Menu Expand
Torkel Aschehoug and Norwegian Historical Economic Thought

Torkel Aschehoug and Norwegian Historical Economic Thought

Mathilde C. Fasting

(2013)

Additional Information

Book Details

Abstract

The historical schools of economics have been neglected within the arena of economic theory since the Second World War in favour of the now-dominant classical and neoclassical schools of economic thought. As alternative frameworks re-emerge, this book offers a revaluation of the legal theorist, economist and politician Torkel Aschehoug (1822–1909) and his historical-empirical approach to economics, a highly influential current in Norway during the last decades of the nineteenth century.


‘The historical school has received scandalously insufficient attention, even by historians of economic thought. Fasting has done a superb job in bringing the ideas of Torkel Aschehoug to an English-language audience.’ —Professor Geoff Hodgson, University of Hertfordshire


‘With his historical approach to economics, Torkel Aschehoug was a Norwegian pioneer. Today’s interest in connecting economics to a broader understanding of society makes Fasting’s revitalizing study timely indeed.’ —Professor Rune Slagstad, Oslo University College


‘This book should be compulsory reading for historians of economic thought who want to understand the intellectual background for the development of economics in Norway in the nineteenth and the beginning of the twentieth century.’ —Professor Arild Sæther, University of Agder


Mathilde C. Fasting has just finished her doctorate in political science at the University of Erfurt, Germany.


‘Mathilde C. Fasting’s book is a fascinating and highly readable account of the most influential economist in Norwegian intellectual life in the late nineteenth century. Fasting carefully traces and analyses the intellectual impulses behind Aschehoug’s thinking, making this book a valuable contribution.’ —Professor Einar Lie, University of Oslo


The historical schools of economics have been neglected within the arena of economic theory since the Second World War in favour of the now-dominant classical and neoclassical schools of economic thought. ‘Torkel Aschehoug and Norwegian Economic Thought’ offers a revaluation of the historical-empirical approach to economics that the Norwegian legal theorist and politician Aschehoug became renowned for during the last decades of the nineteenth century up to his death in 1909.

Fasting approaches Aschehoug’s economic thought in relation to his Norwegian colleagues, as well as the dominant international economists of the time. This comparison shows a theoretical affiliation with Gustav von Schmoller, in particular, through Aschehoug’s major work ‘Socialøkonomik’, as well as British economist Alfred Marshall’s marginal theory.

Fasting blends a historical account of the dominant economic models of the late 1800s with a review of contemporary theory through recent economic crises. This work argues that Aschehoug’s ‘Socialøkonomik’ is strikingly relevant to a present-day readership, revealing itself as a work which offers real insight into the reasons for economic collapse.  


