Menu Expand
Civilizing Missions in Colonial and Postcolonial South Asia

Civilizing Missions in Colonial and Postcolonial South Asia

Carey A. Watt | Michael Mann

(2011)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

‘Civilizing Missions in Colonial and Postcolonial South Asia’ offers a series of analyses that highlights the complexities of British and Indian civilizing missions in original ways and through various historiographical approaches. The book applies the concept of the civilizing mission to a number of issues in the colonial and postcolonial eras in South Asia: economic development, state-building, pacification, nationalism, cultural improvement, gender and generational relations, caste and untouchability, religion and missionaries, class relations, urbanization, NGOs, and civil society.


‘The present set of essays is a valuable contribution to the ongoing discourse made relevant in the wake of neocolonialism and invasion of independent nations carried out in the name of progress of “less civilized” societies. […] [S]uch [a] broad spectrum of continuities of the “civilizing mission,” within and beyond India in the colonial and postcolonial periods, adds to the appeal of this volume. […]This volume should therefore be a necessary addition to the library of every student of history.’ —Vinod John, ‘Religious Studies Review’


‘Civilizing Missions in Colonial and Postcolonial South Asia’ demonstrates how the civilizing mission can serve as an analytical rubric with relevance to many themes in the colonial and postcolonial eras: economic development, state building, pacification, nationalism, cultural improvement, gender and generational relations, caste and untouchability, religion and missionaries, class relations, urbanization, NGOs, and civil society.

While some chapters investigate civilizing initiatives that were driven by the British Raj or Indian postcolonial state, the book also considers many examples of nongovernmental undertakings. For example, examining the role of missionary educational endeavours shows how missionary bodies could operate in an ambivalent space between Indians and the colonial state. Moreover, analysis of Indian civilizing efforts carried out by nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), the nationalist movement or postcolonial Indian states gives us interesting opportunities to scrutinize how the civilizing mission could be internalized as a form of 'self-civilizing' by Indians. Some papers also show the global linkages of civilizing efforts in the British Empire, while others examine long-term continuities through broad comparative analyses covering the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. This takes us into the postcolonial era (beyond 1947, into the late twentieth and twenty-first centuries), and such 'transgressions' across the colonial divide give this volume added appeal.


Carey A. Watt holds a PhD in South Asian history from the University of Cambridge, and is currently Associate Professor of History (South Asia/World) at St. Thomas University in Canada.

Michael Mann holds a PhD from the University of Heidelberg and is currently Professor of South Asian History and Culture at Humboldt University, Berlin.

