Menu Expand
Navigating Social Exclusion and Inclusion in Contemporary India and Beyond

Navigating Social Exclusion and Inclusion in Contemporary India and Beyond

Uwe Skoda | Kenneth Bo Nielsen | Marianne Qvortrup Fibiger

(2013)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

‘Navigating Social Exclusion and Inclusion in Contemporary India and Beyond’ contains a collection of lucid, empirically grounded articles that explore and analyse the structures, agents and practices of social inclusion and exclusion in contemporary India and beyond. The volume combines a broad range of approaches to challenge narrow conceptualisations of social inclusion and exclusion in terms of singular factors such as caste, policy or the economy. This collaborative endeavour and cross-disciplinary approach, which brings together younger and more established scholars, facilitates a deeper understanding of complex social and political processes in contemporary India.


‘Navigating Social Exclusion and Inclusion in Contemporary India and Beyond’ examines the applicability of the concept of social exclusion in contemporary India, and addresses the following questions: How does an increasingly liberalised Indian economy contribute to processes of social inclusion and exclusion and to the reproduction of poverty and inequality? To what extent does the deepening of Indian democracy offer hitherto marginalised social groups new opportunities for pursuing strategies of inclusion? And how does ‘development’ alter the social terrain on which inequalities are negotiated? These and related discussions form the focal points of the volume. Importantly, the contributors deal explicitly with the simultaneity of processes of exclusion and inclusion, and with their entangled manifestation in social life. By applying the concept of social exclusion to concrete empirical case studies, the contributors expand conceptual horizons by keeping in mind that neither exclusion nor inclusion can be considered without its ‘alter ego’. The volume also challenges narrow conceptualisations of social inclusion and exclusion in terms of singular factors such as caste, policy or the economy. This collaborative endeavour and cross-disciplinary approach, which brings together younger and more established scholars, facilitates a deeper understanding of complex social and political processes in contemporary India.


‘This book offers rich and revealing empirical analyses of various Indian social relations based on the simple but heuristic concepts of exclusion and inclusion. The inclusion–exclusion dilemmas in social policy and social mobilizations are brought out in powerful ways.’ —Staffan Lindberg, Professor Emeritus of Sociology, Lund University


‘The genesis of the problem of exclusion and inclusion needs to be understood within a broad theoretical and conceptual framework, and with the help of empirical data. The essays in this book deal with this question. They explain with meticulous detail why we need to change our focus from state- and caste-centric discourses to a discourse that takes note of spaces, communities and resources. This volume presents an excellent collection of work.’ —Abhijit Dasgupta, Professor of Sociology, Delhi School of Economics, University of Delhi 


Uwe Skoda is an associate professor of South Asian studies at Aarhus University, Denmark.

Kenneth Bo Nielsen is a research fellow at the Centre for Development and the Environment at the University of Oslo, Norway.

Marianne Qvortrup Fibiger is an associate professor in religious studies at Aarhus University, Denmark. 

Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Navigating Social Exclusion and Inclusion in Contemporary India and Beyond_9780857283221 i
Title iii
Copyright iv
CONTENTS v
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS vii
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS ix
About the Editors ix
Contributors ix
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION: NAVIGATING EXCLUSION, ENGINEERING INCLUSION 1
Social Exclusion: From Concept to Analytical Practice 2
Indian Debates on Exclusion and Inclusion: Foregrounding Caste 3
Navigating and Engineering 5
Spaces and Values 7
Communities and Politics 8
Resources and Development 11
References 13
Part I SPACES AND VALUES 17
Chapter 2 COSMOPOLITANISM OR IATROGENESIS? REFLECTIONS ON RELIGIOUS PLURALITY, CENSORSHIP AND DISCIPLINARY ORIENTATIONS 19
The Indian Penal Code 21
Inclusion and Cosmopolitanism 24
Exclusion and Iatrogenesis 29
Concluding Remarks 34
Acknowledgements 35
Notes 35
References 37
Chapter 3 DEPENDENT HUSBANDS: REFLECTIONS ON MARGINAL MASCULINITIES 41
Marginal Husbands in Cinema 43
Social Structures and Counter Constructions 44
Recouping Lost Masculinity: The Transnational Ghar Jawai 47
Conclusion 50
Notes 51
References 52
Chapter 4 EXCLUSION AND INCLUSION: NAVIGATION STRATEGIES AMONG HINDUS IN THE DIASPORA – A CASE STUDY FROM DENMARK 55
Keeping up Hindu Tradition in a New Setting and under New Circumstances 56
Collective or Cultural Memory: Presumed Core Features that are Kept through Generations 57
Hinduism in the Diaspora 58
The Hindu Diaspora Group in Denmark 60
The Indian Hindus 61
The Sri Lankan Tamil Hindus 63
The Abirami Cult as an Example of Establishing Collective Memory 64
The Avatara Day 65
The Sree Abirami Amman Temple 66
The Textualization of the Local Shakta Cult in Brande 67
Conclusion 67
Notes 68
References 68
Part II COMMUNITIES AND POLITICS 71
Chapter 5 IN SEARCH OF DEVELOPMENT: MUSLIMS AND ELECTORAL POLITICS IN AN INDIAN STATE 73
The Muslim Electorate and the Left Front 75
Marginalized Muslims: The Sachar Committee Report and Beyond 76
Towards the 2011 State Elections: Seeking Development through Quotas 80
Further Policy Initiatives by the LF 84
Rallying behind Mamata at Furfura Sharif 84
TMC’s Campaign to Attract Muslim Voters: Development and Dignity 86
Conclusion: Political Society and the Search for Development 88
Notes 91
References 92
Chapter 6 EXCLUSION AS COMMON DENOMINATOR: INVESTIGATING ‘DALIT-HOOD’ 97
Dalit-hood 99
The Struggle for Education 101
Constructing the ‘Dalit’ and Her Oppressor 103
Inclusion through Affirmative Action? 105
Becoming an Activist 106
Social Exclusion and Activist Legitimacy 110
Conclusion 113
Notes 114
References 115
Chapter 7 INCLUSION OF THE EXCLUDED GROUPS THROUGH PANCHAYATI RAJ: ELECTORAL DEMOCRACY IN UTTAR PRADESH 119
Caste and Democratic Politics in UP 120
History and Structure of the Panchayat in UP 121
Social and Political Structure in Khanpur 122
Factions, Guts and Mohallas 124
Caste Leaders, Caste Associations and Networks 126
The 1999 Village Panchayat Elections 127
Politics of Alliance and Reciprocity 128
Identities of Caste and Religion in Village Politics 128
The Power of Wealth, Muscle and Crime 130
Conclusion: Inclusion of the Excluded Groups 131
Notes 133
References 133
Chapter 8 MAKING SIKKIM MORE INCLUSIVE: AN INSIDER’S VIEW OF THE ROLE OF COMMITTEES AND COMMISSIONS 135
An Ethnographic Context of Sikkim 137
The Sinha Committee 139
The Roy Burman Commission 142
Conclusion 146
Notes 147
References 147
Chapter 9 ENCOUNTERING ‘INCLUSION’ AND EXCLUSION IN POSTINDUSTRIAL MUMBAI: A STUDY OF MUSLIM EX-MILLWORKERS’ OCCUPATIONAL CHOICES 149
Mumbai 150
Muslims and Mumbai’s Textile Industry 153
Expulsion of the Muslim Workforce 154
Muslim Ex-millworkers in Postindustrial Mumbai 156
Encountering Inclusion and Exclusion 158
Conclusion 160
Notes 161
References 162
Part III RESOURCES AND DEVELOPMENT 165
Chapter 10 DAMS, DEVELOPMENT AND THE EXCLUSION OF INDIGENOUS GROUPS: A CASE FROM ODISHA 167
The Concept of ‘Social Exclusion’ and ‘Marginalization’ 168
Exclusion in Relation to Place 169
Objectives 169
Upper Indravati Hydroelectric Project 170
Methodology 171
Indigenous Communities 172
The Project and Its Context 173
Mode of Production, Resource Collection and Utilization 174
Economic Activities and Associated Rituals 175
Impact of Forced Displacement 177
Exclusionary Processes 180
Disruption of Social Network 180
Resistance to the Project 182
Conclusion 183
Notes 185
References 185
Chapter 11 ‘SOLUTIONS EMERGE WHEN EVERYONE WORKS TOGETHER’: EXPERIENCES OF SOCIAL INCLUSION IN WATERSHED MANAGEMENT COMMITTEES IN KARNATAKA 189
Social Exclusion in India Today 190
Inclusion in/through Participatory Development Spaces? 191
Fighting Exclusion through Revolving Fund-Based Watershed Activities: The Case of Allapur 193
Why Was the Intervention Planned? 194
What Was Innovative? 195
The Process Adopted 196
What Happened? 197
Hakkim Sab Mainoordin 198
Rajanan Nagappa Haligen 198
The Water Management Committee 199
What Can This Tell Us about Social Inclusion? 201
Dismantling of caste and class prejudices 201
Local ownership of social change 202
The growth of individualism? 202
Fluctuating spatial power dynamics 203
Notes 204
References 204
Chapter 12 THE DEATH OF SHANKAR: SOCIAL EXCLUSION AND TUBERCULOSIS IN A POOR NEIGHBOURHOOD IN BHUBANESWAR, ODISHA 207
A Note on Methodology 208
Access to Health Care Services in Bhubaneswar, Odisha 208
Beluam Basti 209
Social Divisions in the Basti 211
Culture, Development and Social Exclusion 214
Social In/Exclusion of the Pradhan Community 215
Health-Seeking Patterns in Beluam Basti 216
Shankar’s Trajectory 219
Poor Treatment 220
Alcohol and Medicine 222
Work 222
Ex- and Conclusion 223
Notes 224
References 225