Table of Contents

Section Title Page Action Price
Torkel Aschehoug and Norwegian Historical Economic Thought_9780857280756 i
Title iii
Copyright iv
CONTENTS v
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS vii
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION 1
Applied Sources 5
Structure and Contents 5
Chapter 2 BIOGRAPHY 11
General Background and Childhood 11
Studies and Travels: European Influences 14
A Brief Outline of His Academic Career 18
Political Context: Aschehoug the Politician 21
Public Assignments and Different Academic and Personal Interests 23
Scientific, Legal and Historical-Statistical Works 24
Chapter 3 NORWEGIAN ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL CONTEXT IN THE NINETEENTH CENTURY 27
The Norwegian Political and Social Context in the Nineteenth Century 27
Nineteenth-Century Economic Development in Norway: A Backward Country Becoming Industrialized 31
Anton Martin Schweigaard: The First Norwegian Economist 35
The German Philosophy: About Method, Not Ontology 40
Schweigaard and His Lectures on Political Economy 43
Schweigaard on Trade and Laissez-Faire: Important Distinctions 46
Chapter 4 NORWEGIAN ECONOMIC THOUGHT AND METHOD 51
Introduction 51
Aschehoug and His Presentation of Method in Socialøkonomik 55
The Norwegian Debate about Method 62
Chapter 5 DEVELOPMENT OF THE ECONOMIC THOUGHT OF ASCHEHOUG: STATSØKONOMISK FORENING AND THE SOCIALØKONOMIK PROJECT 67
Development of Aschehoug’s Economic Thought 67
Statsøkonomisk Forening 69
The Socialøkonomik Project: The Final Paramount Effort 72
Later Revisions by Aarum, the Reception and Use of Socialøkonomik 76
Chapter 6 THE GERMAN HISTORICAL SCHOOL: SIMILARITIES, INFLUENCES AND DISCREPANCIES 79
A Small Presentation of the German Historical School 80
How Aschehoug Describes the German Historical School 87
Gustav von Schmoller: A Presentation of Grundriss 88
Schmoller and Aschehoug: A Comparison 91
Personal background 91
Statistics: An important instrument for historical research 91
The combination of science and policymaking: The core of economics 93
The impact of the Verein für Sozialpolitik: General debates, die soziale Frage, trade policies 97
Conclusion 100
Chapter 7 ALFRED MARSHAL: ASCHEHOUG AND THE ADOPTION OF MARGINAL THEORY 103
The Importance of Principles 103
Marshall and Aschehoug on the Method and Scope of Economics 106
Economics: Theory and Praxis 109
Marginal Theory 112
Other Selected Topics: Entrepreneurs, the Cooperative and Labour 116
Chapter 8 THE FRENCH INFLUENCE: ADOPTING SAY AND REFUTING SOCIALISM 121
Aschehoug and Economics as a Historical Science 121
The Physiocrats, Quesnay and Turgot 123
Positivism and Comte 127
The Ethical School in French Thought 128
The French Liberal School 129
Aschehoug and His Comments on French Socialism 135
Conclusion on French Influence 139
Chapter 9 VIEWS OF LABOUR IN THE WORK OF ASCHEHOUG 141
His Background Shaping His Beliefs and His Ethics 141
About Working Contracts and Salaries 144
Aschehoug and the Arbeiterfrage: Laws and Regulations 146
Workers are Humans and are Subject to Diminishing Returns 149
Conclusion 152
Chapter 10 THE ENTREPRENEUR: THE FOURTH PRODUCTION FACTOR 153
Say and the Entrepreneur 154
Schweigaard Following Say in Norway 155
Aschehoug Adopting and Developing Say’s and Schweigaard’s Theories 156
Conclusion: What Happened after Aschehoug? 162
Chapter 11 TRADE AND CUSTOMS DEBATES FROM 1840 TO 1906 165
Historical Trade Development in Norway: Theory and Reality 166
Foreign Trade Policy Development 169
Norwegian Trade and Customs Debates from 1842 to 1879 171
The 1903 Trade Debate and Lecture at the Statsøkonomisk Forening 173
Conclusion 176
Chapter 12 THE THEORY OF ECONOMIC CRISES 177
Crises: Necessary to Analyse 177
Crises and Psychology 178
Identification of Different Crises 179
Theories of Crises: What Happened after Aschehoug? 182
Chapter 13 THE LEGACY OF ASCHEHOUG: CONCLUDING REMARKS 185
Appendix A OTHER NORWEGIAN TURN-OF-THE CENTURY ECONOMISTS 189
Appendix B DRAFTS FOR SOCIALØKONOMIK 195
Appendix C DETAILED CONTENTS OF SOCIALØKONOMIK (FIRST EDITIONS FROM 1903 TO 1908) 197
Volume I 197
Volume II 198
Volume IIIa 199
Volume IIIb 200
NOTES 201
Chapter 1 Introduction 201
Chapter 2 Biography 201
Chapter 3 Norwegian Economic and Political Context in the Nineteenth Century 204
Chapter 4 Norwegian Economic Thought and Method 212
Chapter 5 Development of the Economic Thought of Aschehoug: Statsøkonomisk Forening and the Socialøkonomik Project 218
Chapter 6 The German Historical School: Similarities, Influences and Discrepancies 221
Chapter 7 Alfred Marshall: Aschehoug and the Adoption of Marginal Theory 226
Chapter 8 The French Influence: Adopting Say and Refuting Socialism 231
Chapter 9 Views of Labour in the Work of Aschehoug 235
Chapter 10 The Entrepreneur: The Fourth Production Factor 239
Chapter 11 Trade and Customs Debates from 1840 to 1906 243
Chapter 12 The Theory of Economic Crises 247
Appendix A Other Norwegian Turn-of-the-Century Economists 249
Appendix C Detailed Contents of Socialøkonomik (First Editions from 1903 to 1908) 251
LITERATURE 253
Works and Documents by Aschehoug Used in This Book 253
Published Works by Aschehoug 253
Articles published in Statsøkonomisk Tidsskrift (Journal of political economy) 254
Comments on articles between 1887 and 1989 255
Letters from Aschehoug (1822–1909) 255
Reviews of Aschehoug (1822–1909) 259
Lectures by Torkel Halvorsen Aschehoug (1822–1909) 259
Primary Sources other than Aschehoug and Secondary Sources 260
INDEX 265