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Front Matter i
Half Title i
Title Page iii
Copyright Page iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS v
Main Matter 1
Introduction THE RELEVANCE AND COMPLEXITY OF CIVILIZING MISSIONS C. 1800–2010 1
Civilizing Missions Today? 1
The Present Book 12
Postcolonial Britain: An Area for Further Research? 26
Notes 28
Part One: THE RAJ’S REFORMS AND IMPROVEMENTS: ASPECTS OF THE BRITISH CIVILIZING MISSION 35
Chapter One: CONJECTURING RUDENESS: JAMES MILL’S UTILITARIAN PHILOSOPHY OF HISTORY AND THE BRITISH CIVILIZING MISSION 37
Introduction: The History of British India as an Exercise in Futility 37
Approaching The History of British India: Mill’s Science of Human Nature 40
The Scale of Civilizations 44
Conjecturing Rudeness: Mill’s Historiographical Method 52
Conclusion: Mill and the Civilizing Mission 57
Notes 58
Chapter Two: ART, ARTEFACTS AND ARCHITECTURE: LORD CURZON, THE DELHI ARTS EXHIBITION OF 1902–03 AND THE IMPROVEMENT OF INDIA’S AESTHETICS 65
Prologue: On the Political Implications of Art and Architecture 65
Art and Architecture as a Marker of Progress 68
The Indo-European Debate on Indo-Saracenic vs Palladio-Classic Architecture 75
On the Development of Arts and Artefacts: The Delhi Arts Exhibition of 1902–03 78
Epilogue: Of Patronage and Politics 84
Notes 86
Part Two: COLONIALISM, INDIANS AND NONGOVERNMENTAL ASSOCIATIONS: THE AMBIGUITY AND COMPLEXITY OF ‘IMPROVEMENT’ 91
Chapter Three: INCORPORATION AND DIFFERENTIATION: POPULAR EDUCATION AND THE IMPERIAL CIVILIZING MISSION IN EARLY NINETEENTH CENTURY INDIA 93
Introduction 93
1. Incorporation: Universal Education for Civilization 96
2. Differentiation: Useful Knowledge for Different Social Positions 101
3. Hierarchical Inclusion, Selective Appropriation, Renegotiating Positions 107
4. Demand and Supply, Technologies and Effects: The ‘Copy-Book System’ 111
Conclusion: Tensions of Empire and the Limits of the Civilizing Mission 114
Notes 116
Chapter Four: RECLAIMING SAVAGES IN ‘DARKEST ENGLAND’ AND ‘DARKEST INDIA’: THE SALVATION ARMY AS TRANSNATIONAL AGENT OF THE CIVILIZING MISSION 125
Introduction 125
The Emergence of Salvationism in Mid-Victorian England 127
The Imperial Mission Without 137
Concluding Remarks 149
Appendix 151
Notes 152
Chapter Five: MEDIATING MODERNITY: COLONIAL STATE, INDIAN NATIONALISM AND THE RENEGOTIATION OF THE ‘CIVILIZING MISSION’ IN THE INDIAN CHILD MARRIAGE DEBATE OF 1927–1932 165
Child Marriage, Colonialism and the ‘Civilizing Mission’ 167
Nationalism, Feminism and the ‘Self-Civilizing Mission’ 171
Pragmatism, Principle and the Colonial State 177
The Aftermath 183
Notes 185
Part Three: INDIAN ‘SELF-CIVILIZING’ EFFORTS C. 1900–1930 191
Chapter Six: ‘CIVILIZING SISTERS’: WRITINGS ON HOW TO SAVE WOMEN, MEN, SOCIETY AND THE NATION IN LATE COLONIAL INDIA1 193
Conclusion 208
Appendix. The Life of Women: Women’s Place in Ancient Times 209
Notes 212
Chapter Seven: FROM ‘SOCIAL REFORM’ TO ‘SOCIAL SERVICE’: INDIAN CIVIC ACTIVISM AND THE CIVILIZING MISSION IN COLONIAL BOMBAY C. 1900–1920 217
Introduction 217
Reclaiming the ‘Depressed Classes’ 219
Social Work and the Urban Poor 227
Conclusion 235
Notes 236
Part Four: TRANSCENDING 1947: COLONIAL AND POSTCOLONIAL CONTINUITIES 241
Chapter Eight: FEMALE INFANTICIDE AND THE CIVILIZING MISSION IN POSTCOLONIAL INDIA: A CASE STUDY FROM TAMIL NADU C. 1980–2006 243
Introduction 243
Why Female Infanticide in Postcolonial Tamil Nadu? 244
Description of the Government Policies and Programmes 246
Pre-Application Criteria 251
Post-Application Criteria 251
Voices from the Field 253
Concluding Remarks 263
Notes 265
References 268
Chapter Nine: PHILANTHROPY AND CIVILIZING MISSIONS IN INDIA C. 1820–1960: STATES, NGOS AND DEVELOPMENT 271
I. 1820–57: Philanthropy and the East India Company 275
II. Nationalism, Charity and Constructive Social Work, c. 1890–1947 279
III. 1947–1960: Philanthropy, Development and the Indian State 293
Conclusion 302
Appendix: Some Indian NGOs Connected to Gandhi’s Constructive Programme c. 1915–1948 303
Notes 304
Afterword IMPROVEMENT, PROGRESS AND DEVELOPMENT 317
On the Legitimacy of the Civilizing Mission 317
On the Origins of the Civilizing Mission 320
On the Outcomes of the Civilizing Mission 324
Notes 326
End Matter 329
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS 329
INDEX 331