski, Delcuvellerie and Josse De Pauw – ‘Modern European Tragedy’ draws a vivid picture of the development that tragedy experienced during this time. Along the way, the book engages with some of the prominent currents of twentieth-century thought and philosophy that can still be found in the varied map of contemporary thought today: the ideas of modern Christianity, psychoanalysis, the theory of the Absurd, nihilism, Marxism and the acceptance of the limit. Together, analyses of these currents serve to support the book’s key avenues of investigation: its explorations of what inspired these key authors to engage with the idea of the tragic; and its explanation of why the contemporary tragic no longer bears the form of classic tragedy.


‘Cascetta offers a synoptic vision that includes many of the twentieth century’s most fascinating “tragic” texts. “Modern European Tragedy” should provoke new conversations on old and important topics.’ —Alan Ackerman, Professor of English, University of Toronto


The idea of the tragic has permeated Western culture for millennia, and has been expressed theatrically since the time of the ancient Greeks. However, it was in the Europe of the twentieth century – one of the most violent periods of human history – that the tragic form significantly developed. ‘Modern European Tragedy’ examines the consciousness of this era, drawing a picture of the development of the tragic through an in-depth analysis of some of the twentieth century’s most outstanding texts.


Annamaria Cascetta is a professor of theatre history and the former director of the Department of Communication and Performing Arts at the Catholic University of Milan.

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Modern European Tragedy\r i
Title\r iii
Copyright iv
CONTENTS vii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ix
Introduction 1
Relevance of the Tragic, Irrelevance of Tragedy 1
The Tragic Scene in the Twentieth Century: A Selection of Dramatic and Performance Texts and a Hypothesis of Interpretation 3
Greek Tragedy: An Essential Frame of Reference 6
The Scenario of the Twentieth Century: Generations in Violence 12
Chapter 1 HUBRIS AND GUILT: GENGANGERE (GHOSTS) BY HENRIK IBSEN 15
Janus bifrons 15
From Ancient to Modern Tragedy: Ibsen’s Sources 16
The Tragic Nuclei 18
The Form of Modern Tragedy 27
A Perfect Theatrical Machine 29
Chapter 2 EVE BECOMES MARY: L’ANNONCE FAITE À MARIE (THE TIDINGS BROUGHT TO MARY) BY PAUL CLAUDEL 31
The History of the Text\r 32
Chapter 3 THE SCHOOL OF HATRED: MOURNING BECOMES ELECTRA BY EUGENE O’NEILL 47
In Europe, Thinking of the New Broadway 47
Structure and Plot 48
From Electra to Lavinia 51
Hatred: The Driving Force of the Tragedy 53
Tragic Pessimism: From the Autobiographical Plane to the Historical and the Philosophical-Anthropological 56
Chapter 4 THE DESTINY OF MAN IS MAN: MUTTER COURAGE UND IHRE KINDER (MOTHER COURAGE AND HER CHILDREN) BY BERTOLT BRECHT 59
The Genesis of the Work 60
The Context: Europe in Catastrophe 60
A Mother without Tears and a Mute Who Beats the Drum of Vengeance. The Stone Begins to Speak. 64
Sources and Contexts: The Mentality of War 67
The Limit and Destiny of Humanity Lies in Others. Tragedy Is Not Inevitable. But Courage Learns\r Nothing. 69
Tragedy and the Epic Style 72
Chapter 5 THE TRAGIC AND THE ABSURD: CALIGULA BY ALBERT CAMUS 75
History of the Text and Contexts 75
The First Version of Caligula in ‘les trois Absurdes’ 78
The Faces of the Absurd: From the First Caligula to the Last 80
From the Historical Character to the Tragic-Absurd Character: ‘Poetry is More Philosophical and More Important than History’ 85
The Absurd and Caligula’s Way: Nihilism 86
Grotesque Tragedy 88
Another Way: From Cherea to Rieux 89
Chapter 6 DIANOETIC LAUGHTER IN TRAGEDY: ACCEPTING FINITUDE: ENDGAME BY SAMUEL BECKETT 91
‘He’s crying. […] Then he’s living’: Weeping and Life 91
The Limit and the Evil of the World Disguised as a Minimalist Universe 93
Laughing at Tragedy 97
Form without Drama 99
Chapter 7 THE ARROGANCE OF REASON AND THE ‘DISAPPEARANCE OF THE FIREFLIES’: PILADE (PYLADES) BY PIER PAOLO PASOLINI 101
The Idea of the Tragic: Between Structure of the Human and Historical Transformation 101
The Theatre as ‘Cultural Ritual’ 101
Theatre as the Awareness and Pilot of Change 102
An Anthropological Key to Pylades 103
The Return of the Same, or Destiny and the March of History 112
Chapter 8 THE APOCALYPSE OF A CIVILIZATION: FROM AKROPOLIS TO APOCALYPSIS CUM FIGURIS BY JERZY GROTOWSKI 117
An Introductory Summary 117
The Language of Nightmare 122
Our Acropolis: A Colossal Tragic Farce 124
Towards the Tragedy of Apotheosis and Derision: A Laboratory for ‘Poor Theatre’ 126
The Simpleton-Christ Theme, or the Challenge of Freedom: The Expulsion 142
A Provisional Epilogue BETWEEN THE EXPERIENCE AND THE REPRESENTATION OF THE TRAGIC: TOWARDS A PERFORMATIVE THEATRE 147
Endless Horrors in Stage Scripts from the End of the Century: The Representation of Planned Genocide 147
Appendix CHRONOLOGY OF PRODUCTIONS 163
NOTES 199
Introduction The Tragic, Tragedy and the Idea of the Limit 199
Chapter 1 Hubris and Guilt: Gegangere (Ghosts) by Henrik Ibsen 201
Chapter 2 Eve Becomes Mary: L’annonce faite à Marie (The Tidings Brought to Mary) by Paul Claudel 205
Chapter 3 The School of Hatred: Mourning Becomes Electra by Eugene O’Neill 208
Chapter 4 The Destiny of Man Is Man: Mutter Courage und ihre Kinder (Mother Courage and Her Children) by Bertolt Brecht 210
Chapter 5 The Tragic and the Absurd: Caligula by Albert Camus 213
Chapter 6 Dianoetic Laughter in Tragedy: Accepting Finitude: Endgame by Samuel Beckett 217
Chapter 7 The Arrogance of Reason and the ‘Disappearance of the Fireflies’: Pilade (Pylades) by Pier Paolo Pasolini 218
Chapter 8 The Apocalypse of a Civilization: From Akropolis to Apocalypsis cum figuris by Jerzy Grotowski 223
A Provisional Epilogue Between the Experience and the Representation of the Tragic: Towards a Performative Theatre 230
INDEX 233